Immigration status and basic social human rights: a comparative study of irregular migrants' right to health care in France, the UK and Canada

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

4 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The article examines the constraints that irregular migrants' immigration status exerts on the realisation of their basic social human rights. To this end, the article focuses on the right to health care and undertakes a comparative study of irregular migrants' access to health care in France, the United Kingdom and Canada. The study shows that states perceive the conferment of social rights on irregular migrants as an erosion of the government's immigration power notwithstanding their characterisation as human rights. The resource-intensive nature of the right to health care further heightens states' reluctance to extend this right to irregular migrants. Yet compliance with international human rights law and respect for human dignity require that states reinstate personhood as a source of rights and therefore reassess the relevance of their immigration power.
LanguageEnglish
Pages6-40
Number of pages35
JournalNetherlands Quarterly of Human Rights
Volume28
Issue number1
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2010

Fingerprint

immigration
human rights
migrant
France
Canada
health care
human dignity
social rights
erosion
respect
Law
resources

Keywords

  • migrant
  • immigration
  • health care
  • social rights

Cite this

@article{73e63288002c4c69afade1e54805098d,
title = "Immigration status and basic social human rights: a comparative study of irregular migrants' right to health care in France, the UK and Canada",
abstract = "The article examines the constraints that irregular migrants' immigration status exerts on the realisation of their basic social human rights. To this end, the article focuses on the right to health care and undertakes a comparative study of irregular migrants' access to health care in France, the United Kingdom and Canada. The study shows that states perceive the conferment of social rights on irregular migrants as an erosion of the government's immigration power notwithstanding their characterisation as human rights. The resource-intensive nature of the right to health care further heightens states' reluctance to extend this right to irregular migrants. Yet compliance with international human rights law and respect for human dignity require that states reinstate personhood as a source of rights and therefore reassess the relevance of their immigration power.",
keywords = "migrant, immigration, health care, social rights",
author = "{Da Lomba}, Sylvie",
year = "2010",
month = "3",
language = "English",
volume = "28",
pages = "6--40",
journal = "Netherlands Quarterly of Human Rights",
issn = "0924-0519",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Immigration status and basic social human rights

T2 - Netherlands Quarterly of Human Rights

AU - Da Lomba, Sylvie

PY - 2010/3

Y1 - 2010/3

N2 - The article examines the constraints that irregular migrants' immigration status exerts on the realisation of their basic social human rights. To this end, the article focuses on the right to health care and undertakes a comparative study of irregular migrants' access to health care in France, the United Kingdom and Canada. The study shows that states perceive the conferment of social rights on irregular migrants as an erosion of the government's immigration power notwithstanding their characterisation as human rights. The resource-intensive nature of the right to health care further heightens states' reluctance to extend this right to irregular migrants. Yet compliance with international human rights law and respect for human dignity require that states reinstate personhood as a source of rights and therefore reassess the relevance of their immigration power.

AB - The article examines the constraints that irregular migrants' immigration status exerts on the realisation of their basic social human rights. To this end, the article focuses on the right to health care and undertakes a comparative study of irregular migrants' access to health care in France, the United Kingdom and Canada. The study shows that states perceive the conferment of social rights on irregular migrants as an erosion of the government's immigration power notwithstanding their characterisation as human rights. The resource-intensive nature of the right to health care further heightens states' reluctance to extend this right to irregular migrants. Yet compliance with international human rights law and respect for human dignity require that states reinstate personhood as a source of rights and therefore reassess the relevance of their immigration power.

KW - migrant

KW - immigration

KW - health care

KW - social rights

UR - http://sim.law.uu.nl/SIM/Library/books.nsf/a1c506a79c314718c125668200337d46/9b9bf5dfa487b732c12576e800357972?OpenDocument

M3 - Article

VL - 28

SP - 6

EP - 40

JO - Netherlands Quarterly of Human Rights

JF - Netherlands Quarterly of Human Rights

SN - 0924-0519

IS - 1

ER -