Cutting the dash: experiences of mental health and employment

Belinda Arthur, Lee Knifton, Margaret Park, Ellen Docherty

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    8 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    People who have used mental health services in Scotland have the lowest employment rates of all working ages, despite a national programme for mental health and well-being that provides significant investment in anti-stigma initiatives and employment support services. This paper qualitatively identifies barriers to employment from the perspectives of people who have experienced mental health issues by conducting in-depth focus groups with 20 people who have experienced mental health issues undertaken through collaborative research involving people who have experienced mental health issues alongside practitioners and academics. Researchers who have experienced mental health issues instigated and determined the direction, execution and dissemination of the study. The findings add to the growing evidence base outlining the complex and interlinked barriers to employment which include previous experience of workplace discrimination, financial uncertainty, disclosure concerns, quality of jobs available and the potential of work at times to worsen mental health conditions. Despite this, most participants expressed hopefulness and resilience. Many wanted paid work and outlined practical steps that employers can take in terms of recruitment and retention. However, participants also stressed the equal importance of voluntary work and not just as a step to paid employment. A multiple-perspectives approach provides important insights into the complex and sensitive policy area of mental health and employment. Meaningful involvement of people who have used mental health services should be a central aspect of further research that aims to understand and address these barriers. This study has shaped the development of a national service user research consortium in Scotland.
    LanguageEnglish
    Pages51-59
    Number of pages9
    JournalJournal of Public Mental Health
    Volume7
    Issue number4
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - Dec 2008

    Fingerprint

    Mental Health
    Mental Health Services
    Scotland
    Hope
    Research
    Disclosure
    Focus Groups
    Workplace
    Uncertainty
    Research Personnel

    Keywords

    • employment
    • mental health services
    • service user research
    • stigma
    • workplace

    Cite this

    Arthur, Belinda ; Knifton, Lee ; Park, Margaret ; Docherty, Ellen. / Cutting the dash: experiences of mental health and employment. In: Journal of Public Mental Health. 2008 ; Vol. 7, No. 4. pp. 51-59.
    @article{e19d463a792f481780eb65f0cfafd93b,
    title = "Cutting the dash: experiences of mental health and employment",
    abstract = "People who have used mental health services in Scotland have the lowest employment rates of all working ages, despite a national programme for mental health and well-being that provides significant investment in anti-stigma initiatives and employment support services. This paper qualitatively identifies barriers to employment from the perspectives of people who have experienced mental health issues by conducting in-depth focus groups with 20 people who have experienced mental health issues undertaken through collaborative research involving people who have experienced mental health issues alongside practitioners and academics. Researchers who have experienced mental health issues instigated and determined the direction, execution and dissemination of the study. The findings add to the growing evidence base outlining the complex and interlinked barriers to employment which include previous experience of workplace discrimination, financial uncertainty, disclosure concerns, quality of jobs available and the potential of work at times to worsen mental health conditions. Despite this, most participants expressed hopefulness and resilience. Many wanted paid work and outlined practical steps that employers can take in terms of recruitment and retention. However, participants also stressed the equal importance of voluntary work and not just as a step to paid employment. A multiple-perspectives approach provides important insights into the complex and sensitive policy area of mental health and employment. Meaningful involvement of people who have used mental health services should be a central aspect of further research that aims to understand and address these barriers. This study has shaped the development of a national service user research consortium in Scotland.",
    keywords = "employment, mental health services, service user research, stigma, workplace",
    author = "Belinda Arthur and Lee Knifton and Margaret Park and Ellen Docherty",
    year = "2008",
    month = "12",
    doi = "10.1108/17465729200800029",
    language = "English",
    volume = "7",
    pages = "51--59",
    journal = "Journal of Public Mental Health",
    issn = "1746-5729",
    publisher = "Emerald Publishing Limited",
    number = "4",

    }

    Cutting the dash: experiences of mental health and employment. / Arthur, Belinda ; Knifton, Lee; Park, Margaret ; Docherty, Ellen.

    In: Journal of Public Mental Health, Vol. 7, No. 4, 12.2008, p. 51-59.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Cutting the dash: experiences of mental health and employment

    AU - Arthur, Belinda

    AU - Knifton, Lee

    AU - Park, Margaret

    AU - Docherty, Ellen

    PY - 2008/12

    Y1 - 2008/12

    N2 - People who have used mental health services in Scotland have the lowest employment rates of all working ages, despite a national programme for mental health and well-being that provides significant investment in anti-stigma initiatives and employment support services. This paper qualitatively identifies barriers to employment from the perspectives of people who have experienced mental health issues by conducting in-depth focus groups with 20 people who have experienced mental health issues undertaken through collaborative research involving people who have experienced mental health issues alongside practitioners and academics. Researchers who have experienced mental health issues instigated and determined the direction, execution and dissemination of the study. The findings add to the growing evidence base outlining the complex and interlinked barriers to employment which include previous experience of workplace discrimination, financial uncertainty, disclosure concerns, quality of jobs available and the potential of work at times to worsen mental health conditions. Despite this, most participants expressed hopefulness and resilience. Many wanted paid work and outlined practical steps that employers can take in terms of recruitment and retention. However, participants also stressed the equal importance of voluntary work and not just as a step to paid employment. A multiple-perspectives approach provides important insights into the complex and sensitive policy area of mental health and employment. Meaningful involvement of people who have used mental health services should be a central aspect of further research that aims to understand and address these barriers. This study has shaped the development of a national service user research consortium in Scotland.

    AB - People who have used mental health services in Scotland have the lowest employment rates of all working ages, despite a national programme for mental health and well-being that provides significant investment in anti-stigma initiatives and employment support services. This paper qualitatively identifies barriers to employment from the perspectives of people who have experienced mental health issues by conducting in-depth focus groups with 20 people who have experienced mental health issues undertaken through collaborative research involving people who have experienced mental health issues alongside practitioners and academics. Researchers who have experienced mental health issues instigated and determined the direction, execution and dissemination of the study. The findings add to the growing evidence base outlining the complex and interlinked barriers to employment which include previous experience of workplace discrimination, financial uncertainty, disclosure concerns, quality of jobs available and the potential of work at times to worsen mental health conditions. Despite this, most participants expressed hopefulness and resilience. Many wanted paid work and outlined practical steps that employers can take in terms of recruitment and retention. However, participants also stressed the equal importance of voluntary work and not just as a step to paid employment. A multiple-perspectives approach provides important insights into the complex and sensitive policy area of mental health and employment. Meaningful involvement of people who have used mental health services should be a central aspect of further research that aims to understand and address these barriers. This study has shaped the development of a national service user research consortium in Scotland.

    KW - employment

    KW - mental health services

    KW - service user research

    KW - stigma

    KW - workplace

    U2 - 10.1108/17465729200800029

    DO - 10.1108/17465729200800029

    M3 - Article

    VL - 7

    SP - 51

    EP - 59

    JO - Journal of Public Mental Health

    T2 - Journal of Public Mental Health

    JF - Journal of Public Mental Health

    SN - 1746-5729

    IS - 4

    ER -