For better or worse: joinery apprenticeships in Scotland

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

The revival of apprenticeships in the UK via the Modern Apprenticeship framework is reportedly serving to erode the quality and reputation of traditional apprenticeships. UK construction employers, moreover, report growing problems of recruitment and skill within trade occupations. Construction trade apprenticeship arrangements in Scotland, however, are based around a social partnership-type approach more closely aligned to European counterparts than the rest of the UK. Drawing on an in-depth case study of Scottish joiners, this paper examines changes in apprenticeship arrangements and reported problems of recruitment and skill by locating this model of initial skill formation within the broader context of a joinery skill ecosystem. It is argued that the adaptation of historical apprenticeship arrangements, underpinned by the central role of the Scottish Building Apprenticeship Training Council (SBATC), has been relatively successful, thus far, in offsetting countervailing trends witnessed elsewhere in the UK. Yet, the determination to ‘cling’ on to these arrangements presents longer-term challenges because plus c’est la même chose, plus sa change. The on-going fragmentation of the construction industry means that small, and increasingly specialist, companies tend to employ apprentices and many are not developing the full array of skills that have been the hallmark of the all-round, multi-skilled, Scottish joiner. New products and processes within the industry are also altering the nature of skill demand and deployment. Furthermore, this determination to cling on to traditional apprenticeship arrangements, it is suggested, has not assisted the large numbers of Scottish joinery apprentices ‘orphaned’ in the current global economic downturn.

Conference

ConferenceSASE 23rd Annual Conference 2011. Transformations of Contemporary Capitalism: Actors, Institutions, Processes
CountrySpain
CityMadrid
Period23/06/1125/06/11

Fingerprint

Scotland
Apprenticeship
Employers
Fragmentation
Apprenticeship training
Social partnership
Construction industry
Ecosystem
New products
Economic downturn
Skill formation
Industry

Keywords

  • joinery apprenticeships
  • scotland
  • apprenticeship
  • trade occupations
  • modern apprenticeship framework

Cite this

Anderson, P. (2011). For better or worse: joinery apprenticeships in Scotland. Paper presented at SASE 23rd Annual Conference 2011. Transformations of Contemporary Capitalism: Actors, Institutions, Processes, Madrid, Spain.
Anderson, Pauline. / For better or worse : joinery apprenticeships in Scotland. Paper presented at SASE 23rd Annual Conference 2011. Transformations of Contemporary Capitalism: Actors, Institutions, Processes, Madrid, Spain.
@conference{f3205003c83746c6af52b300a1216718,
title = "For better or worse: joinery apprenticeships in Scotland",
abstract = "The revival of apprenticeships in the UK via the Modern Apprenticeship framework is reportedly serving to erode the quality and reputation of traditional apprenticeships. UK construction employers, moreover, report growing problems of recruitment and skill within trade occupations. Construction trade apprenticeship arrangements in Scotland, however, are based around a social partnership-type approach more closely aligned to European counterparts than the rest of the UK. Drawing on an in-depth case study of Scottish joiners, this paper examines changes in apprenticeship arrangements and reported problems of recruitment and skill by locating this model of initial skill formation within the broader context of a joinery skill ecosystem. It is argued that the adaptation of historical apprenticeship arrangements, underpinned by the central role of the Scottish Building Apprenticeship Training Council (SBATC), has been relatively successful, thus far, in offsetting countervailing trends witnessed elsewhere in the UK. Yet, the determination to ‘cling’ on to these arrangements presents longer-term challenges because plus c’est la m{\^e}me chose, plus sa change. The on-going fragmentation of the construction industry means that small, and increasingly specialist, companies tend to employ apprentices and many are not developing the full array of skills that have been the hallmark of the all-round, multi-skilled, Scottish joiner. New products and processes within the industry are also altering the nature of skill demand and deployment. Furthermore, this determination to cling on to traditional apprenticeship arrangements, it is suggested, has not assisted the large numbers of Scottish joinery apprentices ‘orphaned’ in the current global economic downturn.",
keywords = "joinery apprenticeships, scotland, apprenticeship, trade occupations, modern apprenticeship framework",
author = "Pauline Anderson",
year = "2011",
language = "English",
note = "SASE 23rd Annual Conference 2011. Transformations of Contemporary Capitalism: Actors, Institutions, Processes ; Conference date: 23-06-2011 Through 25-06-2011",

}

Anderson, P 2011, 'For better or worse: joinery apprenticeships in Scotland' Paper presented at SASE 23rd Annual Conference 2011. Transformations of Contemporary Capitalism: Actors, Institutions, Processes, Madrid, Spain, 23/06/11 - 25/06/11, .

For better or worse : joinery apprenticeships in Scotland. / Anderson, Pauline.

2011. Paper presented at SASE 23rd Annual Conference 2011. Transformations of Contemporary Capitalism: Actors, Institutions, Processes, Madrid, Spain.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - For better or worse

T2 - joinery apprenticeships in Scotland

AU - Anderson, Pauline

PY - 2011

Y1 - 2011

N2 - The revival of apprenticeships in the UK via the Modern Apprenticeship framework is reportedly serving to erode the quality and reputation of traditional apprenticeships. UK construction employers, moreover, report growing problems of recruitment and skill within trade occupations. Construction trade apprenticeship arrangements in Scotland, however, are based around a social partnership-type approach more closely aligned to European counterparts than the rest of the UK. Drawing on an in-depth case study of Scottish joiners, this paper examines changes in apprenticeship arrangements and reported problems of recruitment and skill by locating this model of initial skill formation within the broader context of a joinery skill ecosystem. It is argued that the adaptation of historical apprenticeship arrangements, underpinned by the central role of the Scottish Building Apprenticeship Training Council (SBATC), has been relatively successful, thus far, in offsetting countervailing trends witnessed elsewhere in the UK. Yet, the determination to ‘cling’ on to these arrangements presents longer-term challenges because plus c’est la même chose, plus sa change. The on-going fragmentation of the construction industry means that small, and increasingly specialist, companies tend to employ apprentices and many are not developing the full array of skills that have been the hallmark of the all-round, multi-skilled, Scottish joiner. New products and processes within the industry are also altering the nature of skill demand and deployment. Furthermore, this determination to cling on to traditional apprenticeship arrangements, it is suggested, has not assisted the large numbers of Scottish joinery apprentices ‘orphaned’ in the current global economic downturn.

AB - The revival of apprenticeships in the UK via the Modern Apprenticeship framework is reportedly serving to erode the quality and reputation of traditional apprenticeships. UK construction employers, moreover, report growing problems of recruitment and skill within trade occupations. Construction trade apprenticeship arrangements in Scotland, however, are based around a social partnership-type approach more closely aligned to European counterparts than the rest of the UK. Drawing on an in-depth case study of Scottish joiners, this paper examines changes in apprenticeship arrangements and reported problems of recruitment and skill by locating this model of initial skill formation within the broader context of a joinery skill ecosystem. It is argued that the adaptation of historical apprenticeship arrangements, underpinned by the central role of the Scottish Building Apprenticeship Training Council (SBATC), has been relatively successful, thus far, in offsetting countervailing trends witnessed elsewhere in the UK. Yet, the determination to ‘cling’ on to these arrangements presents longer-term challenges because plus c’est la même chose, plus sa change. The on-going fragmentation of the construction industry means that small, and increasingly specialist, companies tend to employ apprentices and many are not developing the full array of skills that have been the hallmark of the all-round, multi-skilled, Scottish joiner. New products and processes within the industry are also altering the nature of skill demand and deployment. Furthermore, this determination to cling on to traditional apprenticeship arrangements, it is suggested, has not assisted the large numbers of Scottish joinery apprentices ‘orphaned’ in the current global economic downturn.

KW - joinery apprenticeships

KW - scotland

KW - apprenticeship

KW - trade occupations

KW - modern apprenticeship framework

UR - https://sase.org/call-for-papers/in-english_fr_88.html

M3 - Paper

ER -

Anderson P. For better or worse: joinery apprenticeships in Scotland. 2011. Paper presented at SASE 23rd Annual Conference 2011. Transformations of Contemporary Capitalism: Actors, Institutions, Processes, Madrid, Spain.