'Everybody's Scottish at the end of the day': nationalism and social justice amongst young Yes voters

Maddie Breeze, Hugo Gorringe, Lynn Jamieson, Michael Rosie

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

In the wake of the diverse mobilization for Yes in the 2014 Independence Referendum and unprecedented SNP gains in the 2015 General Election, a number of commentators deployed a rhetoric of 'dangerous nationalism' by way of explanation and criticism. Such an interpretation is refuted by survey evidence and complicated by sociologies of nationalism and national identity. This short article joins these debates, and presents analysis of ten explorative interviews conducted with young Yes voters between the Referendum and the General Election. There is no simple narrative of 'nationalism' in these young people's accounts. Some explicitly distanced themselves from nationalist sentiment, emphasising a commitment to social justice as their key motivation for Yes. Others shared this primary concern but expressed it as overlapping with a national(ist) identity in complex ways. While disavowals of 'romantic' or 'narrow' nationalism occur on both sides of the independence debate, this study points to how more banal, and nuanced discourses of national(ist) identity underpin respondents' explanations for voting Yes.
LanguageEnglish
Pages419-431
Number of pages13
JournalScottish Affairs
Volume24
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 2015

Fingerprint

social justice
nationalism
national identity
referendum
election
voting
mobilization
rhetoric
criticism
commitment
narrative
interpretation
discourse
interview
evidence

Keywords

  • nationalism
  • national identity
  • youth
  • Scottish independence referendum 2014
  • general election 2015

Cite this

Breeze, Maddie ; Gorringe, Hugo ; Jamieson, Lynn ; Rosie, Michael. / 'Everybody's Scottish at the end of the day' : nationalism and social justice amongst young Yes voters. In: Scottish Affairs. 2015 ; Vol. 24, No. 4. pp. 419-431.
@article{ef04ead7d09c431789bebfedb87f2f0d,
title = "'Everybody's Scottish at the end of the day': nationalism and social justice amongst young Yes voters",
abstract = "In the wake of the diverse mobilization for Yes in the 2014 Independence Referendum and unprecedented SNP gains in the 2015 General Election, a number of commentators deployed a rhetoric of 'dangerous nationalism' by way of explanation and criticism. Such an interpretation is refuted by survey evidence and complicated by sociologies of nationalism and national identity. This short article joins these debates, and presents analysis of ten explorative interviews conducted with young Yes voters between the Referendum and the General Election. There is no simple narrative of 'nationalism' in these young people's accounts. Some explicitly distanced themselves from nationalist sentiment, emphasising a commitment to social justice as their key motivation for Yes. Others shared this primary concern but expressed it as overlapping with a national(ist) identity in complex ways. While disavowals of 'romantic' or 'narrow' nationalism occur on both sides of the independence debate, this study points to how more banal, and nuanced discourses of national(ist) identity underpin respondents' explanations for voting Yes.",
keywords = "nationalism, national identity, youth, Scottish independence referendum 2014, general election 2015",
author = "Maddie Breeze and Hugo Gorringe and Lynn Jamieson and Michael Rosie",
year = "2015",
doi = "10.3366/scot.2015.0094",
language = "English",
volume = "24",
pages = "419--431",
journal = "Scottish Affairs",
issn = "0966-0356",
publisher = "Edinburgh University Press",
number = "4",

}

'Everybody's Scottish at the end of the day' : nationalism and social justice amongst young Yes voters. / Breeze, Maddie; Gorringe, Hugo; Jamieson, Lynn; Rosie, Michael.

In: Scottish Affairs, Vol. 24, No. 4, 2015, p. 419-431.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - 'Everybody's Scottish at the end of the day'

T2 - Scottish Affairs

AU - Breeze, Maddie

AU - Gorringe, Hugo

AU - Jamieson, Lynn

AU - Rosie, Michael

PY - 2015

Y1 - 2015

N2 - In the wake of the diverse mobilization for Yes in the 2014 Independence Referendum and unprecedented SNP gains in the 2015 General Election, a number of commentators deployed a rhetoric of 'dangerous nationalism' by way of explanation and criticism. Such an interpretation is refuted by survey evidence and complicated by sociologies of nationalism and national identity. This short article joins these debates, and presents analysis of ten explorative interviews conducted with young Yes voters between the Referendum and the General Election. There is no simple narrative of 'nationalism' in these young people's accounts. Some explicitly distanced themselves from nationalist sentiment, emphasising a commitment to social justice as their key motivation for Yes. Others shared this primary concern but expressed it as overlapping with a national(ist) identity in complex ways. While disavowals of 'romantic' or 'narrow' nationalism occur on both sides of the independence debate, this study points to how more banal, and nuanced discourses of national(ist) identity underpin respondents' explanations for voting Yes.

AB - In the wake of the diverse mobilization for Yes in the 2014 Independence Referendum and unprecedented SNP gains in the 2015 General Election, a number of commentators deployed a rhetoric of 'dangerous nationalism' by way of explanation and criticism. Such an interpretation is refuted by survey evidence and complicated by sociologies of nationalism and national identity. This short article joins these debates, and presents analysis of ten explorative interviews conducted with young Yes voters between the Referendum and the General Election. There is no simple narrative of 'nationalism' in these young people's accounts. Some explicitly distanced themselves from nationalist sentiment, emphasising a commitment to social justice as their key motivation for Yes. Others shared this primary concern but expressed it as overlapping with a national(ist) identity in complex ways. While disavowals of 'romantic' or 'narrow' nationalism occur on both sides of the independence debate, this study points to how more banal, and nuanced discourses of national(ist) identity underpin respondents' explanations for voting Yes.

KW - nationalism

KW - national identity

KW - youth

KW - Scottish independence referendum 2014

KW - general election 2015

U2 - 10.3366/scot.2015.0094

DO - 10.3366/scot.2015.0094

M3 - Article

VL - 24

SP - 419

EP - 431

JO - Scottish Affairs

JF - Scottish Affairs

SN - 0966-0356

IS - 4

ER -