Mediation’s failings in El Salvador and the limits of crusading universalism

K. Howarth, C. Irvine

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

International efforts to ameliorate violent conflict, broadly categorized as peacebuilding, have become indelibly associated with mediation (Webel and Galtung 2007). “Call in the mediators” is a popular cry in times of international crisis.1 Less clear, however, is whether those making such calls have a shared understanding of what mediators actually do and the values they bring in their wake. “Mediation” may seem a simple, even self-evident, concept. Yet a veritable industry has grown up over the last 30 years in training mediators and writing about their work. This article summarizes a recent analysis of five popular mediation texts, each purporting to have universal application and widely used to train mediators throughout the world. We find that although mediation has an ancient pedigree and thrives in diverse societies (see below, p. 10), these books are underpinned by a strong thread of liberal, democratic individualism. We then ask whether this particular values-base is helpful for mediators by considering the peculiar case of a successful mediation with unsuccessful consequences.
LanguageEnglish
Pages358-363
Number of pages6
Journal International Studies Review
Volume13
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2011

Fingerprint

individualism
El Salvador
universalism
train
mediation
industry
self-concept
conflict
society
world
book
analysis
Values

Keywords

  • future
  • terrorism
  • civil war
  • justice
  • El-Salvador
  • society

Cite this

@article{4d67fe7b88a847f1806ff9dcd644c03e,
title = "Mediation’s failings in El Salvador and the limits of crusading universalism",
abstract = "International efforts to ameliorate violent conflict, broadly categorized as peacebuilding, have become indelibly associated with mediation (Webel and Galtung 2007). “Call in the mediators” is a popular cry in times of international crisis.1 Less clear, however, is whether those making such calls have a shared understanding of what mediators actually do and the values they bring in their wake. “Mediation” may seem a simple, even self-evident, concept. Yet a veritable industry has grown up over the last 30 years in training mediators and writing about their work. This article summarizes a recent analysis of five popular mediation texts, each purporting to have universal application and widely used to train mediators throughout the world. We find that although mediation has an ancient pedigree and thrives in diverse societies (see below, p. 10), these books are underpinned by a strong thread of liberal, democratic individualism. We then ask whether this particular values-base is helpful for mediators by considering the peculiar case of a successful mediation with unsuccessful consequences.",
keywords = "future, terrorism, civil war, justice, El-Salvador, society",
author = "K. Howarth and C. Irvine",
year = "2011",
month = "6",
doi = "10.1111/j.1468-2486.2011.01042.x",
language = "English",
volume = "13",
pages = "358--363",
journal = "International Studies Review",
issn = "1521-9488",
number = "2",

}

Mediation’s failings in El Salvador and the limits of crusading universalism. / Howarth, K.; Irvine, C.

In: International Studies Review , Vol. 13, No. 2, 06.2011, p. 358-363.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Mediation’s failings in El Salvador and the limits of crusading universalism

AU - Howarth, K.

AU - Irvine, C.

PY - 2011/6

Y1 - 2011/6

N2 - International efforts to ameliorate violent conflict, broadly categorized as peacebuilding, have become indelibly associated with mediation (Webel and Galtung 2007). “Call in the mediators” is a popular cry in times of international crisis.1 Less clear, however, is whether those making such calls have a shared understanding of what mediators actually do and the values they bring in their wake. “Mediation” may seem a simple, even self-evident, concept. Yet a veritable industry has grown up over the last 30 years in training mediators and writing about their work. This article summarizes a recent analysis of five popular mediation texts, each purporting to have universal application and widely used to train mediators throughout the world. We find that although mediation has an ancient pedigree and thrives in diverse societies (see below, p. 10), these books are underpinned by a strong thread of liberal, democratic individualism. We then ask whether this particular values-base is helpful for mediators by considering the peculiar case of a successful mediation with unsuccessful consequences.

AB - International efforts to ameliorate violent conflict, broadly categorized as peacebuilding, have become indelibly associated with mediation (Webel and Galtung 2007). “Call in the mediators” is a popular cry in times of international crisis.1 Less clear, however, is whether those making such calls have a shared understanding of what mediators actually do and the values they bring in their wake. “Mediation” may seem a simple, even self-evident, concept. Yet a veritable industry has grown up over the last 30 years in training mediators and writing about their work. This article summarizes a recent analysis of five popular mediation texts, each purporting to have universal application and widely used to train mediators throughout the world. We find that although mediation has an ancient pedigree and thrives in diverse societies (see below, p. 10), these books are underpinned by a strong thread of liberal, democratic individualism. We then ask whether this particular values-base is helpful for mediators by considering the peculiar case of a successful mediation with unsuccessful consequences.

KW - future

KW - terrorism

KW - civil war

KW - justice

KW - El-Salvador

KW - society

U2 - 10.1111/j.1468-2486.2011.01042.x

DO - 10.1111/j.1468-2486.2011.01042.x

M3 - Article

VL - 13

SP - 358

EP - 363

JO - International Studies Review

T2 - International Studies Review

JF - International Studies Review

SN - 1521-9488

IS - 2

ER -