Improving cattle disease reporting and surveillance in Ethiopia using smartphone-based application

TJ Beyene, F Asfaw, Y Getachew, T Beyene, I Collins, FA Beyi, CW Revie

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution book

Abstract

This study explores the use of a smartphone-based application to increase the accuracy and completeness of cattle disease reporting and surveillance in three regions of Ethiopia. We compared the performance of a smartphone-based application with traditional (paper-based) cattle diagnosis and reporting, in terms of demographics and disease information, level of detail and delay in time to transmit information to higher levels. A total of 547 and 678 clinical cattle cases were diagnosed in veterinary clinics visited by two groups of final-year veterinary students using the VetAfrica-Ethiopia (VAE) smartphone app and manual approach respectively. The group using the VAE application diagnosed over 90% cases as diseases of a specific name, while in reports from the manual system almost 50% of cases were diagnosed as non-specific diseases or ‘syndromes’. Furthermore, the mean duration of time required for smartphone data to be received by zonal- and federal- level veterinary services through a Cloud-based server were estimated to be two days (95% CI: 1.6–2.3), five days (95% CI: 3.8–5.4), and 13 days (95% CI: 12–14.9) in the Central, Eastern and Southern regions. The traditional reporting system adopted a batch reporting approach and only around two thirds of all cases reach the federal veterinary service by the end of a month. Despite the fact that such smartphone technology-assisted reporting and surveillance involves considerable start-up challenges and may be affected by intermittent mobile internet network coverage, they offer significant benefits in terms of improving data integrity, timeliness and reduced costs in the long run.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationProceeding of the 3rd International Conference of Animal Health Surveillance
Place of PublicationWellington, New Zealand
Pages77-80
Number of pages4
Publication statusPublished - 4 May 2017

Fingerprint

Cattle Diseases
Ethiopia
Animal Hospitals
Internet
Names
Demography
Smartphone
Students
Technology
Costs and Cost Analysis

Keywords

  • smartphone applications
  • surveillance
  • diagnosis
  • disease monitoring
  • data integrity

Cite this

Beyene, TJ., Asfaw, F., Getachew, Y., Beyene, T., Collins, I., Beyi, FA., & Revie, CW. (2017). Improving cattle disease reporting and surveillance in Ethiopia using smartphone-based application. In Proceeding of the 3rd International Conference of Animal Health Surveillance (pp. 77-80). Wellington, New Zealand.
Beyene, TJ ; Asfaw, F ; Getachew, Y ; Beyene, T ; Collins, I ; Beyi, FA ; Revie, CW. / Improving cattle disease reporting and surveillance in Ethiopia using smartphone-based application. Proceeding of the 3rd International Conference of Animal Health Surveillance. Wellington, New Zealand, 2017. pp. 77-80
@inproceedings{f5f31915796e44a7aaa4e214704b5589,
title = "Improving cattle disease reporting and surveillance in Ethiopia using smartphone-based application",
abstract = "This study explores the use of a smartphone-based application to increase the accuracy and completeness of cattle disease reporting and surveillance in three regions of Ethiopia. We compared the performance of a smartphone-based application with traditional (paper-based) cattle diagnosis and reporting, in terms of demographics and disease information, level of detail and delay in time to transmit information to higher levels. A total of 547 and 678 clinical cattle cases were diagnosed in veterinary clinics visited by two groups of final-year veterinary students using the VetAfrica-Ethiopia (VAE) smartphone app and manual approach respectively. The group using the VAE application diagnosed over 90{\%} cases as diseases of a specific name, while in reports from the manual system almost 50{\%} of cases were diagnosed as non-specific diseases or ‘syndromes’. Furthermore, the mean duration of time required for smartphone data to be received by zonal- and federal- level veterinary services through a Cloud-based server were estimated to be two days (95{\%} CI: 1.6–2.3), five days (95{\%} CI: 3.8–5.4), and 13 days (95{\%} CI: 12–14.9) in the Central, Eastern and Southern regions. The traditional reporting system adopted a batch reporting approach and only around two thirds of all cases reach the federal veterinary service by the end of a month. Despite the fact that such smartphone technology-assisted reporting and surveillance involves considerable start-up challenges and may be affected by intermittent mobile internet network coverage, they offer significant benefits in terms of improving data integrity, timeliness and reduced costs in the long run.",
keywords = "smartphone applications, surveillance, diagnosis, disease monitoring, data integrity",
author = "TJ Beyene and F Asfaw and Y Getachew and T Beyene and I Collins and FA Beyi and CW Revie",
year = "2017",
month = "5",
day = "4",
language = "English",
pages = "77--80",
booktitle = "Proceeding of the 3rd International Conference of Animal Health Surveillance",

}

Beyene, TJ, Asfaw, F, Getachew, Y, Beyene, T, Collins, I, Beyi, FA & Revie, CW 2017, Improving cattle disease reporting and surveillance in Ethiopia using smartphone-based application. in Proceeding of the 3rd International Conference of Animal Health Surveillance. Wellington, New Zealand, pp. 77-80.

Improving cattle disease reporting and surveillance in Ethiopia using smartphone-based application. / Beyene, TJ; Asfaw, F; Getachew, Y; Beyene, T; Collins, I; Beyi, FA; Revie, CW.

Proceeding of the 3rd International Conference of Animal Health Surveillance. Wellington, New Zealand, 2017. p. 77-80.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingConference contribution book

TY - GEN

T1 - Improving cattle disease reporting and surveillance in Ethiopia using smartphone-based application

AU - Beyene, TJ

AU - Asfaw, F

AU - Getachew, Y

AU - Beyene, T

AU - Collins, I

AU - Beyi, FA

AU - Revie, CW

PY - 2017/5/4

Y1 - 2017/5/4

N2 - This study explores the use of a smartphone-based application to increase the accuracy and completeness of cattle disease reporting and surveillance in three regions of Ethiopia. We compared the performance of a smartphone-based application with traditional (paper-based) cattle diagnosis and reporting, in terms of demographics and disease information, level of detail and delay in time to transmit information to higher levels. A total of 547 and 678 clinical cattle cases were diagnosed in veterinary clinics visited by two groups of final-year veterinary students using the VetAfrica-Ethiopia (VAE) smartphone app and manual approach respectively. The group using the VAE application diagnosed over 90% cases as diseases of a specific name, while in reports from the manual system almost 50% of cases were diagnosed as non-specific diseases or ‘syndromes’. Furthermore, the mean duration of time required for smartphone data to be received by zonal- and federal- level veterinary services through a Cloud-based server were estimated to be two days (95% CI: 1.6–2.3), five days (95% CI: 3.8–5.4), and 13 days (95% CI: 12–14.9) in the Central, Eastern and Southern regions. The traditional reporting system adopted a batch reporting approach and only around two thirds of all cases reach the federal veterinary service by the end of a month. Despite the fact that such smartphone technology-assisted reporting and surveillance involves considerable start-up challenges and may be affected by intermittent mobile internet network coverage, they offer significant benefits in terms of improving data integrity, timeliness and reduced costs in the long run.

AB - This study explores the use of a smartphone-based application to increase the accuracy and completeness of cattle disease reporting and surveillance in three regions of Ethiopia. We compared the performance of a smartphone-based application with traditional (paper-based) cattle diagnosis and reporting, in terms of demographics and disease information, level of detail and delay in time to transmit information to higher levels. A total of 547 and 678 clinical cattle cases were diagnosed in veterinary clinics visited by two groups of final-year veterinary students using the VetAfrica-Ethiopia (VAE) smartphone app and manual approach respectively. The group using the VAE application diagnosed over 90% cases as diseases of a specific name, while in reports from the manual system almost 50% of cases were diagnosed as non-specific diseases or ‘syndromes’. Furthermore, the mean duration of time required for smartphone data to be received by zonal- and federal- level veterinary services through a Cloud-based server were estimated to be two days (95% CI: 1.6–2.3), five days (95% CI: 3.8–5.4), and 13 days (95% CI: 12–14.9) in the Central, Eastern and Southern regions. The traditional reporting system adopted a batch reporting approach and only around two thirds of all cases reach the federal veterinary service by the end of a month. Despite the fact that such smartphone technology-assisted reporting and surveillance involves considerable start-up challenges and may be affected by intermittent mobile internet network coverage, they offer significant benefits in terms of improving data integrity, timeliness and reduced costs in the long run.

KW - smartphone applications

KW - surveillance

KW - diagnosis

KW - disease monitoring

KW - data integrity

M3 - Conference contribution book

SP - 77

EP - 80

BT - Proceeding of the 3rd International Conference of Animal Health Surveillance

CY - Wellington, New Zealand

ER -

Beyene TJ, Asfaw F, Getachew Y, Beyene T, Collins I, Beyi FA et al. Improving cattle disease reporting and surveillance in Ethiopia using smartphone-based application. In Proceeding of the 3rd International Conference of Animal Health Surveillance. Wellington, New Zealand. 2017. p. 77-80