Modelling the potential impacts of locational versus system-wide strike prices in contracts for difference for low carbon generation

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

This paper describes the use of a cost - minimisation algorithm to explore the potential impact of two options for financial support for low carbon generation in the form of contracts for difference in a system with locational marginal pricing: 1. with a system-wide strike price; 2. with locational strike prices. A two zone system is modelled with the additional financial support for low carbon generation represented as negative variable costs that have the effect of filling in the difference between wholesale market prices and the strike price, the latter intended to cover the long-run costs of low carbon generation. The British case is modelled in which there is a limit to the total top-up expenditure. It is shown that the case of a system-wide strike price can result in less new low carbon generation capacity compared with the case of locational strike prices, due to the increased top-up spend in the lower price zone more rapidly meeting the constraint on the total cost of top-up payments to low carbon generation. However, it is also shown that the imposition of this constraint leads to a failure of the model to settle on one solution due to the non-convex relationship between installed capacity of low carbon generation and wholesale market price.

Conference

Conference14th International Conference on the European Energy Market
Abbreviated titleEEM 17
CountryGermany
CityDresden
Period6/06/179/06/17

Fingerprint

Carbon
Costs

Keywords

  • power system modelling
  • investment planning
  • cost-minimisation
  • zonal pricing
  • low carbon subsides

Cite this

Pennock, S., Gill, S., & Bell, K. (Accepted/In press). Modelling the potential impacts of locational versus system-wide strike prices in contracts for difference for low carbon generation. Paper presented at 14th International Conference on the European Energy Market, Dresden, Germany.
Pennock, Shona ; Gill, Simon ; Bell, Keith. / Modelling the potential impacts of locational versus system-wide strike prices in contracts for difference for low carbon generation. Paper presented at 14th International Conference on the European Energy Market, Dresden, Germany.6 p.
@conference{ce3c6cc99a6a4b4cad0d7d3f0b16764d,
title = "Modelling the potential impacts of locational versus system-wide strike prices in contracts for difference for low carbon generation",
abstract = "This paper describes the use of a cost - minimisation algorithm to explore the potential impact of two options for financial support for low carbon generation in the form of contracts for difference in a system with locational marginal pricing: 1. with a system-wide strike price; 2. with locational strike prices. A two zone system is modelled with the additional financial support for low carbon generation represented as negative variable costs that have the effect of filling in the difference between wholesale market prices and the strike price, the latter intended to cover the long-run costs of low carbon generation. The British case is modelled in which there is a limit to the total top-up expenditure. It is shown that the case of a system-wide strike price can result in less new low carbon generation capacity compared with the case of locational strike prices, due to the increased top-up spend in the lower price zone more rapidly meeting the constraint on the total cost of top-up payments to low carbon generation. However, it is also shown that the imposition of this constraint leads to a failure of the model to settle on one solution due to the non-convex relationship between installed capacity of low carbon generation and wholesale market price.",
keywords = "power system modelling, investment planning, cost-minimisation, zonal pricing, low carbon subsides",
author = "Shona Pennock and Simon Gill and Keith Bell",
year = "2017",
month = "4",
day = "28",
language = "English",
note = "14th International Conference on the European Energy Market, EEM 17 ; Conference date: 06-06-2017 Through 09-06-2017",

}

Pennock, S, Gill, S & Bell, K 2017, 'Modelling the potential impacts of locational versus system-wide strike prices in contracts for difference for low carbon generation' Paper presented at 14th International Conference on the European Energy Market, Dresden, Germany, 6/06/17 - 9/06/17, .

Modelling the potential impacts of locational versus system-wide strike prices in contracts for difference for low carbon generation. / Pennock, Shona; Gill, Simon; Bell, Keith.

2017. Paper presented at 14th International Conference on the European Energy Market, Dresden, Germany.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - Modelling the potential impacts of locational versus system-wide strike prices in contracts for difference for low carbon generation

AU - Pennock, Shona

AU - Gill, Simon

AU - Bell, Keith

PY - 2017/4/28

Y1 - 2017/4/28

N2 - This paper describes the use of a cost - minimisation algorithm to explore the potential impact of two options for financial support for low carbon generation in the form of contracts for difference in a system with locational marginal pricing: 1. with a system-wide strike price; 2. with locational strike prices. A two zone system is modelled with the additional financial support for low carbon generation represented as negative variable costs that have the effect of filling in the difference between wholesale market prices and the strike price, the latter intended to cover the long-run costs of low carbon generation. The British case is modelled in which there is a limit to the total top-up expenditure. It is shown that the case of a system-wide strike price can result in less new low carbon generation capacity compared with the case of locational strike prices, due to the increased top-up spend in the lower price zone more rapidly meeting the constraint on the total cost of top-up payments to low carbon generation. However, it is also shown that the imposition of this constraint leads to a failure of the model to settle on one solution due to the non-convex relationship between installed capacity of low carbon generation and wholesale market price.

AB - This paper describes the use of a cost - minimisation algorithm to explore the potential impact of two options for financial support for low carbon generation in the form of contracts for difference in a system with locational marginal pricing: 1. with a system-wide strike price; 2. with locational strike prices. A two zone system is modelled with the additional financial support for low carbon generation represented as negative variable costs that have the effect of filling in the difference between wholesale market prices and the strike price, the latter intended to cover the long-run costs of low carbon generation. The British case is modelled in which there is a limit to the total top-up expenditure. It is shown that the case of a system-wide strike price can result in less new low carbon generation capacity compared with the case of locational strike prices, due to the increased top-up spend in the lower price zone more rapidly meeting the constraint on the total cost of top-up payments to low carbon generation. However, it is also shown that the imposition of this constraint leads to a failure of the model to settle on one solution due to the non-convex relationship between installed capacity of low carbon generation and wholesale market price.

KW - power system modelling

KW - investment planning

KW - cost-minimisation

KW - zonal pricing

KW - low carbon subsides

UR - http://eem2017.com/

M3 - Paper

ER -

Pennock S, Gill S, Bell K. Modelling the potential impacts of locational versus system-wide strike prices in contracts for difference for low carbon generation. 2017. Paper presented at 14th International Conference on the European Energy Market, Dresden, Germany.