Geospatial statistics elucidate competing geological controls on natural CO2 seeps in Italy

Jennifer J. Roberts, Andrew F. Bell, Rachel A. Wood, R. Stuart Haszeldine

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Site selection for the geological storage of CO2 for long timespans requires an understanding of the controls on containment, migration and surface seepage of subsurface CO2 fluids. Evidence of natural CO2 migration from depth to surface is documented at 270 sites from Italy, a prolific COprovince. Previous studies indicate that CO2 delivery to and from buried structures that host CO2 accumulations is fault controlled, but that competing controls on the CO2 flow pathways affect the location and style of CO2 release. Here, we conduct a meta-analysis using a novel geospatial approach to statistically determine the relationship between geological setting and structures and the CO2 seep spatial distribution and characteristics (morphological type, flux and temperature) in central Italy. We find that seep distribution differs on two spatial scales corresponding to geological setting. On large scales (>5 km) seeps are isotropically distributed and align with regional structures such as anticlines, decollements, and extensional faults. On local scales (<5 km) seeps cluster and align with subsidiary geologic structures, including faults and lithological boundaries. The detailed location and flux of seeps within clusters is influenced by regional structural domain: in the Tyrrhenian seeps tend to be located along fault traces; whereas seeps are located as springs in tip and ramp regions of fault scarps in the Apennines. Thus, our geospatial approach evidences, at a regional scale, how macro-crustal fluid flow is governed by deep extensional and compressional features, but, once CO2 reaches shallower structures, how smaller-scale features and hydrogeological factors distribute the CO2 fluids in the near-surface, dependent on the geological setting. This work not only demonstrates useful application of a novel geospatial approach to characterize competing crustal controls on CO2 flow at different scales, but also informs the design of appropriate site characterization and surface monitoring programs at engineered carbon stores.
LanguageEnglish
Article number8147345
Number of pages9
JournalGeofluids
Volume2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 20 May 2019

Fingerprint

buried structure
site characterization
fluid
decollement
meta-analysis
site selection
containment
anticline
seepage
fluid flow
statistics
spatial distribution
carbon
monitoring
temperature
province
distribution
programme
regional structure

Keywords

  • CO2 seeps
  • crustal fluid flow
  • CO2 storage
  • geographical information systems (GIS)
  • site characterization
  • Italy

Cite this

Roberts, Jennifer J. ; Bell, Andrew F. ; Wood, Rachel A. ; Haszeldine, R. Stuart. / Geospatial statistics elucidate competing geological controls on natural CO2 seeps in Italy. In: Geofluids. 2019 ; Vol. 2019.
@article{9224f425306d40598b761c2b8645d621,
title = "Geospatial statistics elucidate competing geological controls on natural CO2 seeps in Italy",
abstract = "Site selection for the geological storage of CO2 for long timespans requires an understanding of the controls on containment, migration and surface seepage of subsurface CO2 fluids. Evidence of natural CO2 migration from depth to surface is documented at 270 sites from Italy, a prolific CO2 province. Previous studies indicate that CO2 delivery to and from buried structures that host CO2 accumulations is fault controlled, but that competing controls on the CO2 flow pathways affect the location and style of CO2 release. Here, we conduct a meta-analysis using a novel geospatial approach to statistically determine the relationship between geological setting and structures and the CO2 seep spatial distribution and characteristics (morphological type, flux and temperature) in central Italy. We find that seep distribution differs on two spatial scales corresponding to geological setting. On large scales (>5 km) seeps are isotropically distributed and align with regional structures such as anticlines, decollements, and extensional faults. On local scales (<5 km) seeps cluster and align with subsidiary geologic structures, including faults and lithological boundaries. The detailed location and flux of seeps within clusters is influenced by regional structural domain: in the Tyrrhenian seeps tend to be located along fault traces; whereas seeps are located as springs in tip and ramp regions of fault scarps in the Apennines. Thus, our geospatial approach evidences, at a regional scale, how macro-crustal fluid flow is governed by deep extensional and compressional features, but, once CO2 reaches shallower structures, how smaller-scale features and hydrogeological factors distribute the CO2 fluids in the near-surface, dependent on the geological setting. This work not only demonstrates useful application of a novel geospatial approach to characterize competing crustal controls on CO2 flow at different scales, but also informs the design of appropriate site characterization and surface monitoring programs at engineered carbon stores.",
keywords = "CO2 seeps, crustal fluid flow, CO2 storage, geographical information systems (GIS), site characterization, Italy",
author = "Roberts, {Jennifer J.} and Bell, {Andrew F.} and Wood, {Rachel A.} and Haszeldine, {R. Stuart}",
year = "2019",
month = "5",
day = "20",
doi = "10.1155/2019/8147345",
language = "English",
volume = "2019",
journal = "Geofluids",
issn = "1468-8115",

}

Geospatial statistics elucidate competing geological controls on natural CO2 seeps in Italy. / Roberts, Jennifer J.; Bell, Andrew F.; Wood, Rachel A.; Haszeldine, R. Stuart.

In: Geofluids, Vol. 2019, 8147345, 20.05.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Geospatial statistics elucidate competing geological controls on natural CO2 seeps in Italy

AU - Roberts, Jennifer J.

AU - Bell, Andrew F.

AU - Wood, Rachel A.

AU - Haszeldine, R. Stuart

PY - 2019/5/20

Y1 - 2019/5/20

N2 - Site selection for the geological storage of CO2 for long timespans requires an understanding of the controls on containment, migration and surface seepage of subsurface CO2 fluids. Evidence of natural CO2 migration from depth to surface is documented at 270 sites from Italy, a prolific CO2 province. Previous studies indicate that CO2 delivery to and from buried structures that host CO2 accumulations is fault controlled, but that competing controls on the CO2 flow pathways affect the location and style of CO2 release. Here, we conduct a meta-analysis using a novel geospatial approach to statistically determine the relationship between geological setting and structures and the CO2 seep spatial distribution and characteristics (morphological type, flux and temperature) in central Italy. We find that seep distribution differs on two spatial scales corresponding to geological setting. On large scales (>5 km) seeps are isotropically distributed and align with regional structures such as anticlines, decollements, and extensional faults. On local scales (<5 km) seeps cluster and align with subsidiary geologic structures, including faults and lithological boundaries. The detailed location and flux of seeps within clusters is influenced by regional structural domain: in the Tyrrhenian seeps tend to be located along fault traces; whereas seeps are located as springs in tip and ramp regions of fault scarps in the Apennines. Thus, our geospatial approach evidences, at a regional scale, how macro-crustal fluid flow is governed by deep extensional and compressional features, but, once CO2 reaches shallower structures, how smaller-scale features and hydrogeological factors distribute the CO2 fluids in the near-surface, dependent on the geological setting. This work not only demonstrates useful application of a novel geospatial approach to characterize competing crustal controls on CO2 flow at different scales, but also informs the design of appropriate site characterization and surface monitoring programs at engineered carbon stores.

AB - Site selection for the geological storage of CO2 for long timespans requires an understanding of the controls on containment, migration and surface seepage of subsurface CO2 fluids. Evidence of natural CO2 migration from depth to surface is documented at 270 sites from Italy, a prolific CO2 province. Previous studies indicate that CO2 delivery to and from buried structures that host CO2 accumulations is fault controlled, but that competing controls on the CO2 flow pathways affect the location and style of CO2 release. Here, we conduct a meta-analysis using a novel geospatial approach to statistically determine the relationship between geological setting and structures and the CO2 seep spatial distribution and characteristics (morphological type, flux and temperature) in central Italy. We find that seep distribution differs on two spatial scales corresponding to geological setting. On large scales (>5 km) seeps are isotropically distributed and align with regional structures such as anticlines, decollements, and extensional faults. On local scales (<5 km) seeps cluster and align with subsidiary geologic structures, including faults and lithological boundaries. The detailed location and flux of seeps within clusters is influenced by regional structural domain: in the Tyrrhenian seeps tend to be located along fault traces; whereas seeps are located as springs in tip and ramp regions of fault scarps in the Apennines. Thus, our geospatial approach evidences, at a regional scale, how macro-crustal fluid flow is governed by deep extensional and compressional features, but, once CO2 reaches shallower structures, how smaller-scale features and hydrogeological factors distribute the CO2 fluids in the near-surface, dependent on the geological setting. This work not only demonstrates useful application of a novel geospatial approach to characterize competing crustal controls on CO2 flow at different scales, but also informs the design of appropriate site characterization and surface monitoring programs at engineered carbon stores.

KW - CO2 seeps

KW - crustal fluid flow

KW - CO2 storage

KW - geographical information systems (GIS)

KW - site characterization

KW - Italy

U2 - 10.1155/2019/8147345

DO - 10.1155/2019/8147345

M3 - Article

VL - 2019

JO - Geofluids

T2 - Geofluids

JF - Geofluids

SN - 1468-8115

M1 - 8147345

ER -