Intimate labour and the state: contrasting policy discourses with the working experiences of indoor sex workers

Jane Pitcher

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

Drawing on an interview-based study with indoor-based sex workers of different genders in Great Britain, this paper explores the disparity between dominant policy representations of sex workers and the working lives of people selling intimate services. I argue certain policy discourses reinforce narratives of vulnerability and coercion when discussing female sex workers and responses to perceived ‘problems’ of prostitution and neglect the needs of male and transgender sex workers. I contrast messages in policy discourses with the experiences of sex workers across indoor sectors. My study found considerable diversity in working experiences, influenced by factors such as work setting, personal circumstances and aspirations. While some people may view sex work as a short-term option, for others it represents a longer-term career. For some, sex work may offer greater job satisfaction and control over working conditions than other jobs available. Nonetheless, external constraints sometimes make it difficult for them to work safely. I argue state discourses fail to reflect the diverse experiences of sex workers and undermine their agency, perpetuating disrespect and excluding them from human and labour rights. I suggest the need to consider policy approaches shaped according to varied circumstances and settings, drawing on the expertise of sex workers.
LanguageEnglish
Number of pages13
JournalSexuality Research and Social Policy
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 2 Mar 2018

Fingerprint

labor
worker
discourse
experience
policy approach
working life
prostitution
working conditions
job satisfaction
selling
neglect
vulnerability
expertise
career
narrative
gender
interview

Keywords

  • sex work
  • prostitution
  • labour relations
  • policy
  • stigma
  • recognition
  • diversity

Cite this

@article{408032ed08ce49b29f4e76bdb18304df,
title = "Intimate labour and the state: contrasting policy discourses with the working experiences of indoor sex workers",
abstract = "Drawing on an interview-based study with indoor-based sex workers of different genders in Great Britain, this paper explores the disparity between dominant policy representations of sex workers and the working lives of people selling intimate services. I argue certain policy discourses reinforce narratives of vulnerability and coercion when discussing female sex workers and responses to perceived ‘problems’ of prostitution and neglect the needs of male and transgender sex workers. I contrast messages in policy discourses with the experiences of sex workers across indoor sectors. My study found considerable diversity in working experiences, influenced by factors such as work setting, personal circumstances and aspirations. While some people may view sex work as a short-term option, for others it represents a longer-term career. For some, sex work may offer greater job satisfaction and control over working conditions than other jobs available. Nonetheless, external constraints sometimes make it difficult for them to work safely. I argue state discourses fail to reflect the diverse experiences of sex workers and undermine their agency, perpetuating disrespect and excluding them from human and labour rights. I suggest the need to consider policy approaches shaped according to varied circumstances and settings, drawing on the expertise of sex workers.",
keywords = "sex work, prostitution, labour relations, policy, stigma, recognition, diversity",
author = "Jane Pitcher",
year = "2018",
month = "3",
day = "2",
doi = "10.1007/s13178-018-0323-3",
language = "English",

}

Intimate labour and the state : contrasting policy discourses with the working experiences of indoor sex workers. / Pitcher, Jane.

02.03.2018.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Intimate labour and the state

T2 - contrasting policy discourses with the working experiences of indoor sex workers

AU - Pitcher, Jane

PY - 2018/3/2

Y1 - 2018/3/2

N2 - Drawing on an interview-based study with indoor-based sex workers of different genders in Great Britain, this paper explores the disparity between dominant policy representations of sex workers and the working lives of people selling intimate services. I argue certain policy discourses reinforce narratives of vulnerability and coercion when discussing female sex workers and responses to perceived ‘problems’ of prostitution and neglect the needs of male and transgender sex workers. I contrast messages in policy discourses with the experiences of sex workers across indoor sectors. My study found considerable diversity in working experiences, influenced by factors such as work setting, personal circumstances and aspirations. While some people may view sex work as a short-term option, for others it represents a longer-term career. For some, sex work may offer greater job satisfaction and control over working conditions than other jobs available. Nonetheless, external constraints sometimes make it difficult for them to work safely. I argue state discourses fail to reflect the diverse experiences of sex workers and undermine their agency, perpetuating disrespect and excluding them from human and labour rights. I suggest the need to consider policy approaches shaped according to varied circumstances and settings, drawing on the expertise of sex workers.

AB - Drawing on an interview-based study with indoor-based sex workers of different genders in Great Britain, this paper explores the disparity between dominant policy representations of sex workers and the working lives of people selling intimate services. I argue certain policy discourses reinforce narratives of vulnerability and coercion when discussing female sex workers and responses to perceived ‘problems’ of prostitution and neglect the needs of male and transgender sex workers. I contrast messages in policy discourses with the experiences of sex workers across indoor sectors. My study found considerable diversity in working experiences, influenced by factors such as work setting, personal circumstances and aspirations. While some people may view sex work as a short-term option, for others it represents a longer-term career. For some, sex work may offer greater job satisfaction and control over working conditions than other jobs available. Nonetheless, external constraints sometimes make it difficult for them to work safely. I argue state discourses fail to reflect the diverse experiences of sex workers and undermine their agency, perpetuating disrespect and excluding them from human and labour rights. I suggest the need to consider policy approaches shaped according to varied circumstances and settings, drawing on the expertise of sex workers.

KW - sex work

KW - prostitution

KW - labour relations

KW - policy

KW - stigma

KW - recognition

KW - diversity

U2 - 10.1007/s13178-018-0323-3

DO - 10.1007/s13178-018-0323-3

M3 - Article

ER -