Migratory things on land: property rights and a law of capture

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This article analyses English and Scots law relating to 'migratory things' - ie things which by their own inherent characteristics move to and for across tracts of land - both in terms of what property rights landowners hold in such things and whether the same may be legitimately 'captured' by the actions of others. In reviewing relevant authorities, the article reveals that the law governing this area is opaque and uncertain and displays inconsistencies in approach both within and between different migratory things across the English and Scottish jurisdictions. The analysis suggests that the limitations placed upon rights of ownership in migratory things represents a shot across the bows of general principles of landownership. The article concludes by suggesting that the current state of the law may give rise to a number of practical problems and proposes that there may be a need to reform certain aspects of the law in this area.
LanguageEnglish
Number of pages34
JournalElectronic Journal of Comparative Law
Volume6
Issue number3
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2002

Fingerprint

right of ownership
Law
jurisdiction
reform

Keywords

  • law of capture
  • Scots law
  • property rights
  • running water
  • fugacious minerals
  • hydrocarbons
  • rights of support
  • migratory
  • land

Cite this

@article{124de39a49cf4ae893de521ef340a103,
title = "Migratory things on land: property rights and a law of capture",
abstract = "This article analyses English and Scots law relating to 'migratory things' - ie things which by their own inherent characteristics move to and for across tracts of land - both in terms of what property rights landowners hold in such things and whether the same may be legitimately 'captured' by the actions of others. In reviewing relevant authorities, the article reveals that the law governing this area is opaque and uncertain and displays inconsistencies in approach both within and between different migratory things across the English and Scottish jurisdictions. The analysis suggests that the limitations placed upon rights of ownership in migratory things represents a shot across the bows of general principles of landownership. The article concludes by suggesting that the current state of the law may give rise to a number of practical problems and proposes that there may be a need to reform certain aspects of the law in this area.",
keywords = "law of capture, Scots law, property rights, running water, fugacious minerals, hydrocarbons, rights of support, migratory, land",
author = "Bryan Clark",
year = "2002",
month = "12",
language = "English",
volume = "6",
journal = "Electronic Journal of Comparative Law",
issn = "1387-3091",
number = "3",

}

Migratory things on land : property rights and a law of capture. / Clark, Bryan.

In: Electronic Journal of Comparative Law, Vol. 6, No. 3, 12.2002.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Migratory things on land

T2 - Electronic Journal of Comparative Law

AU - Clark, Bryan

PY - 2002/12

Y1 - 2002/12

N2 - This article analyses English and Scots law relating to 'migratory things' - ie things which by their own inherent characteristics move to and for across tracts of land - both in terms of what property rights landowners hold in such things and whether the same may be legitimately 'captured' by the actions of others. In reviewing relevant authorities, the article reveals that the law governing this area is opaque and uncertain and displays inconsistencies in approach both within and between different migratory things across the English and Scottish jurisdictions. The analysis suggests that the limitations placed upon rights of ownership in migratory things represents a shot across the bows of general principles of landownership. The article concludes by suggesting that the current state of the law may give rise to a number of practical problems and proposes that there may be a need to reform certain aspects of the law in this area.

AB - This article analyses English and Scots law relating to 'migratory things' - ie things which by their own inherent characteristics move to and for across tracts of land - both in terms of what property rights landowners hold in such things and whether the same may be legitimately 'captured' by the actions of others. In reviewing relevant authorities, the article reveals that the law governing this area is opaque and uncertain and displays inconsistencies in approach both within and between different migratory things across the English and Scottish jurisdictions. The analysis suggests that the limitations placed upon rights of ownership in migratory things represents a shot across the bows of general principles of landownership. The article concludes by suggesting that the current state of the law may give rise to a number of practical problems and proposes that there may be a need to reform certain aspects of the law in this area.

KW - law of capture

KW - Scots law

KW - property rights

KW - running water

KW - fugacious minerals

KW - hydrocarbons

KW - rights of support

KW - migratory

KW - land

UR - http://www.ejcl.org/63/art63-3.html

M3 - Article

VL - 6

JO - Electronic Journal of Comparative Law

JF - Electronic Journal of Comparative Law

SN - 1387-3091

IS - 3

ER -