Global error estimation in CFD mesh coarsening process for uncertainty quantification methods

Martin Kubicek, Edmondo Minisci

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

1 Citation (Scopus)
49 Downloads (Pure)

Abstract

Due to high performance of modern computers, Uncertainty Quantification is becoming an important part of engineering design. Every non intrusive Uncertainty Quantification method requires a considerable number of evaluations of the model, meaning that the design process is more expensive in terms of computational resources/time. In Computational Fluid Dynamics, the usual practice is to reduce the computational time by reducing the number of nodes of the used mesh. Each coarsening of the mesh leads to the increase of the error measured as the difference between the real solution and the solution provided by the computational model. In this work, an approach for quantification of the global error around the stochastic domain, in a mesh reduction process, is described and results obtained for a test case are detailed. The method is based on a comparison of the high accurate mesh against coarse mesh with lower accuracy, but less expensive in terms of computational time. The global error is defined as a volume difference between surrogate models created in the stochastic domain. The stochastic domain is given by pre-specified input variables with appropriate boundaries. Surrogate models are used and a non intrusive polynomial chaos model is created with response samples from high and low accuracy mesh. For the chosen test case, the input variables, related to the stochastic space, were the free stream pressure and free stream Mach number. A hypersonic flow solver developed at the von Karman Institute, Cosmic, was used to compute properties of a flow around the reentry spacecraft. A computational expensive mesh was used as a reference mesh. Due to computational resources, it was impossible to use expansive mesh for Monte Carlo simulation or high order Polynomial Chaos. Therefore, the global error estimation approach was applied to find an accurate and relatively inexpensive mesh for Uncertainty Quantification in hypersonic simulation. Multiple meshes with different coarsening were tested, based on expert knowledge of the problem. The global error estimation method allowed for finding a final mesh, with an error on the mean value 0.48% and on the standard deviation 5.89%, which was 4 times faster than the reference mesh.
Original languageEnglish
PagesPaper IAC-13-C2.7.3x18517
Number of pages12
Publication statusPublished - 23 Sep 2013
Event64th International Astronautical Congress 2013 - Beijing, China
Duration: 23 Sep 201327 Sep 2013

Conference

Conference64th International Astronautical Congress 2013
CountryChina
CityBeijing
Period23/09/1327/09/13

Fingerprint

Coarsening
Error analysis
Computational fluid dynamics
Chaos theory
Polynomials
Hypersonic flow
Reentry
Hypersonic aerodynamics
Mach number
Spacecraft
Uncertainty

Keywords

  • error estimate
  • CFD
  • uncertainty analysis
  • mesh generation

Cite this

Kubicek, M., & Minisci, E. (2013). Global error estimation in CFD mesh coarsening process for uncertainty quantification methods. Paper IAC-13-C2.7.3x18517. Paper presented at 64th International Astronautical Congress 2013, Beijing, China.
Kubicek, Martin ; Minisci, Edmondo. / Global error estimation in CFD mesh coarsening process for uncertainty quantification methods. Paper presented at 64th International Astronautical Congress 2013, Beijing, China.12 p.
@conference{d220b1e1cb764a888d170cf6b585e448,
title = "Global error estimation in CFD mesh coarsening process for uncertainty quantification methods",
abstract = "Due to high performance of modern computers, Uncertainty Quantification is becoming an important part of engineering design. Every non intrusive Uncertainty Quantification method requires a considerable number of evaluations of the model, meaning that the design process is more expensive in terms of computational resources/time. In Computational Fluid Dynamics, the usual practice is to reduce the computational time by reducing the number of nodes of the used mesh. Each coarsening of the mesh leads to the increase of the error measured as the difference between the real solution and the solution provided by the computational model. In this work, an approach for quantification of the global error around the stochastic domain, in a mesh reduction process, is described and results obtained for a test case are detailed. The method is based on a comparison of the high accurate mesh against coarse mesh with lower accuracy, but less expensive in terms of computational time. The global error is defined as a volume difference between surrogate models created in the stochastic domain. The stochastic domain is given by pre-specified input variables with appropriate boundaries. Surrogate models are used and a non intrusive polynomial chaos model is created with response samples from high and low accuracy mesh. For the chosen test case, the input variables, related to the stochastic space, were the free stream pressure and free stream Mach number. A hypersonic flow solver developed at the von Karman Institute, Cosmic, was used to compute properties of a flow around the reentry spacecraft. A computational expensive mesh was used as a reference mesh. Due to computational resources, it was impossible to use expansive mesh for Monte Carlo simulation or high order Polynomial Chaos. Therefore, the global error estimation approach was applied to find an accurate and relatively inexpensive mesh for Uncertainty Quantification in hypersonic simulation. Multiple meshes with different coarsening were tested, based on expert knowledge of the problem. The global error estimation method allowed for finding a final mesh, with an error on the mean value 0.48{\%} and on the standard deviation 5.89{\%}, which was 4 times faster than the reference mesh.",
keywords = "error estimate, CFD, uncertainty analysis, mesh generation",
author = "Martin Kubicek and Edmondo Minisci",
note = "Copyright 2013 by Mr. Martin Kubicek. Published by the IAF, with permission and released to the IAF to publish in all forms.; 64th International Astronautical Congress 2013 ; Conference date: 23-09-2013 Through 27-09-2013",
year = "2013",
month = "9",
day = "23",
language = "English",
pages = "Paper IAC--13--C2.7.3x18517",

}

Kubicek, M & Minisci, E 2013, 'Global error estimation in CFD mesh coarsening process for uncertainty quantification methods' Paper presented at 64th International Astronautical Congress 2013, Beijing, China, 23/09/13 - 27/09/13, pp. Paper IAC-13-C2.7.3x18517.

Global error estimation in CFD mesh coarsening process for uncertainty quantification methods. / Kubicek, Martin; Minisci, Edmondo.

2013. Paper IAC-13-C2.7.3x18517 Paper presented at 64th International Astronautical Congress 2013, Beijing, China.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - Global error estimation in CFD mesh coarsening process for uncertainty quantification methods

AU - Kubicek, Martin

AU - Minisci, Edmondo

N1 - Copyright 2013 by Mr. Martin Kubicek. Published by the IAF, with permission and released to the IAF to publish in all forms.

PY - 2013/9/23

Y1 - 2013/9/23

N2 - Due to high performance of modern computers, Uncertainty Quantification is becoming an important part of engineering design. Every non intrusive Uncertainty Quantification method requires a considerable number of evaluations of the model, meaning that the design process is more expensive in terms of computational resources/time. In Computational Fluid Dynamics, the usual practice is to reduce the computational time by reducing the number of nodes of the used mesh. Each coarsening of the mesh leads to the increase of the error measured as the difference between the real solution and the solution provided by the computational model. In this work, an approach for quantification of the global error around the stochastic domain, in a mesh reduction process, is described and results obtained for a test case are detailed. The method is based on a comparison of the high accurate mesh against coarse mesh with lower accuracy, but less expensive in terms of computational time. The global error is defined as a volume difference between surrogate models created in the stochastic domain. The stochastic domain is given by pre-specified input variables with appropriate boundaries. Surrogate models are used and a non intrusive polynomial chaos model is created with response samples from high and low accuracy mesh. For the chosen test case, the input variables, related to the stochastic space, were the free stream pressure and free stream Mach number. A hypersonic flow solver developed at the von Karman Institute, Cosmic, was used to compute properties of a flow around the reentry spacecraft. A computational expensive mesh was used as a reference mesh. Due to computational resources, it was impossible to use expansive mesh for Monte Carlo simulation or high order Polynomial Chaos. Therefore, the global error estimation approach was applied to find an accurate and relatively inexpensive mesh for Uncertainty Quantification in hypersonic simulation. Multiple meshes with different coarsening were tested, based on expert knowledge of the problem. The global error estimation method allowed for finding a final mesh, with an error on the mean value 0.48% and on the standard deviation 5.89%, which was 4 times faster than the reference mesh.

AB - Due to high performance of modern computers, Uncertainty Quantification is becoming an important part of engineering design. Every non intrusive Uncertainty Quantification method requires a considerable number of evaluations of the model, meaning that the design process is more expensive in terms of computational resources/time. In Computational Fluid Dynamics, the usual practice is to reduce the computational time by reducing the number of nodes of the used mesh. Each coarsening of the mesh leads to the increase of the error measured as the difference between the real solution and the solution provided by the computational model. In this work, an approach for quantification of the global error around the stochastic domain, in a mesh reduction process, is described and results obtained for a test case are detailed. The method is based on a comparison of the high accurate mesh against coarse mesh with lower accuracy, but less expensive in terms of computational time. The global error is defined as a volume difference between surrogate models created in the stochastic domain. The stochastic domain is given by pre-specified input variables with appropriate boundaries. Surrogate models are used and a non intrusive polynomial chaos model is created with response samples from high and low accuracy mesh. For the chosen test case, the input variables, related to the stochastic space, were the free stream pressure and free stream Mach number. A hypersonic flow solver developed at the von Karman Institute, Cosmic, was used to compute properties of a flow around the reentry spacecraft. A computational expensive mesh was used as a reference mesh. Due to computational resources, it was impossible to use expansive mesh for Monte Carlo simulation or high order Polynomial Chaos. Therefore, the global error estimation approach was applied to find an accurate and relatively inexpensive mesh for Uncertainty Quantification in hypersonic simulation. Multiple meshes with different coarsening were tested, based on expert knowledge of the problem. The global error estimation method allowed for finding a final mesh, with an error on the mean value 0.48% and on the standard deviation 5.89%, which was 4 times faster than the reference mesh.

KW - error estimate

KW - CFD

KW - uncertainty analysis

KW - mesh generation

UR - http://www.iac2013.org/dct/page/1

M3 - Paper

SP - Paper IAC-13-C2.7.3x18517

ER -

Kubicek M, Minisci E. Global error estimation in CFD mesh coarsening process for uncertainty quantification methods. 2013. Paper presented at 64th International Astronautical Congress 2013, Beijing, China.