Exploring decisions' influence on life-cycle performance to aid 'design for Multi-X'

Jonathan C. Borg, Xiu Tian Yan, Neal P. Juster

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

21 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The problem addressed in this paper is that design decisions can have a propagation effect spanning multiple life-phases influencing life-cycle metrics such as cost, time, and quality. It introduces a computational framework of a `Knowledge of life-cycle Consequences (KC) approach' aimed at allowing designers to foresee and explore effectively unintended, solution specific life-cycle consequences (LCCs) during solution synthesis. The paper presents a phenomena model describing how LCCs are generated from two fundamentally different conditions: noninteracting and interacting synthesis decision commitments. Based on this understanding, the KC approach framework has been developed and implemented as a Knowledge-Intensive CAD (KICAD) tool named FORESEE. The framework consists of three frames: an artefact life modelling frame, an operational frame, and an LCC knowledge modelling frame. This paper focuses on the knowledge modelling frame, composed basically of synthesis elements, consequence inference knowledge, and consequence action knowledge. To evaluate the influence of design decision consequences on artefact life-phases, cost, time and quality performance measures are used within the frame. Using these metrics, the life-cycle implications of a decision can be instantly updated and fully appreciated. An evaluation of the approach was carried out by applying FORESEE to thermoplastic component design. The results provide a degree of evidence that the approach integrates the activity of component design synthesis with the activity of foreseeing artefact life issues including fluctuations in life-cycle metrics. This makes the approach fundamentally different from the conventional approach in which first a candidate design solution is generated and then, at a penalty of extra time, an analysis of the solution for conflicts with artefact life issues is carried out. The framework thus provides a significant step towards the realization of a `Design Synthesis for Multi-X' approach to component design, although further work is required to exploit practically its utilization.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)91-113
Number of pages23
JournalArtificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing: AIEDAM
Volume14
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Apr 2000

Fingerprint

Design aids
Life cycle
Thermoplastics
Costs
Computer aided design

Keywords

  • life-cycle modelling
  • life-cycle metrics

Cite this

@article{3d5807c9f12b4e8f8bd6c93b39eeb8d3,
title = "Exploring decisions' influence on life-cycle performance to aid 'design for Multi-X'",
abstract = "The problem addressed in this paper is that design decisions can have a propagation effect spanning multiple life-phases influencing life-cycle metrics such as cost, time, and quality. It introduces a computational framework of a `Knowledge of life-cycle Consequences (KC) approach' aimed at allowing designers to foresee and explore effectively unintended, solution specific life-cycle consequences (LCCs) during solution synthesis. The paper presents a phenomena model describing how LCCs are generated from two fundamentally different conditions: noninteracting and interacting synthesis decision commitments. Based on this understanding, the KC approach framework has been developed and implemented as a Knowledge-Intensive CAD (KICAD) tool named FORESEE. The framework consists of three frames: an artefact life modelling frame, an operational frame, and an LCC knowledge modelling frame. This paper focuses on the knowledge modelling frame, composed basically of synthesis elements, consequence inference knowledge, and consequence action knowledge. To evaluate the influence of design decision consequences on artefact life-phases, cost, time and quality performance measures are used within the frame. Using these metrics, the life-cycle implications of a decision can be instantly updated and fully appreciated. An evaluation of the approach was carried out by applying FORESEE to thermoplastic component design. The results provide a degree of evidence that the approach integrates the activity of component design synthesis with the activity of foreseeing artefact life issues including fluctuations in life-cycle metrics. This makes the approach fundamentally different from the conventional approach in which first a candidate design solution is generated and then, at a penalty of extra time, an analysis of the solution for conflicts with artefact life issues is carried out. The framework thus provides a significant step towards the realization of a `Design Synthesis for Multi-X' approach to component design, although further work is required to exploit practically its utilization.",
keywords = "life-cycle modelling, life-cycle metrics",
author = "Borg, {Jonathan C.} and Yan, {Xiu Tian} and Juster, {Neal P.}",
year = "2000",
month = "4",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1017/S0890060400142015",
language = "English",
volume = "14",
pages = "91--113",
journal = "AI EDAM",
issn = "0890-0604",
number = "2",

}

Exploring decisions' influence on life-cycle performance to aid 'design for Multi-X'. / Borg, Jonathan C.; Yan, Xiu Tian; Juster, Neal P.

In: Artificial Intelligence for Engineering Design, Analysis and Manufacturing: AIEDAM, Vol. 14, No. 2, 01.04.2000, p. 91-113.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Exploring decisions' influence on life-cycle performance to aid 'design for Multi-X'

AU - Borg, Jonathan C.

AU - Yan, Xiu Tian

AU - Juster, Neal P.

PY - 2000/4/1

Y1 - 2000/4/1

N2 - The problem addressed in this paper is that design decisions can have a propagation effect spanning multiple life-phases influencing life-cycle metrics such as cost, time, and quality. It introduces a computational framework of a `Knowledge of life-cycle Consequences (KC) approach' aimed at allowing designers to foresee and explore effectively unintended, solution specific life-cycle consequences (LCCs) during solution synthesis. The paper presents a phenomena model describing how LCCs are generated from two fundamentally different conditions: noninteracting and interacting synthesis decision commitments. Based on this understanding, the KC approach framework has been developed and implemented as a Knowledge-Intensive CAD (KICAD) tool named FORESEE. The framework consists of three frames: an artefact life modelling frame, an operational frame, and an LCC knowledge modelling frame. This paper focuses on the knowledge modelling frame, composed basically of synthesis elements, consequence inference knowledge, and consequence action knowledge. To evaluate the influence of design decision consequences on artefact life-phases, cost, time and quality performance measures are used within the frame. Using these metrics, the life-cycle implications of a decision can be instantly updated and fully appreciated. An evaluation of the approach was carried out by applying FORESEE to thermoplastic component design. The results provide a degree of evidence that the approach integrates the activity of component design synthesis with the activity of foreseeing artefact life issues including fluctuations in life-cycle metrics. This makes the approach fundamentally different from the conventional approach in which first a candidate design solution is generated and then, at a penalty of extra time, an analysis of the solution for conflicts with artefact life issues is carried out. The framework thus provides a significant step towards the realization of a `Design Synthesis for Multi-X' approach to component design, although further work is required to exploit practically its utilization.

AB - The problem addressed in this paper is that design decisions can have a propagation effect spanning multiple life-phases influencing life-cycle metrics such as cost, time, and quality. It introduces a computational framework of a `Knowledge of life-cycle Consequences (KC) approach' aimed at allowing designers to foresee and explore effectively unintended, solution specific life-cycle consequences (LCCs) during solution synthesis. The paper presents a phenomena model describing how LCCs are generated from two fundamentally different conditions: noninteracting and interacting synthesis decision commitments. Based on this understanding, the KC approach framework has been developed and implemented as a Knowledge-Intensive CAD (KICAD) tool named FORESEE. The framework consists of three frames: an artefact life modelling frame, an operational frame, and an LCC knowledge modelling frame. This paper focuses on the knowledge modelling frame, composed basically of synthesis elements, consequence inference knowledge, and consequence action knowledge. To evaluate the influence of design decision consequences on artefact life-phases, cost, time and quality performance measures are used within the frame. Using these metrics, the life-cycle implications of a decision can be instantly updated and fully appreciated. An evaluation of the approach was carried out by applying FORESEE to thermoplastic component design. The results provide a degree of evidence that the approach integrates the activity of component design synthesis with the activity of foreseeing artefact life issues including fluctuations in life-cycle metrics. This makes the approach fundamentally different from the conventional approach in which first a candidate design solution is generated and then, at a penalty of extra time, an analysis of the solution for conflicts with artefact life issues is carried out. The framework thus provides a significant step towards the realization of a `Design Synthesis for Multi-X' approach to component design, although further work is required to exploit practically its utilization.

KW - life-cycle modelling

KW - life-cycle metrics

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=0034172009&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1017/S0890060400142015

DO - 10.1017/S0890060400142015

M3 - Article

VL - 14

SP - 91

EP - 113

JO - AI EDAM

JF - AI EDAM

SN - 0890-0604

IS - 2

ER -