Creation dependencies of evolutionary artefact and design process knowledge

Wenjuan Wang, Alexander Duffy, Iain Boyle, Robert Whitfield

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

  • 5 Citations

Abstract

As design progresses, artefact and process knowledge often evolve together. However, there is very limited knowledge on the true nature of the dependencies between these two elements of knowledge. This paper presents the first attempt to clearly define 'creation' dependencies, which cause a change in design knowledge. Three data analyses were used to identify the dependencies: two were in-depth protocol analyses of a single student product design project and a senior ship designer’s daily work, and a third was a quantitative questionnaire analysis involving seven experienced complex system designers from industry. The analyses revealed a set of 52 previously unknown creation dependencies between artefact and design process knowledge with commonality found in only 5, with additional dependencies being identified that were specific to the design being studied. Different frequencies of dependency occurrence and particular dependency loops were identified. In addition, the importance and role of domain knowledge were explicitly revealed. The described research highlights the need for further work to provide a more comprehensive definition of the nature of evolutionary artefact and design process knowledge dependencies. Identification of these dependencies offers a significant opportunity to develop tools and techniques with an enhanced ability to support 'what–if' analyses during design.
LanguageEnglish
Pages681-710
Number of pages30
JournalJournal of Engineering Design
Volume24
Issue number9
Early online date27 Aug 2013
DOIs
StatePublished - Sep 2013

Fingerprint

Product design
Large scale systems
Ships
Students
Chemical analysis
Industry

Keywords

  • creation dependency
  • artefact knowledge
  • design process knowledge
  • dependency occurrence

Cite this

@article{1f0aa348d4064211be7294780390adbf,
title = "Creation dependencies of evolutionary artefact and design process knowledge",
abstract = "As design progresses, artefact and process knowledge often evolve together. However, there is very limited knowledge on the true nature of the dependencies between these two elements of knowledge. This paper presents the first attempt to clearly define 'creation' dependencies, which cause a change in design knowledge. Three data analyses were used to identify the dependencies: two were in-depth protocol analyses of a single student product design project and a senior ship designer’s daily work, and a third was a quantitative questionnaire analysis involving seven experienced complex system designers from industry. The analyses revealed a set of 52 previously unknown creation dependencies between artefact and design process knowledge with commonality found in only 5, with additional dependencies being identified that were specific to the design being studied. Different frequencies of dependency occurrence and particular dependency loops were identified. In addition, the importance and role of domain knowledge were explicitly revealed. The described research highlights the need for further work to provide a more comprehensive definition of the nature of evolutionary artefact and design process knowledge dependencies. Identification of these dependencies offers a significant opportunity to develop tools and techniques with an enhanced ability to support 'what–if' analyses during design.",
keywords = "creation dependency, artefact knowledge, design process knowledge, dependency occurrence",
author = "Wenjuan Wang and Alexander Duffy and Iain Boyle and Robert Whitfield",
year = "2013",
month = "9",
doi = "10.1080/09544828.2013.825103",
language = "English",
volume = "24",
pages = "681--710",
journal = "Journal of Engineering Design",
issn = "0954-4828",
number = "9",

}

Creation dependencies of evolutionary artefact and design process knowledge. / Wang, Wenjuan; Duffy, Alexander; Boyle, Iain; Whitfield, Robert.

In: Journal of Engineering Design, Vol. 24, No. 9, 09.2013, p. 681-710.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Creation dependencies of evolutionary artefact and design process knowledge

AU - Wang,Wenjuan

AU - Duffy,Alexander

AU - Boyle,Iain

AU - Whitfield,Robert

PY - 2013/9

Y1 - 2013/9

N2 - As design progresses, artefact and process knowledge often evolve together. However, there is very limited knowledge on the true nature of the dependencies between these two elements of knowledge. This paper presents the first attempt to clearly define 'creation' dependencies, which cause a change in design knowledge. Three data analyses were used to identify the dependencies: two were in-depth protocol analyses of a single student product design project and a senior ship designer’s daily work, and a third was a quantitative questionnaire analysis involving seven experienced complex system designers from industry. The analyses revealed a set of 52 previously unknown creation dependencies between artefact and design process knowledge with commonality found in only 5, with additional dependencies being identified that were specific to the design being studied. Different frequencies of dependency occurrence and particular dependency loops were identified. In addition, the importance and role of domain knowledge were explicitly revealed. The described research highlights the need for further work to provide a more comprehensive definition of the nature of evolutionary artefact and design process knowledge dependencies. Identification of these dependencies offers a significant opportunity to develop tools and techniques with an enhanced ability to support 'what–if' analyses during design.

AB - As design progresses, artefact and process knowledge often evolve together. However, there is very limited knowledge on the true nature of the dependencies between these two elements of knowledge. This paper presents the first attempt to clearly define 'creation' dependencies, which cause a change in design knowledge. Three data analyses were used to identify the dependencies: two were in-depth protocol analyses of a single student product design project and a senior ship designer’s daily work, and a third was a quantitative questionnaire analysis involving seven experienced complex system designers from industry. The analyses revealed a set of 52 previously unknown creation dependencies between artefact and design process knowledge with commonality found in only 5, with additional dependencies being identified that were specific to the design being studied. Different frequencies of dependency occurrence and particular dependency loops were identified. In addition, the importance and role of domain knowledge were explicitly revealed. The described research highlights the need for further work to provide a more comprehensive definition of the nature of evolutionary artefact and design process knowledge dependencies. Identification of these dependencies offers a significant opportunity to develop tools and techniques with an enhanced ability to support 'what–if' analyses during design.

KW - creation dependency

KW - artefact knowledge

KW - design process knowledge

KW - dependency occurrence

UR - http://www.tandfonline.com/toc/cjen20/current#.Uh29RpK1FJQ

U2 - 10.1080/09544828.2013.825103

DO - 10.1080/09544828.2013.825103

M3 - Article

VL - 24

SP - 681

EP - 710

JO - Journal of Engineering Design

T2 - Journal of Engineering Design

JF - Journal of Engineering Design

SN - 0954-4828

IS - 9

ER -