Modelling the population effectiveness of the national seasonal influenza vaccination programme in Scotland: the impact of targeting all individuals aged 65 years and over Flu Vaccination Programme Effectiveness

Stephen Corson, Charles Robertson, Arlene Reynolds, Jim McMenamin

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Background: For the last 17 years, the UK has employed a routine influenza vaccination programme with the aim of reducing the spread of seasonal influenza. In mid-2000, the programme moved from a purely risk-based approach to a risk and age group targeted approach with all those aged 65+ years being included. To date, there has been no assessment of the population effectiveness of this age targeted policy in Scotland.
Objectives: Statistical modelling techniques were used to determine what impact the routine vaccination of those aged 65+ years has had on influenza related morbidity and mortality in Scotland.
Methods: Two Poisson regression models were developed using weekly counts of all-cause mortality, cause specific mortality and emergency hospitalisations for the period 1981 – 2012, one using week-in-year and the other using temperature to capture the seasonal variability in mortality/hospitalisations. These models were used to determine the number of excess deaths/hospitalisations associated with the introduction of the local risk and age-based vaccination programme in 2000.
Results: Routinely vaccinating those aged 65+ years is associated with a reduction in excess allcause mortality, cardiovascular and COPD related mortality and COPD related hospitalisations. Our analysis suggests that using the week-in-year model, on average, 732 (95%CI 66 – 1,398) deaths from all-causes, 248 (95%CI 10 – 486) cardiovascular related deaths, 123 (95%CI 28 – 218) COPD related deaths, and 425 (95%CI 258 – 592) COPD related hospitalisations have been prevented each flu season among the those aged 65+. Similar results were found using the temperature model. There was no evidence to suggest that the change in policy was associated with reductions in influenza/pneumonia related mortality or influenza/cardiovascular related hospitalisations.
Conclusions: Routinely vaccinating those aged 65+ years appears to have reduced influenza related morbidity and mortality in Scotland. With the childhood vaccination programme well underway, these data provide an importance benchmark which can be used to accurately assess the impact of this new seasonal influenza vaccination programme.
LanguageEnglish
JournalInfluenza and Other Respiratory Viruses
Early online date16 Jun 2018
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 16 Jun 2018

Fingerprint

Program Evaluation
Scotland
Human Influenza
Vaccination
Hospitalization
Mortality
Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease
Population
Morbidity
Benchmarking
Temperature
Cause of Death
Pneumonia
Emergencies
Age Groups

Keywords

  • influenza
  • vaccines
  • modelling
  • population

Cite this

@article{8e1ab08d25f741438a4b8ee583d9b7d5,
title = "Modelling the population effectiveness of the national seasonal influenza vaccination programme in Scotland: the impact of targeting all individuals aged 65 years and over Flu Vaccination Programme Effectiveness",
abstract = "Background: For the last 17 years, the UK has employed a routine influenza vaccination programme with the aim of reducing the spread of seasonal influenza. In mid-2000, the programme moved from a purely risk-based approach to a risk and age group targeted approach with all those aged 65+ years being included. To date, there has been no assessment of the population effectiveness of this age targeted policy in Scotland. Objectives: Statistical modelling techniques were used to determine what impact the routine vaccination of those aged 65+ years has had on influenza related morbidity and mortality in Scotland. Methods: Two Poisson regression models were developed using weekly counts of all-cause mortality, cause specific mortality and emergency hospitalisations for the period 1981 – 2012, one using week-in-year and the other using temperature to capture the seasonal variability in mortality/hospitalisations. These models were used to determine the number of excess deaths/hospitalisations associated with the introduction of the local risk and age-based vaccination programme in 2000. Results: Routinely vaccinating those aged 65+ years is associated with a reduction in excess allcause mortality, cardiovascular and COPD related mortality and COPD related hospitalisations. Our analysis suggests that using the week-in-year model, on average, 732 (95{\%}CI 66 – 1,398) deaths from all-causes, 248 (95{\%}CI 10 – 486) cardiovascular related deaths, 123 (95{\%}CI 28 – 218) COPD related deaths, and 425 (95{\%}CI 258 – 592) COPD related hospitalisations have been prevented each flu season among the those aged 65+. Similar results were found using the temperature model. There was no evidence to suggest that the change in policy was associated with reductions in influenza/pneumonia related mortality or influenza/cardiovascular related hospitalisations. Conclusions: Routinely vaccinating those aged 65+ years appears to have reduced influenza related morbidity and mortality in Scotland. With the childhood vaccination programme well underway, these data provide an importance benchmark which can be used to accurately assess the impact of this new seasonal influenza vaccination programme.",
keywords = "influenza, vaccines, modelling, population",
author = "Stephen Corson and Charles Robertson and Arlene Reynolds and Jim McMenamin",
year = "2018",
month = "6",
day = "16",
doi = "10.1111/irv.12583",
language = "English",
journal = "Influenza and Other Respiratory Viruses",
issn = "1750-2640",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Modelling the population effectiveness of the national seasonal influenza vaccination programme in Scotland

T2 - Influenza and Other Respiratory Viruses

AU - Corson, Stephen

AU - Robertson, Charles

AU - Reynolds, Arlene

AU - McMenamin, Jim

PY - 2018/6/16

Y1 - 2018/6/16

N2 - Background: For the last 17 years, the UK has employed a routine influenza vaccination programme with the aim of reducing the spread of seasonal influenza. In mid-2000, the programme moved from a purely risk-based approach to a risk and age group targeted approach with all those aged 65+ years being included. To date, there has been no assessment of the population effectiveness of this age targeted policy in Scotland. Objectives: Statistical modelling techniques were used to determine what impact the routine vaccination of those aged 65+ years has had on influenza related morbidity and mortality in Scotland. Methods: Two Poisson regression models were developed using weekly counts of all-cause mortality, cause specific mortality and emergency hospitalisations for the period 1981 – 2012, one using week-in-year and the other using temperature to capture the seasonal variability in mortality/hospitalisations. These models were used to determine the number of excess deaths/hospitalisations associated with the introduction of the local risk and age-based vaccination programme in 2000. Results: Routinely vaccinating those aged 65+ years is associated with a reduction in excess allcause mortality, cardiovascular and COPD related mortality and COPD related hospitalisations. Our analysis suggests that using the week-in-year model, on average, 732 (95%CI 66 – 1,398) deaths from all-causes, 248 (95%CI 10 – 486) cardiovascular related deaths, 123 (95%CI 28 – 218) COPD related deaths, and 425 (95%CI 258 – 592) COPD related hospitalisations have been prevented each flu season among the those aged 65+. Similar results were found using the temperature model. There was no evidence to suggest that the change in policy was associated with reductions in influenza/pneumonia related mortality or influenza/cardiovascular related hospitalisations. Conclusions: Routinely vaccinating those aged 65+ years appears to have reduced influenza related morbidity and mortality in Scotland. With the childhood vaccination programme well underway, these data provide an importance benchmark which can be used to accurately assess the impact of this new seasonal influenza vaccination programme.

AB - Background: For the last 17 years, the UK has employed a routine influenza vaccination programme with the aim of reducing the spread of seasonal influenza. In mid-2000, the programme moved from a purely risk-based approach to a risk and age group targeted approach with all those aged 65+ years being included. To date, there has been no assessment of the population effectiveness of this age targeted policy in Scotland. Objectives: Statistical modelling techniques were used to determine what impact the routine vaccination of those aged 65+ years has had on influenza related morbidity and mortality in Scotland. Methods: Two Poisson regression models were developed using weekly counts of all-cause mortality, cause specific mortality and emergency hospitalisations for the period 1981 – 2012, one using week-in-year and the other using temperature to capture the seasonal variability in mortality/hospitalisations. These models were used to determine the number of excess deaths/hospitalisations associated with the introduction of the local risk and age-based vaccination programme in 2000. Results: Routinely vaccinating those aged 65+ years is associated with a reduction in excess allcause mortality, cardiovascular and COPD related mortality and COPD related hospitalisations. Our analysis suggests that using the week-in-year model, on average, 732 (95%CI 66 – 1,398) deaths from all-causes, 248 (95%CI 10 – 486) cardiovascular related deaths, 123 (95%CI 28 – 218) COPD related deaths, and 425 (95%CI 258 – 592) COPD related hospitalisations have been prevented each flu season among the those aged 65+. Similar results were found using the temperature model. There was no evidence to suggest that the change in policy was associated with reductions in influenza/pneumonia related mortality or influenza/cardiovascular related hospitalisations. Conclusions: Routinely vaccinating those aged 65+ years appears to have reduced influenza related morbidity and mortality in Scotland. With the childhood vaccination programme well underway, these data provide an importance benchmark which can be used to accurately assess the impact of this new seasonal influenza vaccination programme.

KW - influenza

KW - vaccines

KW - modelling

KW - population

UR - https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/journal/17502659

U2 - 10.1111/irv.12583

DO - 10.1111/irv.12583

M3 - Article

JO - Influenza and Other Respiratory Viruses

JF - Influenza and Other Respiratory Viruses

SN - 1750-2640

ER -