French security and a British 'continental commitment' after the first world war: a reassessment

Peter Jackson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In his classic study Britain and France between two World Wars, Arnold Wolfers characterised ‘British support’ as the ‘conditio sine qua non’ of French security policy. Wolfers argued that only an alliance with Britain would enable France to deter a German bid to revise the Treaty of Versailles by force. France’s ‘entire post-war foreign policy’, he judged, could be characterised as ‘a continuous struggle to get Britain to pledge her support to France’. This conclusion has rightly become a cornerstone of the historiography of international relations between the wars. Yet there has been surprisingly little examination of the precise character of the security commitment desired from Britain by France. Historians have tended to assume that throughout the inter-war period French policy aimed consistently at a resurrection of the 1914-1918 military alliance. This judgement does not hold up to careful scrutiny. The essay that follows will argue that the commitment sought from Britain between 1919 and 1925 evolved from that of a traditional military ally to that of joint-guarantor of a Europe-wide system of inter-locking arbitration and mutual assistance pacts.
LanguageEnglish
Pages345-385
Number of pages41
JournalEnglish Historical Review
VolumeCCXXVI
Issue number519
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Apr 2011

Fingerprint

Continental
World War I
France
Military
Alliances
Security Policy
International Relations
Foreign Policy
Interwar Period
Versailles
Pact
Historian
Scrutiny
Resurrection
Second World War
Historiography
Arbitration
Treaties
Allies

Keywords

  • French
  • British
  • security
  • continental commitment
  • world war 1

Cite this

@article{ba5615ab3c0c40b9a91082a93ca02444,
title = "French security and a British 'continental commitment' after the first world war: a reassessment",
abstract = "In his classic study Britain and France between two World Wars, Arnold Wolfers characterised ‘British support’ as the ‘conditio sine qua non’ of French security policy. Wolfers argued that only an alliance with Britain would enable France to deter a German bid to revise the Treaty of Versailles by force. France’s ‘entire post-war foreign policy’, he judged, could be characterised as ‘a continuous struggle to get Britain to pledge her support to France’. This conclusion has rightly become a cornerstone of the historiography of international relations between the wars. Yet there has been surprisingly little examination of the precise character of the security commitment desired from Britain by France. Historians have tended to assume that throughout the inter-war period French policy aimed consistently at a resurrection of the 1914-1918 military alliance. This judgement does not hold up to careful scrutiny. The essay that follows will argue that the commitment sought from Britain between 1919 and 1925 evolved from that of a traditional military ally to that of joint-guarantor of a Europe-wide system of inter-locking arbitration and mutual assistance pacts.",
keywords = "French , British, security, continental commitment, world war 1",
author = "Peter Jackson",
year = "2011",
month = "4",
doi = "10.1093/ehr/cer074",
language = "English",
volume = "CCXXVI",
pages = "345--385",
journal = "English Historical Review",
issn = "0013-8266",
number = "519",

}

French security and a British 'continental commitment' after the first world war : a reassessment. / Jackson, Peter.

In: English Historical Review, Vol. CCXXVI, No. 519, 04.2011, p. 345-385.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - French security and a British 'continental commitment' after the first world war

T2 - English Historical Review

AU - Jackson, Peter

PY - 2011/4

Y1 - 2011/4

N2 - In his classic study Britain and France between two World Wars, Arnold Wolfers characterised ‘British support’ as the ‘conditio sine qua non’ of French security policy. Wolfers argued that only an alliance with Britain would enable France to deter a German bid to revise the Treaty of Versailles by force. France’s ‘entire post-war foreign policy’, he judged, could be characterised as ‘a continuous struggle to get Britain to pledge her support to France’. This conclusion has rightly become a cornerstone of the historiography of international relations between the wars. Yet there has been surprisingly little examination of the precise character of the security commitment desired from Britain by France. Historians have tended to assume that throughout the inter-war period French policy aimed consistently at a resurrection of the 1914-1918 military alliance. This judgement does not hold up to careful scrutiny. The essay that follows will argue that the commitment sought from Britain between 1919 and 1925 evolved from that of a traditional military ally to that of joint-guarantor of a Europe-wide system of inter-locking arbitration and mutual assistance pacts.

AB - In his classic study Britain and France between two World Wars, Arnold Wolfers characterised ‘British support’ as the ‘conditio sine qua non’ of French security policy. Wolfers argued that only an alliance with Britain would enable France to deter a German bid to revise the Treaty of Versailles by force. France’s ‘entire post-war foreign policy’, he judged, could be characterised as ‘a continuous struggle to get Britain to pledge her support to France’. This conclusion has rightly become a cornerstone of the historiography of international relations between the wars. Yet there has been surprisingly little examination of the precise character of the security commitment desired from Britain by France. Historians have tended to assume that throughout the inter-war period French policy aimed consistently at a resurrection of the 1914-1918 military alliance. This judgement does not hold up to careful scrutiny. The essay that follows will argue that the commitment sought from Britain between 1919 and 1925 evolved from that of a traditional military ally to that of joint-guarantor of a Europe-wide system of inter-locking arbitration and mutual assistance pacts.

KW - French

KW - British

KW - security

KW - continental commitment

KW - world war 1

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=79960139039&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1093/ehr/cer074

DO - 10.1093/ehr/cer074

M3 - Article

VL - CCXXVI

SP - 345

EP - 385

JO - English Historical Review

JF - English Historical Review

SN - 0013-8266

IS - 519

ER -