"Fascinating scalpel-wielders and fair dissectors": women’s experience of Irish medical education, c.1880s-1920s

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

9 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

... Though all the world’s a stage and we are acting,
Yet still I think your part is not dissecting,
To me the art of making apple tarts
Would suit you better than those “horrid parts”.
In times to come when queens at home you are,
There’ll be more rapture in the light guitar.
Your knowledge—of the frog should only be
How they are cooked in France—or making tea!
And as for learning Chemistry and that
’Twould be a nicer thing to trim a hat.
I know your aims in medicine are true
But tell me is there any need of you?1

This poem, entitled Ode to the lady medicals and published in 1902 in St. Stephen's, the student magazine of the Catholic University in Dublin, questions the relatively recent undertaking of medical education by women. Although admittedly tongue-in-cheek, it highlights some of the prevalent attitudes towards the admission of women to medicine, a subject that had faced fierce criticism from some.2 Certainly, this poem strongly suggests that a woman's place should be in the home, learning how to cook frogs rather than how to dissect them, and that women should concern themselves with more feminine activities such as hat-trimming. Moreover, it ends on the question of whether there was actually any need for women doctors, highlighting fears about the overcrowded medical marketplace.
LanguageEnglish
Pages495-516
Number of pages22
JournalMedical History
Volume54
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2010

Fingerprint

Medical Education
Anura
Medicine
Learning
Malus
Tea
France
Fear
1920s
Students
Light
Hat
Poem
Frog

Keywords

  • education, medical
  • female
  • gender identity
  • history, 19th century
  • history, 20th century
  • humans
  • Ireland
  • male
  • woman

Cite this

@article{7e31a832308f41289c76ab22ab1ba86f,
title = "{"}Fascinating scalpel-wielders and fair dissectors{"}: women’s experience of Irish medical education, c.1880s-1920s",
abstract = "... Though all the world’s a stage and we are acting,Yet still I think your part is not dissecting,To me the art of making apple tartsWould suit you better than those “horrid parts”.In times to come when queens at home you are,There’ll be more rapture in the light guitar.Your knowledge—of the frog should only beHow they are cooked in France—or making tea!And as for learning Chemistry and that’Twould be a nicer thing to trim a hat.I know your aims in medicine are trueBut tell me is there any need of you?1This poem, entitled Ode to the lady medicals and published in 1902 in St. Stephen's, the student magazine of the Catholic University in Dublin, questions the relatively recent undertaking of medical education by women. Although admittedly tongue-in-cheek, it highlights some of the prevalent attitudes towards the admission of women to medicine, a subject that had faced fierce criticism from some.2 Certainly, this poem strongly suggests that a woman's place should be in the home, learning how to cook frogs rather than how to dissect them, and that women should concern themselves with more feminine activities such as hat-trimming. Moreover, it ends on the question of whether there was actually any need for women doctors, highlighting fears about the overcrowded medical marketplace.",
keywords = "education, medical, female, gender identity, history, 19th century, history, 20th century, humans, Ireland, male, woman",
author = "Laura Kelly",
year = "2010",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1017/S0025727300006384",
language = "English",
volume = "54",
pages = "495--516",
journal = "Medical History",
issn = "0025-7273",
number = "4",

}

"Fascinating scalpel-wielders and fair dissectors" : women’s experience of Irish medical education, c.1880s-1920s. / Kelly, Laura.

In: Medical History, Vol. 54, No. 4, 10.2010, p. 495-516.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - "Fascinating scalpel-wielders and fair dissectors"

T2 - Medical History

AU - Kelly, Laura

PY - 2010/10

Y1 - 2010/10

N2 - ... Though all the world’s a stage and we are acting,Yet still I think your part is not dissecting,To me the art of making apple tartsWould suit you better than those “horrid parts”.In times to come when queens at home you are,There’ll be more rapture in the light guitar.Your knowledge—of the frog should only beHow they are cooked in France—or making tea!And as for learning Chemistry and that’Twould be a nicer thing to trim a hat.I know your aims in medicine are trueBut tell me is there any need of you?1This poem, entitled Ode to the lady medicals and published in 1902 in St. Stephen's, the student magazine of the Catholic University in Dublin, questions the relatively recent undertaking of medical education by women. Although admittedly tongue-in-cheek, it highlights some of the prevalent attitudes towards the admission of women to medicine, a subject that had faced fierce criticism from some.2 Certainly, this poem strongly suggests that a woman's place should be in the home, learning how to cook frogs rather than how to dissect them, and that women should concern themselves with more feminine activities such as hat-trimming. Moreover, it ends on the question of whether there was actually any need for women doctors, highlighting fears about the overcrowded medical marketplace.

AB - ... Though all the world’s a stage and we are acting,Yet still I think your part is not dissecting,To me the art of making apple tartsWould suit you better than those “horrid parts”.In times to come when queens at home you are,There’ll be more rapture in the light guitar.Your knowledge—of the frog should only beHow they are cooked in France—or making tea!And as for learning Chemistry and that’Twould be a nicer thing to trim a hat.I know your aims in medicine are trueBut tell me is there any need of you?1This poem, entitled Ode to the lady medicals and published in 1902 in St. Stephen's, the student magazine of the Catholic University in Dublin, questions the relatively recent undertaking of medical education by women. Although admittedly tongue-in-cheek, it highlights some of the prevalent attitudes towards the admission of women to medicine, a subject that had faced fierce criticism from some.2 Certainly, this poem strongly suggests that a woman's place should be in the home, learning how to cook frogs rather than how to dissect them, and that women should concern themselves with more feminine activities such as hat-trimming. Moreover, it ends on the question of whether there was actually any need for women doctors, highlighting fears about the overcrowded medical marketplace.

KW - education, medical

KW - female

KW - gender identity

KW - history, 19th century

KW - history, 20th century

KW - humans

KW - Ireland

KW - male

KW - woman

UR - http://journals.cambridge.org/action/displayJournal?jid=MDH

U2 - 10.1017/S0025727300006384

DO - 10.1017/S0025727300006384

M3 - Article

VL - 54

SP - 495

EP - 516

JO - Medical History

JF - Medical History

SN - 0025-7273

IS - 4

ER -