Development and initial application of a blade design methodology for overspeed power-regulated tidal turbines

Katie Gracie-Orr, Thomas M. Nevalainen, Cameron M. Johnstone, Robynne E. Murray, Darrel A. Doman, Michael J. Pegg

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The range and variability of flow velocities in which horizontal axis tidal stream turbines operate introduces the requirement for a power regulation method in the system. Overspeed power regulation (OSPR) has the potential to improve the structural robustness and decrease the complexity associated with active pitch power regulation methods, while removing the difficulties of operating in stalled flow. This paper presents the development of a methodology for the design of blades to be used in such systems. The method requires a site depth, maximum flow velocity and rated power or flow speed as input parameters. The pitch setting, twist and chord distribution were set as input parameters, variable through the use of alteration functions. Rotor performance has been broken down into OSPR performance metrics which consider coefficients of power and thrust, and cavitation inception. Three visual-numerical tools have been developed: the OSPR performance metrics were used in conjunction with a one-at-a-time sensitivity analysis approach to develop a design space; cavitation inception analyses gave plots of converging cavitation and pressure terms for each blade section; the local angle of attack and torque distribution across the blade designs were plotted at key turbine operation states. Alterations to pitch setting and twist distribution are shown to have most impact upon the design requirement of increased gradient in the rotor speed-efficiency relationship in the overspeed region; coupled with such alterations, targeted changes to the chord distribution have been shown to increase the maximum efficiency. The prevention of cavitation has been highlighted as a driver for speed-limiting design alterations. While facilitating blade design, the methodology also produces experiential knowledge which can be stored, and shared in graphical format.

LanguageEnglish
Pages140-155
Number of pages16
JournalInternational Journal of Marine Energy
Volume15
Early online date4 May 2016
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 30 Sep 2016

Fingerprint

Tidal power
tidal power
turbine
Turbomachine blades
Turbines
cavitation
Cavitation
methodology
Flow velocity
flow velocity
Rotors
Angle of attack
torque
Sensitivity analysis
sensitivity analysis
Torque
thrust
regulation
distribution
speed

Keywords

  • blade design
  • blade element momentum theory
  • design methodology
  • overspeed
  • power regulation
  • sensitivity analysis
  • tidal turbine

Cite this

Gracie-Orr, Katie ; Nevalainen, Thomas M. ; Johnstone, Cameron M. ; Murray, Robynne E. ; Doman, Darrel A. ; Pegg, Michael J. / Development and initial application of a blade design methodology for overspeed power-regulated tidal turbines. In: International Journal of Marine Energy. 2016 ; Vol. 15. pp. 140-155.
@article{5444f1c3adb042898d14aff307c16396,
title = "Development and initial application of a blade design methodology for overspeed power-regulated tidal turbines",
abstract = "The range and variability of flow velocities in which horizontal axis tidal stream turbines operate introduces the requirement for a power regulation method in the system. Overspeed power regulation (OSPR) has the potential to improve the structural robustness and decrease the complexity associated with active pitch power regulation methods, while removing the difficulties of operating in stalled flow. This paper presents the development of a methodology for the design of blades to be used in such systems. The method requires a site depth, maximum flow velocity and rated power or flow speed as input parameters. The pitch setting, twist and chord distribution were set as input parameters, variable through the use of alteration functions. Rotor performance has been broken down into OSPR performance metrics which consider coefficients of power and thrust, and cavitation inception. Three visual-numerical tools have been developed: the OSPR performance metrics were used in conjunction with a one-at-a-time sensitivity analysis approach to develop a design space; cavitation inception analyses gave plots of converging cavitation and pressure terms for each blade section; the local angle of attack and torque distribution across the blade designs were plotted at key turbine operation states. Alterations to pitch setting and twist distribution are shown to have most impact upon the design requirement of increased gradient in the rotor speed-efficiency relationship in the overspeed region; coupled with such alterations, targeted changes to the chord distribution have been shown to increase the maximum efficiency. The prevention of cavitation has been highlighted as a driver for speed-limiting design alterations. While facilitating blade design, the methodology also produces experiential knowledge which can be stored, and shared in graphical format.",
keywords = "blade design, blade element momentum theory, design methodology, overspeed, power regulation, sensitivity analysis, tidal turbine",
author = "Katie Gracie-Orr and Nevalainen, {Thomas M.} and Johnstone, {Cameron M.} and Murray, {Robynne E.} and Doman, {Darrel A.} and Pegg, {Michael J.}",
year = "2016",
month = "9",
day = "30",
doi = "10.1016/j.ijome.2016.04.006",
language = "English",
volume = "15",
pages = "140--155",
journal = "International Journal of Marine Energy",
issn = "2214-1669",

}

Development and initial application of a blade design methodology for overspeed power-regulated tidal turbines. / Gracie-Orr, Katie; Nevalainen, Thomas M.; Johnstone, Cameron M.; Murray, Robynne E.; Doman, Darrel A.; Pegg, Michael J.

In: International Journal of Marine Energy, Vol. 15, 30.09.2016, p. 140-155.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Development and initial application of a blade design methodology for overspeed power-regulated tidal turbines

AU - Gracie-Orr, Katie

AU - Nevalainen, Thomas M.

AU - Johnstone, Cameron M.

AU - Murray, Robynne E.

AU - Doman, Darrel A.

AU - Pegg, Michael J.

PY - 2016/9/30

Y1 - 2016/9/30

N2 - The range and variability of flow velocities in which horizontal axis tidal stream turbines operate introduces the requirement for a power regulation method in the system. Overspeed power regulation (OSPR) has the potential to improve the structural robustness and decrease the complexity associated with active pitch power regulation methods, while removing the difficulties of operating in stalled flow. This paper presents the development of a methodology for the design of blades to be used in such systems. The method requires a site depth, maximum flow velocity and rated power or flow speed as input parameters. The pitch setting, twist and chord distribution were set as input parameters, variable through the use of alteration functions. Rotor performance has been broken down into OSPR performance metrics which consider coefficients of power and thrust, and cavitation inception. Three visual-numerical tools have been developed: the OSPR performance metrics were used in conjunction with a one-at-a-time sensitivity analysis approach to develop a design space; cavitation inception analyses gave plots of converging cavitation and pressure terms for each blade section; the local angle of attack and torque distribution across the blade designs were plotted at key turbine operation states. Alterations to pitch setting and twist distribution are shown to have most impact upon the design requirement of increased gradient in the rotor speed-efficiency relationship in the overspeed region; coupled with such alterations, targeted changes to the chord distribution have been shown to increase the maximum efficiency. The prevention of cavitation has been highlighted as a driver for speed-limiting design alterations. While facilitating blade design, the methodology also produces experiential knowledge which can be stored, and shared in graphical format.

AB - The range and variability of flow velocities in which horizontal axis tidal stream turbines operate introduces the requirement for a power regulation method in the system. Overspeed power regulation (OSPR) has the potential to improve the structural robustness and decrease the complexity associated with active pitch power regulation methods, while removing the difficulties of operating in stalled flow. This paper presents the development of a methodology for the design of blades to be used in such systems. The method requires a site depth, maximum flow velocity and rated power or flow speed as input parameters. The pitch setting, twist and chord distribution were set as input parameters, variable through the use of alteration functions. Rotor performance has been broken down into OSPR performance metrics which consider coefficients of power and thrust, and cavitation inception. Three visual-numerical tools have been developed: the OSPR performance metrics were used in conjunction with a one-at-a-time sensitivity analysis approach to develop a design space; cavitation inception analyses gave plots of converging cavitation and pressure terms for each blade section; the local angle of attack and torque distribution across the blade designs were plotted at key turbine operation states. Alterations to pitch setting and twist distribution are shown to have most impact upon the design requirement of increased gradient in the rotor speed-efficiency relationship in the overspeed region; coupled with such alterations, targeted changes to the chord distribution have been shown to increase the maximum efficiency. The prevention of cavitation has been highlighted as a driver for speed-limiting design alterations. While facilitating blade design, the methodology also produces experiential knowledge which can be stored, and shared in graphical format.

KW - blade design

KW - blade element momentum theory

KW - design methodology

KW - overspeed

KW - power regulation

KW - sensitivity analysis

KW - tidal turbine

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84973452397&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/journal/22141669

U2 - 10.1016/j.ijome.2016.04.006

DO - 10.1016/j.ijome.2016.04.006

M3 - Article

VL - 15

SP - 140

EP - 155

JO - International Journal of Marine Energy

T2 - International Journal of Marine Energy

JF - International Journal of Marine Energy

SN - 2214-1669

ER -