Grid-forming: a control approach to go further offshore?

Offshore wind farms are increasingly being commissioned farther from shore, and high voltage alternating current (HVAC) transmission systems are preferred because of their maturity and reliability. However, as cable length increases, ensuring system stability becomes more challenging, making it essential to investigate shunt reactor compensation configurations and converter control strategies. This study examines three different shunt reactor compensation arrangements and two control strategies, grid-forming (GFM) and grid-following (GFL), across three cable lengths (80 km, 120 km, and 150 km). The systems were evaluated based on small-signal stability using disk margins for different active power operating points, and later for different short-circuit ratios (SCR) and X/R. The results demonstrate that the GFM is preferable for longer cables and enhanced stability. The most robust configuration includes a shunt reactor placed in the mid-cable with additional reactors at both ends of the cable, followed by an arrangement with reactors at the beginning and end. The GFM converter control maintained stability across all operating points, cable lengths, and configurations, whereas the stability of the GFL unit was highly dependent on active power injection and struggled under weaker grid conditions. Thus, for longer HVAC cables, it is necessary to employ GFM control units, and it is recommended to use shunt reactors at the cable start and end, as well as at mid-cable, for optimal stability.