Information about assisted dying: an evaluation of web-based information resources

Carol Haigh, Cristina Costa

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This paper is a report of a study of the quality of information that is available on the World Wide Web around the topic of assisted dying by sampling information from a number of web pages about assisted dying with a view to evaluating the nature, content and rigour of the information they contain. The Internet is seen as one of the first places people will go for information about their health or health-related topics. However, whilst it would appear that, as a source of factual
health-related information, the Internet has a degree of reliability and credibility, there is a dearth of information about how the information may contribute to opinion formation and attitudes around important health debates.The study used content analysis of web-based material to evaluate the nature, content,
currency and rigour of the information they contained against 27 criteria. Each website was independently assessed by two people, and discrepancies were resolved by discussion. In addition the readability and reading age level of each site was evaluated objectively using ‘The Readability Test Tool’ website (Simpson, 2009). The web page data were collected on three separate days in November 2010. The majority of sites showed accuracy (76%, n¼43) with 7 (14%) being
assessed as highly accurate. This was reflected in the completeness of the site evaluated. All sites were readable with 12 pages (24%) being rated at 3.
There is a discrepancy between web-based information that is aimed at ‘scholars’ and that aimed at the general public. This does have implications for those service users who wish to make health-related decisions based upon reliable information.
LanguageEnglish
Number of pages10
JournalJournal of Research in Nursing
Early online date9 Jan 2013
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2013

Fingerprint

Internet
Health
Reading

Keywords

  • assisted dying
  • nursing
  • web-based information
  • evaluation

Cite this

@article{c75f4d61a09f40b6bbeb87d3232ce851,
title = "Information about assisted dying: an evaluation of web-based information resources",
abstract = "This paper is a report of a study of the quality of information that is available on the World Wide Web around the topic of assisted dying by sampling information from a number of web pages about assisted dying with a view to evaluating the nature, content and rigour of the information they contain. The Internet is seen as one of the first places people will go for information about their health or health-related topics. However, whilst it would appear that, as a source of factualhealth-related information, the Internet has a degree of reliability and credibility, there is a dearth of information about how the information may contribute to opinion formation and attitudes around important health debates.The study used content analysis of web-based material to evaluate the nature, content,currency and rigour of the information they contained against 27 criteria. Each website was independently assessed by two people, and discrepancies were resolved by discussion. In addition the readability and reading age level of each site was evaluated objectively using ‘The Readability Test Tool’ website (Simpson, 2009). The web page data were collected on three separate days in November 2010. The majority of sites showed accuracy (76{\%}, n¼43) with 7 (14{\%}) beingassessed as highly accurate. This was reflected in the completeness of the site evaluated. All sites were readable with 12 pages (24{\%}) being rated at 3.There is a discrepancy between web-based information that is aimed at ‘scholars’ and that aimed at the general public. This does have implications for those service users who wish to make health-related decisions based upon reliable information.",
keywords = "assisted dying, nursing, web-based information, evaluation",
author = "Carol Haigh and Cristina Costa",
year = "2013",
doi = "10.1177/1744987112471139",
language = "English",
journal = "Journal of Research in Nursing",
issn = "1744-9871",

}

Information about assisted dying : an evaluation of web-based information resources. / Haigh, Carol; Costa, Cristina.

In: Journal of Research in Nursing, 2013.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Information about assisted dying

T2 - Journal of Research in Nursing

AU - Haigh, Carol

AU - Costa, Cristina

PY - 2013

Y1 - 2013

N2 - This paper is a report of a study of the quality of information that is available on the World Wide Web around the topic of assisted dying by sampling information from a number of web pages about assisted dying with a view to evaluating the nature, content and rigour of the information they contain. The Internet is seen as one of the first places people will go for information about their health or health-related topics. However, whilst it would appear that, as a source of factualhealth-related information, the Internet has a degree of reliability and credibility, there is a dearth of information about how the information may contribute to opinion formation and attitudes around important health debates.The study used content analysis of web-based material to evaluate the nature, content,currency and rigour of the information they contained against 27 criteria. Each website was independently assessed by two people, and discrepancies were resolved by discussion. In addition the readability and reading age level of each site was evaluated objectively using ‘The Readability Test Tool’ website (Simpson, 2009). The web page data were collected on three separate days in November 2010. The majority of sites showed accuracy (76%, n¼43) with 7 (14%) beingassessed as highly accurate. This was reflected in the completeness of the site evaluated. All sites were readable with 12 pages (24%) being rated at 3.There is a discrepancy between web-based information that is aimed at ‘scholars’ and that aimed at the general public. This does have implications for those service users who wish to make health-related decisions based upon reliable information.

AB - This paper is a report of a study of the quality of information that is available on the World Wide Web around the topic of assisted dying by sampling information from a number of web pages about assisted dying with a view to evaluating the nature, content and rigour of the information they contain. The Internet is seen as one of the first places people will go for information about their health or health-related topics. However, whilst it would appear that, as a source of factualhealth-related information, the Internet has a degree of reliability and credibility, there is a dearth of information about how the information may contribute to opinion formation and attitudes around important health debates.The study used content analysis of web-based material to evaluate the nature, content,currency and rigour of the information they contained against 27 criteria. Each website was independently assessed by two people, and discrepancies were resolved by discussion. In addition the readability and reading age level of each site was evaluated objectively using ‘The Readability Test Tool’ website (Simpson, 2009). The web page data were collected on three separate days in November 2010. The majority of sites showed accuracy (76%, n¼43) with 7 (14%) beingassessed as highly accurate. This was reflected in the completeness of the site evaluated. All sites were readable with 12 pages (24%) being rated at 3.There is a discrepancy between web-based information that is aimed at ‘scholars’ and that aimed at the general public. This does have implications for those service users who wish to make health-related decisions based upon reliable information.

KW - assisted dying

KW - nursing

KW - web-based information

KW - evaluation

U2 - 10.1177/1744987112471139

DO - 10.1177/1744987112471139

M3 - Article

JO - Journal of Research in Nursing

JF - Journal of Research in Nursing

SN - 1744-9871

ER -