Neuroimaging resolution of the altered state hypothesis

Giuliana Mazzoni, Annalena Venneri, William J. McGeown, Irving Kirsch

Research output: Contribution to journalLiterature review

28 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

A controversy in the field of hypnosis has centered on the question of whether there is a uniquely hypnotic state of consciousness and, if so, whether it is causally related to responsiveness to suggestion. Evidence from brain imaging studies has been used to support claims for various altered state hypotheses, without resolving the debate. The designs of many neuroimaging studies confound the induction of hypnosis with the suggestions that can be given in or out of hypnosis, thus rendering them incapable of resolving the controversy. Brain imaging studies that do not have this confound support the hypothesis that hypnotic inductions produce changes in brain activity, but also indicate that these changes are not required for the experience of hypnotic suggestions or their neural correlates. The data remain equivocal as to whether there is a causal relation between the changes in brain activity produced by hypnotic inductions and those produced by other suggestions. It also remains uncertain whether the changes in activation produced by hypnotic inductions reflect a uniquely hypnotic state as opposed to more mundane processes.

LanguageEnglish
Pages400-410
Number of pages11
JournalCortex
Volume49
Issue number2
Early online date6 Sep 2012
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Feb 2013

Fingerprint

Hypnotics and Sedatives
Neuroimaging
Hypnosis
Suggestion
Brain
Consciousness

Keywords

  • human brain
  • suggestion
  • cortex
  • activation
  • default mode
  • hallucinations
  • hypnosis
  • altered state

Cite this

Mazzoni, Giuliana ; Venneri, Annalena ; McGeown, William J. ; Kirsch, Irving. / Neuroimaging resolution of the altered state hypothesis. In: Cortex. 2013 ; Vol. 49, No. 2. pp. 400-410.
@article{684d97dd2b1a465d85b066fc0b57bbd7,
title = "Neuroimaging resolution of the altered state hypothesis",
abstract = "A controversy in the field of hypnosis has centered on the question of whether there is a uniquely hypnotic state of consciousness and, if so, whether it is causally related to responsiveness to suggestion. Evidence from brain imaging studies has been used to support claims for various altered state hypotheses, without resolving the debate. The designs of many neuroimaging studies confound the induction of hypnosis with the suggestions that can be given in or out of hypnosis, thus rendering them incapable of resolving the controversy. Brain imaging studies that do not have this confound support the hypothesis that hypnotic inductions produce changes in brain activity, but also indicate that these changes are not required for the experience of hypnotic suggestions or their neural correlates. The data remain equivocal as to whether there is a causal relation between the changes in brain activity produced by hypnotic inductions and those produced by other suggestions. It also remains uncertain whether the changes in activation produced by hypnotic inductions reflect a uniquely hypnotic state as opposed to more mundane processes.",
keywords = "human brain, suggestion, cortex, activation, default mode, hallucinations , hypnosis, altered state",
author = "Giuliana Mazzoni and Annalena Venneri and McGeown, {William J.} and Irving Kirsch",
year = "2013",
month = "2",
doi = "10.1016/j.cortex.2012.08.005",
language = "English",
volume = "49",
pages = "400--410",
journal = "Cortex",
issn = "0010-9452",
number = "2",

}

Neuroimaging resolution of the altered state hypothesis. / Mazzoni, Giuliana; Venneri, Annalena; McGeown, William J.; Kirsch, Irving.

In: Cortex, Vol. 49, No. 2, 02.2013, p. 400-410.

Research output: Contribution to journalLiterature review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Neuroimaging resolution of the altered state hypothesis

AU - Mazzoni, Giuliana

AU - Venneri, Annalena

AU - McGeown, William J.

AU - Kirsch, Irving

PY - 2013/2

Y1 - 2013/2

N2 - A controversy in the field of hypnosis has centered on the question of whether there is a uniquely hypnotic state of consciousness and, if so, whether it is causally related to responsiveness to suggestion. Evidence from brain imaging studies has been used to support claims for various altered state hypotheses, without resolving the debate. The designs of many neuroimaging studies confound the induction of hypnosis with the suggestions that can be given in or out of hypnosis, thus rendering them incapable of resolving the controversy. Brain imaging studies that do not have this confound support the hypothesis that hypnotic inductions produce changes in brain activity, but also indicate that these changes are not required for the experience of hypnotic suggestions or their neural correlates. The data remain equivocal as to whether there is a causal relation between the changes in brain activity produced by hypnotic inductions and those produced by other suggestions. It also remains uncertain whether the changes in activation produced by hypnotic inductions reflect a uniquely hypnotic state as opposed to more mundane processes.

AB - A controversy in the field of hypnosis has centered on the question of whether there is a uniquely hypnotic state of consciousness and, if so, whether it is causally related to responsiveness to suggestion. Evidence from brain imaging studies has been used to support claims for various altered state hypotheses, without resolving the debate. The designs of many neuroimaging studies confound the induction of hypnosis with the suggestions that can be given in or out of hypnosis, thus rendering them incapable of resolving the controversy. Brain imaging studies that do not have this confound support the hypothesis that hypnotic inductions produce changes in brain activity, but also indicate that these changes are not required for the experience of hypnotic suggestions or their neural correlates. The data remain equivocal as to whether there is a causal relation between the changes in brain activity produced by hypnotic inductions and those produced by other suggestions. It also remains uncertain whether the changes in activation produced by hypnotic inductions reflect a uniquely hypnotic state as opposed to more mundane processes.

KW - human brain

KW - suggestion

KW - cortex

KW - activation

KW - default mode

KW - hallucinations

KW - hypnosis

KW - altered state

UR - http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/00109452

U2 - 10.1016/j.cortex.2012.08.005

DO - 10.1016/j.cortex.2012.08.005

M3 - Literature review

VL - 49

SP - 400

EP - 410

JO - Cortex

T2 - Cortex

JF - Cortex

SN - 0010-9452

IS - 2

ER -