Journal quality grading: a critical appraisal

P.A. Lynch, E. Blaxter

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

    Abstract

    A critical examination is undertaken of United Kingdom journal ranking lists in business and management in relation to 'peripheral' industry-facing subjects using hospitality and tourism as an exemplar, with particular focus upon methodological and social construction processes. The paper adds to limited critical literature by contributing to recognising the power structures and contested nature of power underlying list creation. Lists contribute to discourse construction in the workplace and the wider academic community bringing many organisational and managerial benefits. However, a Bourdieuian analysis suggests they also reflect symbolic violence, bad faith, and raises questions of transparency, integrity and ethics, as well as generating criticisms in respect of their reliability and validity. Theoretical issues are debated and practical recommendations are made in order to raise the standards of list construction.

    Conference

    ConferenceBritish Academy of Management Conference
    CountryUnited Kingdom
    CitySheffield
    Period14/09/1016/09/10

    Fingerprint

    grading
    symbolic violence
    social construction
    transparency
    faith
    integrity
    ranking
    criticism
    workplace
    Tourism
    moral philosophy
    examination
    industry
    discourse
    management
    community
    literature

    Keywords

    • journal quality grading
    • critical
    • Bourdieu
    • power
    • higher education

    Cite this

    Lynch, P. A., & Blaxter, E. (2010). Journal quality grading: a critical appraisal. Paper presented at British Academy of Management Conference, Sheffield, United Kingdom.
    Lynch, P.A. ; Blaxter, E. / Journal quality grading: a critical appraisal. Paper presented at British Academy of Management Conference, Sheffield, United Kingdom.
    @conference{437de1e78bb94d909ede706ea5ea4404,
    title = "Journal quality grading: a critical appraisal",
    abstract = "A critical examination is undertaken of United Kingdom journal ranking lists in business and management in relation to 'peripheral' industry-facing subjects using hospitality and tourism as an exemplar, with particular focus upon methodological and social construction processes. The paper adds to limited critical literature by contributing to recognising the power structures and contested nature of power underlying list creation. Lists contribute to discourse construction in the workplace and the wider academic community bringing many organisational and managerial benefits. However, a Bourdieuian analysis suggests they also reflect symbolic violence, bad faith, and raises questions of transparency, integrity and ethics, as well as generating criticisms in respect of their reliability and validity. Theoretical issues are debated and practical recommendations are made in order to raise the standards of list construction.",
    keywords = "journal quality grading, critical, Bourdieu, power, higher education",
    author = "P.A. Lynch and E. Blaxter",
    year = "2010",
    month = "9",
    day = "15",
    language = "English",
    note = "British Academy of Management Conference ; Conference date: 14-09-2010 Through 16-09-2010",

    }

    Lynch, PA & Blaxter, E 2010, 'Journal quality grading: a critical appraisal' Paper presented at British Academy of Management Conference, Sheffield, United Kingdom, 14/09/10 - 16/09/10, .

    Journal quality grading: a critical appraisal. / Lynch, P.A.; Blaxter, E.

    2010. Paper presented at British Academy of Management Conference, Sheffield, United Kingdom.

    Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

    TY - CONF

    T1 - Journal quality grading: a critical appraisal

    AU - Lynch, P.A.

    AU - Blaxter, E.

    PY - 2010/9/15

    Y1 - 2010/9/15

    N2 - A critical examination is undertaken of United Kingdom journal ranking lists in business and management in relation to 'peripheral' industry-facing subjects using hospitality and tourism as an exemplar, with particular focus upon methodological and social construction processes. The paper adds to limited critical literature by contributing to recognising the power structures and contested nature of power underlying list creation. Lists contribute to discourse construction in the workplace and the wider academic community bringing many organisational and managerial benefits. However, a Bourdieuian analysis suggests they also reflect symbolic violence, bad faith, and raises questions of transparency, integrity and ethics, as well as generating criticisms in respect of their reliability and validity. Theoretical issues are debated and practical recommendations are made in order to raise the standards of list construction.

    AB - A critical examination is undertaken of United Kingdom journal ranking lists in business and management in relation to 'peripheral' industry-facing subjects using hospitality and tourism as an exemplar, with particular focus upon methodological and social construction processes. The paper adds to limited critical literature by contributing to recognising the power structures and contested nature of power underlying list creation. Lists contribute to discourse construction in the workplace and the wider academic community bringing many organisational and managerial benefits. However, a Bourdieuian analysis suggests they also reflect symbolic violence, bad faith, and raises questions of transparency, integrity and ethics, as well as generating criticisms in respect of their reliability and validity. Theoretical issues are debated and practical recommendations are made in order to raise the standards of list construction.

    KW - journal quality grading

    KW - critical

    KW - Bourdieu

    KW - power

    KW - higher education

    UR - http://www.bam.ac.uk/uploadedfiles/BAM_2010_Programme.pdf

    M3 - Paper

    ER -

    Lynch PA, Blaxter E. Journal quality grading: a critical appraisal. 2010. Paper presented at British Academy of Management Conference, Sheffield, United Kingdom.