Economic voting through boom and bust: information and choice at Irish General Elections, 2002–2011

Patrick Bernhagen, Heinz Brandenburg

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

A considerable body of research exists on the economic and informational determinants of voting behaviour. However, unresolved questions remain about the relationship between these two factors. While economic voting is generally understood as a matter of prospective evaluation carried out on the basis of retrospective cues available to voters, the extent to which prospective information matters for vote choice remains unclear, in particular if it conflicts with retrospective experience. How do different sources of information compete to affect vote choice and evaluations of incumbents? Specifically, how do voters evaluate incumbents if past economic performance has been good but predictions about the near future are bleak? In this chapter we address this question by analysing the economic and informational determinants of vote choice at three successive Irish elections: the last two general elections before the fiscal and economic collapse and the first election following the meltdown. Jointly, these elections form a quasi-experimental case study of economic votingthatenablesustoinvestigatewhethertheextenttowhichvotersreward the government for facilitating an economic boom is affected by warnings about precarious foundations and predictions of economic decline. To analyse this potentially contingent relationship we link media content data in the context of the elections with survey data from the Irish National Election Study (INES). The three election campaigns are marked by significant variation in the amount (and, for two elections, in the tone) of economic
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationA Conservative Revolution?
Subtitle of host publicationElectoral Change in Twenty-First Century Ireland
EditorsMichael Marsh, David M. Farrell, Gail McElroy
Place of PublicationOxford
Pages42-60
Number of pages19
Publication statusPublished - 9 Mar 2017

Fingerprint

voting
election
economics
voter
determinants
study of economics
election research
election campaign
voting behavior
evaluation
source of information
performance
experience

Keywords

  • economic voting
  • media effects
  • information
  • voting behaviour
  • voting behavior
  • media
  • economic conditions
  • Irish National Elections
  • economic collapse

Cite this

Bernhagen, P., & Brandenburg, H. (2017). Economic voting through boom and bust: information and choice at Irish General Elections, 2002–2011. In M. Marsh, D. M. Farrell, & G. McElroy (Eds.), A Conservative Revolution?: Electoral Change in Twenty-First Century Ireland (pp. 42-60). Oxford.
Bernhagen, Patrick ; Brandenburg, Heinz. / Economic voting through boom and bust : information and choice at Irish General Elections, 2002–2011. A Conservative Revolution?: Electoral Change in Twenty-First Century Ireland. editor / Michael Marsh ; David M. Farrell ; Gail McElroy. Oxford, 2017. pp. 42-60
@inbook{a752ae8ae5514319bfb3a97e1ce9e398,
title = "Economic voting through boom and bust: information and choice at Irish General Elections, 2002–2011",
abstract = "A considerable body of research exists on the economic and informational determinants of voting behaviour. However, unresolved questions remain about the relationship between these two factors. While economic voting is generally understood as a matter of prospective evaluation carried out on the basis of retrospective cues available to voters, the extent to which prospective information matters for vote choice remains unclear, in particular if it conflicts with retrospective experience. How do different sources of information compete to affect vote choice and evaluations of incumbents? Specifically, how do voters evaluate incumbents if past economic performance has been good but predictions about the near future are bleak? In this chapter we address this question by analysing the economic and informational determinants of vote choice at three successive Irish elections: the last two general elections before the fiscal and economic collapse and the first election following the meltdown. Jointly, these elections form a quasi-experimental case study of economic votingthatenablesustoinvestigatewhethertheextenttowhichvotersreward the government for facilitating an economic boom is affected by warnings about precarious foundations and predictions of economic decline. To analyse this potentially contingent relationship we link media content data in the context of the elections with survey data from the Irish National Election Study (INES). The three election campaigns are marked by significant variation in the amount (and, for two elections, in the tone) of economic",
keywords = "economic voting, media effects, information, voting behaviour, voting behavior, media, economic conditions, Irish National Elections, economic collapse",
author = "Patrick Bernhagen and Heinz Brandenburg",
note = "Bernhagen, P., & Brandenburg, H. (2015). Economic voting through boom and bust: information and choice at Irish General Elections, 2002–2011. In M. Marsh, D. M. Farrell, & G. McElroy (Eds.), A Conservative Revolution?: Electoral Change in Twenty-First Century Ireland. (pp. 42-60). Oxford: Oxford University Press, reproduced by permission of Oxford University Press. https://global.oup.com/academic/product/a-conservative-revolution-9780198744030",
year = "2017",
month = "3",
day = "9",
language = "English",
isbn = "9780198744030",
pages = "42--60",
editor = "Michael Marsh and Farrell, {David M.} and McElroy, {Gail }",
booktitle = "A Conservative Revolution?",

}

Bernhagen, P & Brandenburg, H 2017, Economic voting through boom and bust: information and choice at Irish General Elections, 2002–2011. in M Marsh, DM Farrell & G McElroy (eds), A Conservative Revolution?: Electoral Change in Twenty-First Century Ireland. Oxford, pp. 42-60.

Economic voting through boom and bust : information and choice at Irish General Elections, 2002–2011. / Bernhagen, Patrick; Brandenburg, Heinz.

A Conservative Revolution?: Electoral Change in Twenty-First Century Ireland. ed. / Michael Marsh; David M. Farrell; Gail McElroy. Oxford, 2017. p. 42-60.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Economic voting through boom and bust

T2 - information and choice at Irish General Elections, 2002–2011

AU - Bernhagen, Patrick

AU - Brandenburg, Heinz

N1 - Bernhagen, P., & Brandenburg, H. (2015). Economic voting through boom and bust: information and choice at Irish General Elections, 2002–2011. In M. Marsh, D. M. Farrell, & G. McElroy (Eds.), A Conservative Revolution?: Electoral Change in Twenty-First Century Ireland. (pp. 42-60). Oxford: Oxford University Press, reproduced by permission of Oxford University Press. https://global.oup.com/academic/product/a-conservative-revolution-9780198744030

PY - 2017/3/9

Y1 - 2017/3/9

N2 - A considerable body of research exists on the economic and informational determinants of voting behaviour. However, unresolved questions remain about the relationship between these two factors. While economic voting is generally understood as a matter of prospective evaluation carried out on the basis of retrospective cues available to voters, the extent to which prospective information matters for vote choice remains unclear, in particular if it conflicts with retrospective experience. How do different sources of information compete to affect vote choice and evaluations of incumbents? Specifically, how do voters evaluate incumbents if past economic performance has been good but predictions about the near future are bleak? In this chapter we address this question by analysing the economic and informational determinants of vote choice at three successive Irish elections: the last two general elections before the fiscal and economic collapse and the first election following the meltdown. Jointly, these elections form a quasi-experimental case study of economic votingthatenablesustoinvestigatewhethertheextenttowhichvotersreward the government for facilitating an economic boom is affected by warnings about precarious foundations and predictions of economic decline. To analyse this potentially contingent relationship we link media content data in the context of the elections with survey data from the Irish National Election Study (INES). The three election campaigns are marked by significant variation in the amount (and, for two elections, in the tone) of economic

AB - A considerable body of research exists on the economic and informational determinants of voting behaviour. However, unresolved questions remain about the relationship between these two factors. While economic voting is generally understood as a matter of prospective evaluation carried out on the basis of retrospective cues available to voters, the extent to which prospective information matters for vote choice remains unclear, in particular if it conflicts with retrospective experience. How do different sources of information compete to affect vote choice and evaluations of incumbents? Specifically, how do voters evaluate incumbents if past economic performance has been good but predictions about the near future are bleak? In this chapter we address this question by analysing the economic and informational determinants of vote choice at three successive Irish elections: the last two general elections before the fiscal and economic collapse and the first election following the meltdown. Jointly, these elections form a quasi-experimental case study of economic votingthatenablesustoinvestigatewhethertheextenttowhichvotersreward the government for facilitating an economic boom is affected by warnings about precarious foundations and predictions of economic decline. To analyse this potentially contingent relationship we link media content data in the context of the elections with survey data from the Irish National Election Study (INES). The three election campaigns are marked by significant variation in the amount (and, for two elections, in the tone) of economic

KW - economic voting

KW - media effects

KW - information

KW - voting behaviour

KW - voting behavior

KW - media

KW - economic conditions

KW - Irish National Elections

KW - economic collapse

UR - https://global.oup.com/academic/product/a-conservative-revolution-9780198744030

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9780198744030

SP - 42

EP - 60

BT - A Conservative Revolution?

A2 - Marsh, Michael

A2 - Farrell, David M.

A2 - McElroy, Gail

CY - Oxford

ER -

Bernhagen P, Brandenburg H. Economic voting through boom and bust: information and choice at Irish General Elections, 2002–2011. In Marsh M, Farrell DM, McElroy G, editors, A Conservative Revolution?: Electoral Change in Twenty-First Century Ireland. Oxford. 2017. p. 42-60