It's (im)Material: Gender, Work and Emotion

Sharon C. Bolton

    Research output: Contribution to conferenceKeynote

    Abstract

    The subject of emotion in organisations is now well established and widely debated. However, having spent the past twenty five years developing the debate on emotions at work we now seem to have become trapped in never ending circular arguments concerning what is or is not 'emotional labour'. Of course, since Hochschild's seminal contribution concerning the commodification of our emotion work, the debate has raged on with many paths in and out of it focusing on a range of issues from prescriptions for its management to concerns with identity appropriation. One of the latest contributions comes from the Italian neo-Marxist school - Lazeretto, Hardt and Negri - and their notion of immaterial labour which focuses on creative and intellectual labour. A subset of that is affective labour which 'involves the production and manipulation of affect' and includes 'service with a smile', 'care labour', and 'kin work'. In combining different forms of emotion work, paid and unpaid forms of affective labour are conflated into one category of immaterial labour. In doing so the labour of emotional labour is now barely acknowledged. It is suggested that there are some tragic consequences of looking at emotion work through the lens of immaterial (affective) labour as, quite simply, it misses its materiality, i.e. that it is hard and productive work, devalued and unrewarded due to its links with the domestic sphere. In Celia Davies' terms, immaterial labour represents a 'masculine cultural project' in the way it downgrades emotion work as immaterial, unproductive, unskilled and outside of the labour process.
    LanguageEnglish
    Publication statusUnpublished - 2 Dec 2008
    EventUniversity of Sydney - Sydney, Australia
    Duration: 2 Dec 2008 → …

    Conference

    ConferenceUniversity of Sydney
    CitySydney, Australia
    Period2/12/08 → …

    Fingerprint

    Labor
    Emotion
    Emotion Work
    Affective
    Immaterial Labour
    Immaterial
    Emotional Labour
    Negri
    Materiality
    Commodification
    Masculine
    Manipulation
    Appropriation
    Prescription
    Downgrade

    Keywords

    • gender
    • work
    • emotion
    • organisations
    • immaterial
    • material
    • sydney
    • 2008

    Cite this

    Bolton, S. C. (2008). It's (im)Material: Gender, Work and Emotion. University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia, .
    Bolton, Sharon C. / It's (im)Material: Gender, Work and Emotion. University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia, .
    @conference{c64630e7d0664eb3b31e17403d7316b9,
    title = "It's (im)Material: Gender, Work and Emotion",
    abstract = "The subject of emotion in organisations is now well established and widely debated. However, having spent the past twenty five years developing the debate on emotions at work we now seem to have become trapped in never ending circular arguments concerning what is or is not 'emotional labour'. Of course, since Hochschild's seminal contribution concerning the commodification of our emotion work, the debate has raged on with many paths in and out of it focusing on a range of issues from prescriptions for its management to concerns with identity appropriation. One of the latest contributions comes from the Italian neo-Marxist school - Lazeretto, Hardt and Negri - and their notion of immaterial labour which focuses on creative and intellectual labour. A subset of that is affective labour which 'involves the production and manipulation of affect' and includes 'service with a smile', 'care labour', and 'kin work'. In combining different forms of emotion work, paid and unpaid forms of affective labour are conflated into one category of immaterial labour. In doing so the labour of emotional labour is now barely acknowledged. It is suggested that there are some tragic consequences of looking at emotion work through the lens of immaterial (affective) labour as, quite simply, it misses its materiality, i.e. that it is hard and productive work, devalued and unrewarded due to its links with the domestic sphere. In Celia Davies' terms, immaterial labour represents a 'masculine cultural project' in the way it downgrades emotion work as immaterial, unproductive, unskilled and outside of the labour process.",
    keywords = "gender, work, emotion, organisations, immaterial, material, sydney, 2008",
    author = "Bolton, {Sharon C.}",
    year = "2008",
    month = "12",
    day = "2",
    language = "English",
    note = "University of Sydney ; Conference date: 02-12-2008",

    }

    Bolton, SC 2008, 'It's (im)Material: Gender, Work and Emotion' University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia, 2/12/08, .

    It's (im)Material: Gender, Work and Emotion. / Bolton, Sharon C.

    2008. University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia, .

    Research output: Contribution to conferenceKeynote

    TY - CONF

    T1 - It's (im)Material: Gender, Work and Emotion

    AU - Bolton, Sharon C.

    PY - 2008/12/2

    Y1 - 2008/12/2

    N2 - The subject of emotion in organisations is now well established and widely debated. However, having spent the past twenty five years developing the debate on emotions at work we now seem to have become trapped in never ending circular arguments concerning what is or is not 'emotional labour'. Of course, since Hochschild's seminal contribution concerning the commodification of our emotion work, the debate has raged on with many paths in and out of it focusing on a range of issues from prescriptions for its management to concerns with identity appropriation. One of the latest contributions comes from the Italian neo-Marxist school - Lazeretto, Hardt and Negri - and their notion of immaterial labour which focuses on creative and intellectual labour. A subset of that is affective labour which 'involves the production and manipulation of affect' and includes 'service with a smile', 'care labour', and 'kin work'. In combining different forms of emotion work, paid and unpaid forms of affective labour are conflated into one category of immaterial labour. In doing so the labour of emotional labour is now barely acknowledged. It is suggested that there are some tragic consequences of looking at emotion work through the lens of immaterial (affective) labour as, quite simply, it misses its materiality, i.e. that it is hard and productive work, devalued and unrewarded due to its links with the domestic sphere. In Celia Davies' terms, immaterial labour represents a 'masculine cultural project' in the way it downgrades emotion work as immaterial, unproductive, unskilled and outside of the labour process.

    AB - The subject of emotion in organisations is now well established and widely debated. However, having spent the past twenty five years developing the debate on emotions at work we now seem to have become trapped in never ending circular arguments concerning what is or is not 'emotional labour'. Of course, since Hochschild's seminal contribution concerning the commodification of our emotion work, the debate has raged on with many paths in and out of it focusing on a range of issues from prescriptions for its management to concerns with identity appropriation. One of the latest contributions comes from the Italian neo-Marxist school - Lazeretto, Hardt and Negri - and their notion of immaterial labour which focuses on creative and intellectual labour. A subset of that is affective labour which 'involves the production and manipulation of affect' and includes 'service with a smile', 'care labour', and 'kin work'. In combining different forms of emotion work, paid and unpaid forms of affective labour are conflated into one category of immaterial labour. In doing so the labour of emotional labour is now barely acknowledged. It is suggested that there are some tragic consequences of looking at emotion work through the lens of immaterial (affective) labour as, quite simply, it misses its materiality, i.e. that it is hard and productive work, devalued and unrewarded due to its links with the domestic sphere. In Celia Davies' terms, immaterial labour represents a 'masculine cultural project' in the way it downgrades emotion work as immaterial, unproductive, unskilled and outside of the labour process.

    KW - gender

    KW - work

    KW - emotion

    KW - organisations

    KW - immaterial

    KW - material

    KW - sydney

    KW - 2008

    UR - http://www.econ.usyd.edu.au/work_organisational_studies/research/2008_seminars

    M3 - Keynote

    ER -

    Bolton SC. It's (im)Material: Gender, Work and Emotion. 2008. University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia, .