Developing a universal reading comprehension intervention for mainstream primary schools within areas of social deprivation for children with and without language-learning impairment: a feasibility study

Elspeth McCartney, James Boyle, Sue Ellis

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Background Some children in areas of social deprivation in Scotland have lower reading attainment than neighbouring children in less deprived areas, and some of these also have lower spoken language comprehension skills than expected by assessment norms. There is a need to develop effective reading comprehension interventions that fit easily into the school curriculum and can benefit all pupils. A feasibility study of reading comprehension strategies with existing evidence of efficacy was undertaken in three mainstream primary schools within an area of social deprivation in west central Scotland, to decide whether further investigation of this intervention was warranted. Aims Aims were to measure comprehension of spoken language and reading via standardised assessments towards the beginning of the school year (T1) in mainstream primary school classrooms within an area of social deprivation; to have teachers introduce previously-validated text comprehension strategies, and to measure change in reading comprehension outcome measures towards the end of the year (T2). Methods & Procedures A pre- and post-intervention cohort design was used. Reading comprehension strategies were introduced to staff in participating schools and used throughout the school year as part of on-going reading instruction. Spoken language comprehension was measured by TROG-2 at T1, and reading progress by score changes from T1 to T2 on the WIAT-IIUK-T reading comprehension scale. Outcomes & Results Forty-seven pupils in five classes in three primary schools took part: 38% had TROG-2 scores below the 10th centile. As a group, children made good reading comprehension progress, with a medium effect size of 0.46. Children with TROG-2 scores below the 10th centile had lower mean reading scores than others at T1 and T2, although with considerable overlap. However, TROG-2 did not make a unique contribution to reading progress: children below the 10th centile made as much progress as other children. The intervention was welcomed by schools, and the measure of reading comprehension proved responsive to change. Conclusions The outcomes suggest the reading intervention may be effective for children with and without spoken language comprehension difficulties, and warrants further investigation in larger, controlled, studies.

LanguageEnglish
Pages129-135
Number of pages7
JournalInternational Journal of Language and Communication Disorders
Volume50
Issue number1
Early online date2 Sep 2014
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2015

Fingerprint

social deprivation
Feasibility Studies
primary school
Reading
comprehension
Language
Learning
language
learning
spoken language
school
Scotland
Pupil
Reading Comprehension
Language-learning Impairment
Deprivation
Primary School
pupil
reading instruction

Keywords

  • education
  • language impairment
  • reading comprehension
  • receptive language
  • school-age children

Cite this

@article{71d9858fdfda4e7983940c50b84c0faf,
title = "Developing a universal reading comprehension intervention for mainstream primary schools within areas of social deprivation for children with and without language-learning impairment: a feasibility study",
abstract = "Background Some children in areas of social deprivation in Scotland have lower reading attainment than neighbouring children in less deprived areas, and some of these also have lower spoken language comprehension skills than expected by assessment norms. There is a need to develop effective reading comprehension interventions that fit easily into the school curriculum and can benefit all pupils. A feasibility study of reading comprehension strategies with existing evidence of efficacy was undertaken in three mainstream primary schools within an area of social deprivation in west central Scotland, to decide whether further investigation of this intervention was warranted. Aims Aims were to measure comprehension of spoken language and reading via standardised assessments towards the beginning of the school year (T1) in mainstream primary school classrooms within an area of social deprivation; to have teachers introduce previously-validated text comprehension strategies, and to measure change in reading comprehension outcome measures towards the end of the year (T2). Methods & Procedures A pre- and post-intervention cohort design was used. Reading comprehension strategies were introduced to staff in participating schools and used throughout the school year as part of on-going reading instruction. Spoken language comprehension was measured by TROG-2 at T1, and reading progress by score changes from T1 to T2 on the WIAT-IIUK-T reading comprehension scale. Outcomes & Results Forty-seven pupils in five classes in three primary schools took part: 38{\%} had TROG-2 scores below the 10th centile. As a group, children made good reading comprehension progress, with a medium effect size of 0.46. Children with TROG-2 scores below the 10th centile had lower mean reading scores than others at T1 and T2, although with considerable overlap. However, TROG-2 did not make a unique contribution to reading progress: children below the 10th centile made as much progress as other children. The intervention was welcomed by schools, and the measure of reading comprehension proved responsive to change. Conclusions The outcomes suggest the reading intervention may be effective for children with and without spoken language comprehension difficulties, and warrants further investigation in larger, controlled, studies.",
keywords = "education, language impairment, reading comprehension, receptive language, school-age children",
author = "Elspeth McCartney and James Boyle and Sue Ellis",
year = "2015",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1111/1460-6984.12124",
language = "English",
volume = "50",
pages = "129--135",
journal = "International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders",
issn = "1368-2822",
number = "1",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Developing a universal reading comprehension intervention for mainstream primary schools within areas of social deprivation for children with and without language-learning impairment

T2 - International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders

AU - McCartney, Elspeth

AU - Boyle, James

AU - Ellis, Sue

PY - 2015/1/1

Y1 - 2015/1/1

N2 - Background Some children in areas of social deprivation in Scotland have lower reading attainment than neighbouring children in less deprived areas, and some of these also have lower spoken language comprehension skills than expected by assessment norms. There is a need to develop effective reading comprehension interventions that fit easily into the school curriculum and can benefit all pupils. A feasibility study of reading comprehension strategies with existing evidence of efficacy was undertaken in three mainstream primary schools within an area of social deprivation in west central Scotland, to decide whether further investigation of this intervention was warranted. Aims Aims were to measure comprehension of spoken language and reading via standardised assessments towards the beginning of the school year (T1) in mainstream primary school classrooms within an area of social deprivation; to have teachers introduce previously-validated text comprehension strategies, and to measure change in reading comprehension outcome measures towards the end of the year (T2). Methods & Procedures A pre- and post-intervention cohort design was used. Reading comprehension strategies were introduced to staff in participating schools and used throughout the school year as part of on-going reading instruction. Spoken language comprehension was measured by TROG-2 at T1, and reading progress by score changes from T1 to T2 on the WIAT-IIUK-T reading comprehension scale. Outcomes & Results Forty-seven pupils in five classes in three primary schools took part: 38% had TROG-2 scores below the 10th centile. As a group, children made good reading comprehension progress, with a medium effect size of 0.46. Children with TROG-2 scores below the 10th centile had lower mean reading scores than others at T1 and T2, although with considerable overlap. However, TROG-2 did not make a unique contribution to reading progress: children below the 10th centile made as much progress as other children. The intervention was welcomed by schools, and the measure of reading comprehension proved responsive to change. Conclusions The outcomes suggest the reading intervention may be effective for children with and without spoken language comprehension difficulties, and warrants further investigation in larger, controlled, studies.

AB - Background Some children in areas of social deprivation in Scotland have lower reading attainment than neighbouring children in less deprived areas, and some of these also have lower spoken language comprehension skills than expected by assessment norms. There is a need to develop effective reading comprehension interventions that fit easily into the school curriculum and can benefit all pupils. A feasibility study of reading comprehension strategies with existing evidence of efficacy was undertaken in three mainstream primary schools within an area of social deprivation in west central Scotland, to decide whether further investigation of this intervention was warranted. Aims Aims were to measure comprehension of spoken language and reading via standardised assessments towards the beginning of the school year (T1) in mainstream primary school classrooms within an area of social deprivation; to have teachers introduce previously-validated text comprehension strategies, and to measure change in reading comprehension outcome measures towards the end of the year (T2). Methods & Procedures A pre- and post-intervention cohort design was used. Reading comprehension strategies were introduced to staff in participating schools and used throughout the school year as part of on-going reading instruction. Spoken language comprehension was measured by TROG-2 at T1, and reading progress by score changes from T1 to T2 on the WIAT-IIUK-T reading comprehension scale. Outcomes & Results Forty-seven pupils in five classes in three primary schools took part: 38% had TROG-2 scores below the 10th centile. As a group, children made good reading comprehension progress, with a medium effect size of 0.46. Children with TROG-2 scores below the 10th centile had lower mean reading scores than others at T1 and T2, although with considerable overlap. However, TROG-2 did not make a unique contribution to reading progress: children below the 10th centile made as much progress as other children. The intervention was welcomed by schools, and the measure of reading comprehension proved responsive to change. Conclusions The outcomes suggest the reading intervention may be effective for children with and without spoken language comprehension difficulties, and warrants further investigation in larger, controlled, studies.

KW - education

KW - language impairment

KW - reading comprehension

KW - receptive language

KW - school-age children

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84922987081&partnerID=8YFLogxK

U2 - 10.1111/1460-6984.12124

DO - 10.1111/1460-6984.12124

M3 - Article

VL - 50

SP - 129

EP - 135

JO - International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders

JF - International Journal of Language and Communication Disorders

SN - 1368-2822

IS - 1

ER -