Lessons from post occupancy evaluation and monitoring of the 1st Passive House in Scotland

Paul Gerard Tuohy, Gavin Bruce Murphy, Gokay Devici

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

This paper describes an investigation carried out to understand the performance in practice of the first certified Passive House in Scotland and associated low or zero carbon technologies LZCT. The aim was to provide some useful feedbacks on actual performance in order to inform and hopefully improve building industry processes and policy.

Monitoring was carried out on three dwellings on the west coast of Scotland. All dwellings are within 250m of each other with similar orientation and occupancy but were built to different standards representative of: 1950’s Scottish building standards; 2010 Scottish building standards; and Passive House standards. The Passive House included mechanical ventilation with heat recovery (MVHR), air to air heat pump and solar thermal hot water heating LZCT systems which are in general being encouraged for new build and retrofit. The monitoring was carried out over 1 year and included indoor environment (RH, CO2, T), outdoor conditions (Solar, T, RH), energy use (Watts, kWh), operation schedules, and hot water system temperatures (T).

In parallel with the monitoring, the Passive House and associated LZCT were investigated by inspection and observation and by comparison with both the Passive House Planning Package (PHPP) and the recommendations of the Certified Passive House Designer course.

There were many interesting findings from the investigation, these included: lower and more consistent CO2 levels in the Passive House than in the houses without MVHR; poor layout and ducting of MVHR system giving poor energy performance and condensation problems; poor controls and specification of air to air heat pump giving poor space heating performance; poor control of solar thermal hot water system reducing performance; lack of occupant understanding of operation and maintenance for the LZCT systems.

The lessons learned are relevant to all future implementations of these LZCT systems in the building stock both new build and retrofit. Possible improvements in industry and Passive House processes are discussed.
LanguageEnglish
Number of pages8
Publication statusPublished - 22 Oct 2012
EventPassivhus Norden Conference - Trondheim, Norway
Duration: 22 Oct 201223 Oct 2012

Conference

ConferencePassivhus Norden Conference
CountryNorway
CityTrondheim
Period22/10/1223/10/12

Fingerprint

Monitoring
Waste heat utilization
Air
Hot water heating
Pumps
Space heating
Coastal zones
Water
Condensation
Industry
Inspection
Specifications
Feedback
Planning
Carbon
Hot Temperature
Artificial Respiration
Temperature

Keywords

  • passive house technology
  • building energy management systems
  • building and structure
  • low or zero carbon technology
  • solar domestic hot water systems
  • mechanical ventilation and heat recovery

Cite this

Tuohy, P. G., Murphy, G. B., & Devici, G. (2012). Lessons from post occupancy evaluation and monitoring of the 1st Passive House in Scotland. Paper presented at Passivhus Norden Conference, Trondheim, Norway.
Tuohy, Paul Gerard ; Murphy, Gavin Bruce ; Devici, Gokay. / Lessons from post occupancy evaluation and monitoring of the 1st Passive House in Scotland. Paper presented at Passivhus Norden Conference, Trondheim, Norway.8 p.
@conference{c7b3eac7f11b4d8ea1b2e65db391cfbf,
title = "Lessons from post occupancy evaluation and monitoring of the 1st Passive House in Scotland",
abstract = "This paper describes an investigation carried out to understand the performance in practice of the first certified Passive House in Scotland and associated low or zero carbon technologies LZCT. The aim was to provide some useful feedbacks on actual performance in order to inform and hopefully improve building industry processes and policy. Monitoring was carried out on three dwellings on the west coast of Scotland. All dwellings are within 250m of each other with similar orientation and occupancy but were built to different standards representative of: 1950’s Scottish building standards; 2010 Scottish building standards; and Passive House standards. The Passive House included mechanical ventilation with heat recovery (MVHR), air to air heat pump and solar thermal hot water heating LZCT systems which are in general being encouraged for new build and retrofit. The monitoring was carried out over 1 year and included indoor environment (RH, CO2, T), outdoor conditions (Solar, T, RH), energy use (Watts, kWh), operation schedules, and hot water system temperatures (T). In parallel with the monitoring, the Passive House and associated LZCT were investigated by inspection and observation and by comparison with both the Passive House Planning Package (PHPP) and the recommendations of the Certified Passive House Designer course. There were many interesting findings from the investigation, these included: lower and more consistent CO2 levels in the Passive House than in the houses without MVHR; poor layout and ducting of MVHR system giving poor energy performance and condensation problems; poor controls and specification of air to air heat pump giving poor space heating performance; poor control of solar thermal hot water system reducing performance; lack of occupant understanding of operation and maintenance for the LZCT systems. The lessons learned are relevant to all future implementations of these LZCT systems in the building stock both new build and retrofit. Possible improvements in industry and Passive House processes are discussed.",
keywords = "passive house technology, building energy management systems, building and structure, low or zero carbon technology, solar domestic hot water systems, mechanical ventilation and heat recovery",
author = "Tuohy, {Paul Gerard} and Murphy, {Gavin Bruce} and Gokay Devici",
year = "2012",
month = "10",
day = "22",
language = "English",
note = "Passivhus Norden Conference ; Conference date: 22-10-2012 Through 23-10-2012",

}

Tuohy, PG, Murphy, GB & Devici, G 2012, 'Lessons from post occupancy evaluation and monitoring of the 1st Passive House in Scotland' Paper presented at Passivhus Norden Conference, Trondheim, Norway, 22/10/12 - 23/10/12, .

Lessons from post occupancy evaluation and monitoring of the 1st Passive House in Scotland. / Tuohy, Paul Gerard; Murphy, Gavin Bruce; Devici, Gokay.

2012. Paper presented at Passivhus Norden Conference, Trondheim, Norway.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - Lessons from post occupancy evaluation and monitoring of the 1st Passive House in Scotland

AU - Tuohy, Paul Gerard

AU - Murphy, Gavin Bruce

AU - Devici, Gokay

PY - 2012/10/22

Y1 - 2012/10/22

N2 - This paper describes an investigation carried out to understand the performance in practice of the first certified Passive House in Scotland and associated low or zero carbon technologies LZCT. The aim was to provide some useful feedbacks on actual performance in order to inform and hopefully improve building industry processes and policy. Monitoring was carried out on three dwellings on the west coast of Scotland. All dwellings are within 250m of each other with similar orientation and occupancy but were built to different standards representative of: 1950’s Scottish building standards; 2010 Scottish building standards; and Passive House standards. The Passive House included mechanical ventilation with heat recovery (MVHR), air to air heat pump and solar thermal hot water heating LZCT systems which are in general being encouraged for new build and retrofit. The monitoring was carried out over 1 year and included indoor environment (RH, CO2, T), outdoor conditions (Solar, T, RH), energy use (Watts, kWh), operation schedules, and hot water system temperatures (T). In parallel with the monitoring, the Passive House and associated LZCT were investigated by inspection and observation and by comparison with both the Passive House Planning Package (PHPP) and the recommendations of the Certified Passive House Designer course. There were many interesting findings from the investigation, these included: lower and more consistent CO2 levels in the Passive House than in the houses without MVHR; poor layout and ducting of MVHR system giving poor energy performance and condensation problems; poor controls and specification of air to air heat pump giving poor space heating performance; poor control of solar thermal hot water system reducing performance; lack of occupant understanding of operation and maintenance for the LZCT systems. The lessons learned are relevant to all future implementations of these LZCT systems in the building stock both new build and retrofit. Possible improvements in industry and Passive House processes are discussed.

AB - This paper describes an investigation carried out to understand the performance in practice of the first certified Passive House in Scotland and associated low or zero carbon technologies LZCT. The aim was to provide some useful feedbacks on actual performance in order to inform and hopefully improve building industry processes and policy. Monitoring was carried out on three dwellings on the west coast of Scotland. All dwellings are within 250m of each other with similar orientation and occupancy but were built to different standards representative of: 1950’s Scottish building standards; 2010 Scottish building standards; and Passive House standards. The Passive House included mechanical ventilation with heat recovery (MVHR), air to air heat pump and solar thermal hot water heating LZCT systems which are in general being encouraged for new build and retrofit. The monitoring was carried out over 1 year and included indoor environment (RH, CO2, T), outdoor conditions (Solar, T, RH), energy use (Watts, kWh), operation schedules, and hot water system temperatures (T). In parallel with the monitoring, the Passive House and associated LZCT were investigated by inspection and observation and by comparison with both the Passive House Planning Package (PHPP) and the recommendations of the Certified Passive House Designer course. There were many interesting findings from the investigation, these included: lower and more consistent CO2 levels in the Passive House than in the houses without MVHR; poor layout and ducting of MVHR system giving poor energy performance and condensation problems; poor controls and specification of air to air heat pump giving poor space heating performance; poor control of solar thermal hot water system reducing performance; lack of occupant understanding of operation and maintenance for the LZCT systems. The lessons learned are relevant to all future implementations of these LZCT systems in the building stock both new build and retrofit. Possible improvements in industry and Passive House processes are discussed.

KW - passive house technology

KW - building energy management systems

KW - building and structure

KW - low or zero carbon technology

KW - solar domestic hot water systems

KW - mechanical ventilation and heat recovery

UR - http://www.husbanken.no/english/phn12-nordic-passive-house-conference-2012/

M3 - Paper

ER -

Tuohy PG, Murphy GB, Devici G. Lessons from post occupancy evaluation and monitoring of the 1st Passive House in Scotland. 2012. Paper presented at Passivhus Norden Conference, Trondheim, Norway.