Impact of drafts on the damage survivability of cruise ships

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The prevailing probabilistic damage stability concept, as outlined within SOLAS 2009 for passenger ships, calculates the Attained Subdivision Index based upon three loading conditions which combine to form a theoretical draft range for a given vessel. To each of these loading conditions a weighting factor is then applied to account for the probability that a vessel will be operating at or near any of these drafts at the time of collision, should one occur. Currently the weighting factors are applied in a 'one-size-fits-all' manner, with the same weightings to be applied in the case of cargo and passenger vessels despite the fact that these ship types are known to have very different tendencies when it comes to the nature of their operation. This in turn, calls into question the suitability of these weightings concerning what degree they, in fact, reflect the operational profile of the vessels covered by the standard. With this in mind, the present paper aims to investigate the suitability and accuracy of the currently assumed draft weighting factors with regards to cruise vessels. This study is conducted using operational loading condition data sourced from 18 cruise ships and spanning up to a period of two years in some cases. On the basis of this data, draft probability distributions are derived and new weighting factors are formed specifically pertaining to cruise ships and the nature of their operation. Finally, an assessment is conducted looking into the impact of the newly derived weighting factors on the magnitude of the Attained Subdivision Index and recommendations are made on how best to implement them.
LanguageEnglish
Article number106136
Number of pages8
JournalOcean Engineering
Volume187
Early online date3 Jul 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Sep 2019

Fingerprint

Ships
Probability distributions

Keywords

  • SOLAS 2009
  • damage stability
  • draft distribution
  • operational data
  • attained subdivision index
  • survivability

Cite this

@article{f92027dd9c3546fcb90c2e1289c6e686,
title = "Impact of drafts on the damage survivability of cruise ships",
abstract = "The prevailing probabilistic damage stability concept, as outlined within SOLAS 2009 for passenger ships, calculates the Attained Subdivision Index based upon three loading conditions which combine to form a theoretical draft range for a given vessel. To each of these loading conditions a weighting factor is then applied to account for the probability that a vessel will be operating at or near any of these drafts at the time of collision, should one occur. Currently the weighting factors are applied in a 'one-size-fits-all' manner, with the same weightings to be applied in the case of cargo and passenger vessels despite the fact that these ship types are known to have very different tendencies when it comes to the nature of their operation. This in turn, calls into question the suitability of these weightings concerning what degree they, in fact, reflect the operational profile of the vessels covered by the standard. With this in mind, the present paper aims to investigate the suitability and accuracy of the currently assumed draft weighting factors with regards to cruise vessels. This study is conducted using operational loading condition data sourced from 18 cruise ships and spanning up to a period of two years in some cases. On the basis of this data, draft probability distributions are derived and new weighting factors are formed specifically pertaining to cruise ships and the nature of their operation. Finally, an assessment is conducted looking into the impact of the newly derived weighting factors on the magnitude of the Attained Subdivision Index and recommendations are made on how best to implement them.",
keywords = "SOLAS 2009, damage stability, draft distribution, operational data, attained subdivision index, survivability",
author = "Donald Paterson and Dracos Vassalos and Georgios Atzampos and Evangelos Boulougouris and Henning Luhmann",
year = "2019",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1016/j.oceaneng.2019.106136",
language = "English",
volume = "187",
journal = "Ocean Engineering",
issn = "0029-8018",
publisher = "Elsevier",

}

Impact of drafts on the damage survivability of cruise ships. / Paterson, Donald; Vassalos, Dracos; Atzampos, Georgios; Boulougouris, Evangelos; Luhmann, Henning.

In: Ocean Engineering, Vol. 187, 106136, 01.09.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Impact of drafts on the damage survivability of cruise ships

AU - Paterson, Donald

AU - Vassalos, Dracos

AU - Atzampos, Georgios

AU - Boulougouris, Evangelos

AU - Luhmann, Henning

PY - 2019/9/1

Y1 - 2019/9/1

N2 - The prevailing probabilistic damage stability concept, as outlined within SOLAS 2009 for passenger ships, calculates the Attained Subdivision Index based upon three loading conditions which combine to form a theoretical draft range for a given vessel. To each of these loading conditions a weighting factor is then applied to account for the probability that a vessel will be operating at or near any of these drafts at the time of collision, should one occur. Currently the weighting factors are applied in a 'one-size-fits-all' manner, with the same weightings to be applied in the case of cargo and passenger vessels despite the fact that these ship types are known to have very different tendencies when it comes to the nature of their operation. This in turn, calls into question the suitability of these weightings concerning what degree they, in fact, reflect the operational profile of the vessels covered by the standard. With this in mind, the present paper aims to investigate the suitability and accuracy of the currently assumed draft weighting factors with regards to cruise vessels. This study is conducted using operational loading condition data sourced from 18 cruise ships and spanning up to a period of two years in some cases. On the basis of this data, draft probability distributions are derived and new weighting factors are formed specifically pertaining to cruise ships and the nature of their operation. Finally, an assessment is conducted looking into the impact of the newly derived weighting factors on the magnitude of the Attained Subdivision Index and recommendations are made on how best to implement them.

AB - The prevailing probabilistic damage stability concept, as outlined within SOLAS 2009 for passenger ships, calculates the Attained Subdivision Index based upon three loading conditions which combine to form a theoretical draft range for a given vessel. To each of these loading conditions a weighting factor is then applied to account for the probability that a vessel will be operating at or near any of these drafts at the time of collision, should one occur. Currently the weighting factors are applied in a 'one-size-fits-all' manner, with the same weightings to be applied in the case of cargo and passenger vessels despite the fact that these ship types are known to have very different tendencies when it comes to the nature of their operation. This in turn, calls into question the suitability of these weightings concerning what degree they, in fact, reflect the operational profile of the vessels covered by the standard. With this in mind, the present paper aims to investigate the suitability and accuracy of the currently assumed draft weighting factors with regards to cruise vessels. This study is conducted using operational loading condition data sourced from 18 cruise ships and spanning up to a period of two years in some cases. On the basis of this data, draft probability distributions are derived and new weighting factors are formed specifically pertaining to cruise ships and the nature of their operation. Finally, an assessment is conducted looking into the impact of the newly derived weighting factors on the magnitude of the Attained Subdivision Index and recommendations are made on how best to implement them.

KW - SOLAS 2009

KW - damage stability

KW - draft distribution

KW - operational data

KW - attained subdivision index

KW - survivability

UR - https://www.sciencedirect.com/journal/ocean-engineering

U2 - 10.1016/j.oceaneng.2019.106136

DO - 10.1016/j.oceaneng.2019.106136

M3 - Article

VL - 187

JO - Ocean Engineering

T2 - Ocean Engineering

JF - Ocean Engineering

SN - 0029-8018

M1 - 106136

ER -