Excellence and education: rhetoric and reality

D.J.M. Gillies

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

'Excellence' has been a prevalent term in New Labour rhetoric on education, most notably in the stated goal of 'excellence for all' in education. Despite that, the meaning of the term has remained imprecise, and the implications of universal excellence unclear. In this paper, three distinct definitions of excellence are identified and the practicality considered of each as a universal goal for public sector education. The paper also suggests that the emphasis on excellence can be seen, both currently and historically, as a response to 'crisis narratives' in official discourse. In further accounting for the word's current ubiquity, its links to Total Quality Management theory are outlined, exposing its essential neo-liberal roots in the world of the market, and in ill-founded attempts to evaluate schools with the tools of the private sector. Taking account of recent work on New Labour rhetoric, and discourse analysis, the paper concludes that ambiguity of meaning and strong connotative power, mark 'excellence' as a 'keyword' and 'condensation symbol' in public discourse rather than as a genuine political goal.
LanguageEnglish
Pages19-36
Number of pages17
JournalEducation, Knowledge and Economy
Volume1
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Mar 2007

Fingerprint

rhetoric
New Labour
education
political goal
discourse
quality assurance
discourse analysis
private sector
symbol
public sector
narrative
market
school

Keywords

  • excellence
  • new labour
  • total quality management
  • crisis narrative
  • discourse analysis
  • keyword
  • condensation symbol

Cite this

Gillies, D.J.M. / Excellence and education: rhetoric and reality. In: Education, Knowledge and Economy. 2007 ; Vol. 1, No. 1. pp. 19-36.
@article{8c6d1bd0d1c148cdbff3189bac84954a,
title = "Excellence and education: rhetoric and reality",
abstract = "'Excellence' has been a prevalent term in New Labour rhetoric on education, most notably in the stated goal of 'excellence for all' in education. Despite that, the meaning of the term has remained imprecise, and the implications of universal excellence unclear. In this paper, three distinct definitions of excellence are identified and the practicality considered of each as a universal goal for public sector education. The paper also suggests that the emphasis on excellence can be seen, both currently and historically, as a response to 'crisis narratives' in official discourse. In further accounting for the word's current ubiquity, its links to Total Quality Management theory are outlined, exposing its essential neo-liberal roots in the world of the market, and in ill-founded attempts to evaluate schools with the tools of the private sector. Taking account of recent work on New Labour rhetoric, and discourse analysis, the paper concludes that ambiguity of meaning and strong connotative power, mark 'excellence' as a 'keyword' and 'condensation symbol' in public discourse rather than as a genuine political goal.",
keywords = "excellence, new labour, total quality management, crisis narrative, discourse analysis, keyword, condensation symbol",
author = "D.J.M. Gillies",
year = "2007",
month = "3",
doi = "10.1080/17496890601128209",
language = "English",
volume = "1",
pages = "19--36",
journal = "Education, Knowledge and Economy",
issn = "1749-6896",
number = "1",

}

Excellence and education: rhetoric and reality. / Gillies, D.J.M.

In: Education, Knowledge and Economy, Vol. 1, No. 1, 03.2007, p. 19-36.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Excellence and education: rhetoric and reality

AU - Gillies, D.J.M.

PY - 2007/3

Y1 - 2007/3

N2 - 'Excellence' has been a prevalent term in New Labour rhetoric on education, most notably in the stated goal of 'excellence for all' in education. Despite that, the meaning of the term has remained imprecise, and the implications of universal excellence unclear. In this paper, three distinct definitions of excellence are identified and the practicality considered of each as a universal goal for public sector education. The paper also suggests that the emphasis on excellence can be seen, both currently and historically, as a response to 'crisis narratives' in official discourse. In further accounting for the word's current ubiquity, its links to Total Quality Management theory are outlined, exposing its essential neo-liberal roots in the world of the market, and in ill-founded attempts to evaluate schools with the tools of the private sector. Taking account of recent work on New Labour rhetoric, and discourse analysis, the paper concludes that ambiguity of meaning and strong connotative power, mark 'excellence' as a 'keyword' and 'condensation symbol' in public discourse rather than as a genuine political goal.

AB - 'Excellence' has been a prevalent term in New Labour rhetoric on education, most notably in the stated goal of 'excellence for all' in education. Despite that, the meaning of the term has remained imprecise, and the implications of universal excellence unclear. In this paper, three distinct definitions of excellence are identified and the practicality considered of each as a universal goal for public sector education. The paper also suggests that the emphasis on excellence can be seen, both currently and historically, as a response to 'crisis narratives' in official discourse. In further accounting for the word's current ubiquity, its links to Total Quality Management theory are outlined, exposing its essential neo-liberal roots in the world of the market, and in ill-founded attempts to evaluate schools with the tools of the private sector. Taking account of recent work on New Labour rhetoric, and discourse analysis, the paper concludes that ambiguity of meaning and strong connotative power, mark 'excellence' as a 'keyword' and 'condensation symbol' in public discourse rather than as a genuine political goal.

KW - excellence

KW - new labour

KW - total quality management

KW - crisis narrative

KW - discourse analysis

KW - keyword

KW - condensation symbol

UR - http://dx.doi.org/10.1080/17496890601128209

U2 - 10.1080/17496890601128209

DO - 10.1080/17496890601128209

M3 - Article

VL - 1

SP - 19

EP - 36

JO - Education, Knowledge and Economy

T2 - Education, Knowledge and Economy

JF - Education, Knowledge and Economy

SN - 1749-6896

IS - 1

ER -