James Hutton’s geological tours of Scotland: romanticism, literary strategies, and the scientific quest

Thomas Furniss

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This article explores a somewhat neglected part of the story of the emergence of geology as a science and discourse in the late eighteenth century – James Hutton’s posthumously published accounts of the geological tours of Scotland that he undertook in the years 1785 to 1788 in search of empirical evidence in support of his theory of the Earth and that he intended to include in the projected third volume of his Theory of the Earth of 1795. The article brings some of the assumptions and techniques of literary criticism to bear on Hutton’s scientific travel writing in order to open up new connections between geology, Romantic aesthetics and eighteenth-century travel writing about Scotland. Close analysis of Hutton’s accounts of his field trips to Glen Tilt, Galloway and Arran, supplemented by later accounts of the discoveries at Jedburgh and Siccar Point, reveals the interplay between desire, travel and the scientific quest and foregrounds the textual strategies that Hutton uses to persuade his readers that they share in the experience of geological discovery and interpretation as ‘virtual witnesses’. As well as allowing us to revisit the interrelation between scientific theory and discovery, this article concludes that Hutton was a much better writer than he has been given credit for and suggests that if these geological tours had been published in 1795 they would have made it impossible for critics to dismiss him as an armchair geologist.
LanguageEnglish
Pagesn/a
Number of pages24
JournalScience and Education
Volumen/a
Issue numbern/a
Early online date8 May 2012
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2013

Fingerprint

Romanticism
travel
eighteenth century
literary criticism
witness
critic
credit
aesthetics
writer
interpretation
discourse
science
evidence
Geology
Travel Writing
Scotland
experience
Empirical Evidence
Aesthetics
Discourse

Keywords

  • literature
  • science
  • romanticism
  • geological tour
  • Scotland

Cite this

@article{1ce9cbd84bf24651a96dac0927ee13f6,
title = "James Hutton’s geological tours of Scotland: romanticism, literary strategies, and the scientific quest",
abstract = "This article explores a somewhat neglected part of the story of the emergence of geology as a science and discourse in the late eighteenth century – James Hutton’s posthumously published accounts of the geological tours of Scotland that he undertook in the years 1785 to 1788 in search of empirical evidence in support of his theory of the Earth and that he intended to include in the projected third volume of his Theory of the Earth of 1795. The article brings some of the assumptions and techniques of literary criticism to bear on Hutton’s scientific travel writing in order to open up new connections between geology, Romantic aesthetics and eighteenth-century travel writing about Scotland. Close analysis of Hutton’s accounts of his field trips to Glen Tilt, Galloway and Arran, supplemented by later accounts of the discoveries at Jedburgh and Siccar Point, reveals the interplay between desire, travel and the scientific quest and foregrounds the textual strategies that Hutton uses to persuade his readers that they share in the experience of geological discovery and interpretation as ‘virtual witnesses’. As well as allowing us to revisit the interrelation between scientific theory and discovery, this article concludes that Hutton was a much better writer than he has been given credit for and suggests that if these geological tours had been published in 1795 they would have made it impossible for critics to dismiss him as an armchair geologist.",
keywords = "literature, science, romanticism, geological tour, Scotland",
author = "Thomas Furniss",
year = "2013",
doi = "10.1007/s11191-012-9464-6",
language = "English",
volume = "n/a",
pages = "n/a",
journal = "Science and Education",
issn = "0926-7220",
number = "n/a",

}

James Hutton’s geological tours of Scotland : romanticism, literary strategies, and the scientific quest. / Furniss, Thomas.

In: Science and Education, Vol. n/a, No. n/a, 2013, p. n/a.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - James Hutton’s geological tours of Scotland

T2 - Science and Education

AU - Furniss, Thomas

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - This article explores a somewhat neglected part of the story of the emergence of geology as a science and discourse in the late eighteenth century – James Hutton’s posthumously published accounts of the geological tours of Scotland that he undertook in the years 1785 to 1788 in search of empirical evidence in support of his theory of the Earth and that he intended to include in the projected third volume of his Theory of the Earth of 1795. The article brings some of the assumptions and techniques of literary criticism to bear on Hutton’s scientific travel writing in order to open up new connections between geology, Romantic aesthetics and eighteenth-century travel writing about Scotland. Close analysis of Hutton’s accounts of his field trips to Glen Tilt, Galloway and Arran, supplemented by later accounts of the discoveries at Jedburgh and Siccar Point, reveals the interplay between desire, travel and the scientific quest and foregrounds the textual strategies that Hutton uses to persuade his readers that they share in the experience of geological discovery and interpretation as ‘virtual witnesses’. As well as allowing us to revisit the interrelation between scientific theory and discovery, this article concludes that Hutton was a much better writer than he has been given credit for and suggests that if these geological tours had been published in 1795 they would have made it impossible for critics to dismiss him as an armchair geologist.

AB - This article explores a somewhat neglected part of the story of the emergence of geology as a science and discourse in the late eighteenth century – James Hutton’s posthumously published accounts of the geological tours of Scotland that he undertook in the years 1785 to 1788 in search of empirical evidence in support of his theory of the Earth and that he intended to include in the projected third volume of his Theory of the Earth of 1795. The article brings some of the assumptions and techniques of literary criticism to bear on Hutton’s scientific travel writing in order to open up new connections between geology, Romantic aesthetics and eighteenth-century travel writing about Scotland. Close analysis of Hutton’s accounts of his field trips to Glen Tilt, Galloway and Arran, supplemented by later accounts of the discoveries at Jedburgh and Siccar Point, reveals the interplay between desire, travel and the scientific quest and foregrounds the textual strategies that Hutton uses to persuade his readers that they share in the experience of geological discovery and interpretation as ‘virtual witnesses’. As well as allowing us to revisit the interrelation between scientific theory and discovery, this article concludes that Hutton was a much better writer than he has been given credit for and suggests that if these geological tours had been published in 1795 they would have made it impossible for critics to dismiss him as an armchair geologist.

KW - literature

KW - science

KW - romanticism

KW - geological tour

KW - Scotland

UR - http://www.springerlink.com/content/p40550227v601478/?MUD=MP

U2 - 10.1007/s11191-012-9464-6

DO - 10.1007/s11191-012-9464-6

M3 - Article

VL - n/a

SP - n/a

JO - Science and Education

JF - Science and Education

SN - 0926-7220

IS - n/a

ER -