Hacking into tragedy: exploring the ethics of death reporting in the social media age

Jackie Newton, Sallyanne Duncan

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)

Abstract

The phone-tapping scandal blew up with the revelation that murder victim Milly Dowler’s phone had been hacked, seeming to demonstrate that the public are much more concerned with the feelings of bereaved families than with the reputations of celebrities or politicians. Therefore any regulation that arises from the UK hacking scandal is likely to include the area of contact between journalists and the grieving. This paper considers whether families actually need more “protection” from journalists and, drawing on evidence from interviews with bereaved relatives, argues that what they actually need is informed access to the media. It also considers “hacking” and lifting material from social media sites, which, while being legal, similarly prompts many ethical concerns. Journalists’ attitudes to using these sites in covering personal traumatic events will be explored using data collected from questionnaires mostly from reporters of five years or less experience. In particular the paper will examine whether journalists consider “virtual door-stepping” to be more or less intrusive than traditional approaches and whether they use these sites to limit contact with the bereaved. It will attempt to assess the benefits and harms of a probable increased usage of social networking sites in the intrusive reporting process.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationThe Phone Hacking Scandal
Subtitle of host publicationJournalism on Trial
EditorsRichard Lance Keeble, John Mair
Publication statusPublished - 10 Sep 2012

Fingerprint

Social Media
Tragedy
Journalists
Scandal
Hacking
Phone
Revelation
Tapping
Celebrity
Politicians
Social Networking
Harm
Prompts
Grieving
Murder
Questionnaire

Keywords

  • journalism
  • phone hacking
  • social media
  • death reporting
  • journalism ethics

Cite this

Newton, J., & Duncan, S. (2012). Hacking into tragedy: exploring the ethics of death reporting in the social media age. In R. L. Keeble, & J. Mair (Eds.), The Phone Hacking Scandal: Journalism on Trial
Newton, Jackie ; Duncan, Sallyanne. / Hacking into tragedy : exploring the ethics of death reporting in the social media age. The Phone Hacking Scandal: Journalism on Trial. editor / Richard Lance Keeble ; John Mair . 2012.
@inbook{0c6ec9162903412eb770d6c776aef8e1,
title = "Hacking into tragedy: exploring the ethics of death reporting in the social media age",
abstract = "The phone-tapping scandal blew up with the revelation that murder victim Milly Dowler’s phone had been hacked, seeming to demonstrate that the public are much more concerned with the feelings of bereaved families than with the reputations of celebrities or politicians. Therefore any regulation that arises from the UK hacking scandal is likely to include the area of contact between journalists and the grieving. This paper considers whether families actually need more “protection” from journalists and, drawing on evidence from interviews with bereaved relatives, argues that what they actually need is informed access to the media. It also considers “hacking” and lifting material from social media sites, which, while being legal, similarly prompts many ethical concerns. Journalists’ attitudes to using these sites in covering personal traumatic events will be explored using data collected from questionnaires mostly from reporters of five years or less experience. In particular the paper will examine whether journalists consider “virtual door-stepping” to be more or less intrusive than traditional approaches and whether they use these sites to limit contact with the bereaved. It will attempt to assess the benefits and harms of a probable increased usage of social networking sites in the intrusive reporting process.",
keywords = "journalism , phone hacking, social media, death reporting , journalism ethics",
author = "Jackie Newton and Sallyanne Duncan",
year = "2012",
month = "9",
day = "10",
language = "English",
isbn = "9781845495565",
editor = "Keeble, {Richard Lance} and {Mair }, John",
booktitle = "The Phone Hacking Scandal",

}

Newton, J & Duncan, S 2012, Hacking into tragedy: exploring the ethics of death reporting in the social media age. in RL Keeble & J Mair (eds), The Phone Hacking Scandal: Journalism on Trial.

Hacking into tragedy : exploring the ethics of death reporting in the social media age. / Newton, Jackie; Duncan, Sallyanne.

The Phone Hacking Scandal: Journalism on Trial. ed. / Richard Lance Keeble; John Mair . 2012.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter (peer-reviewed)

TY - CHAP

T1 - Hacking into tragedy

T2 - exploring the ethics of death reporting in the social media age

AU - Newton, Jackie

AU - Duncan, Sallyanne

PY - 2012/9/10

Y1 - 2012/9/10

N2 - The phone-tapping scandal blew up with the revelation that murder victim Milly Dowler’s phone had been hacked, seeming to demonstrate that the public are much more concerned with the feelings of bereaved families than with the reputations of celebrities or politicians. Therefore any regulation that arises from the UK hacking scandal is likely to include the area of contact between journalists and the grieving. This paper considers whether families actually need more “protection” from journalists and, drawing on evidence from interviews with bereaved relatives, argues that what they actually need is informed access to the media. It also considers “hacking” and lifting material from social media sites, which, while being legal, similarly prompts many ethical concerns. Journalists’ attitudes to using these sites in covering personal traumatic events will be explored using data collected from questionnaires mostly from reporters of five years or less experience. In particular the paper will examine whether journalists consider “virtual door-stepping” to be more or less intrusive than traditional approaches and whether they use these sites to limit contact with the bereaved. It will attempt to assess the benefits and harms of a probable increased usage of social networking sites in the intrusive reporting process.

AB - The phone-tapping scandal blew up with the revelation that murder victim Milly Dowler’s phone had been hacked, seeming to demonstrate that the public are much more concerned with the feelings of bereaved families than with the reputations of celebrities or politicians. Therefore any regulation that arises from the UK hacking scandal is likely to include the area of contact between journalists and the grieving. This paper considers whether families actually need more “protection” from journalists and, drawing on evidence from interviews with bereaved relatives, argues that what they actually need is informed access to the media. It also considers “hacking” and lifting material from social media sites, which, while being legal, similarly prompts many ethical concerns. Journalists’ attitudes to using these sites in covering personal traumatic events will be explored using data collected from questionnaires mostly from reporters of five years or less experience. In particular the paper will examine whether journalists consider “virtual door-stepping” to be more or less intrusive than traditional approaches and whether they use these sites to limit contact with the bereaved. It will attempt to assess the benefits and harms of a probable increased usage of social networking sites in the intrusive reporting process.

KW - journalism

KW - phone hacking

KW - social media

KW - death reporting

KW - journalism ethics

UR - http://www.arimapublishing.co.uk/bookshopuk/bookinfo/book_184549556?bs=uk

M3 - Chapter (peer-reviewed)

SN - 9781845495565

BT - The Phone Hacking Scandal

A2 - Keeble, Richard Lance

A2 - Mair , John

ER -

Newton J, Duncan S. Hacking into tragedy: exploring the ethics of death reporting in the social media age. In Keeble RL, Mair J, editors, The Phone Hacking Scandal: Journalism on Trial. 2012