Contesting concepts of the nation in arms: French memories of the war of 1870-1871 in Dijon

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

In the campaign to rebuild hope after the defeat of 1870–1, cultural representations of the Franco-Prussian War asserted that the nation had united behind the defence. Yet, while patriotic discourse insisted on the popular character of the resistance, memories of the Paris Commune served to discredit the concept of the nation in arms. By examining radical republican efforts to commemorate the defence of Dijon, this article challenges assumptions of consensus over the conduct of the armed forces in 1870–1. The city’s first war memorial portrayed a civilian- led resistance with revolutionary iconography. Deemed subversive by the government of Moral Order, it was toppled in 1875. Memories of Garibaldi’s antimilitarism and anti-clericalism, revived at the unveiling of his statue in 1900, exacerbated controversies over radical military reforms and the separation of Church and State. At the heart of debates about the defence of Dijon lay competing concepts of the role of the army within the Republic.
LanguageEnglish
Pages548-573
Number of pages26
JournalEuropean History Quarterly
Volume36
Issue number4
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Oct 2006

Fingerprint

antimilitarism
military
clericalism
commune
memorial
republic
UNO
church
campaign
Military
reform
discourse
Dijon
Cultural Representations
Republican
Defeat
Discourse
Discredit
Statue
Iconography

Keywords

  • France
  • Commemoration
  • memory
  • Garibaldi
  • Franco-Prussian War
  • Franco-Prussian War memory

Cite this

@article{9cdf72d6ba1a45439b62687156b3cfc4,
title = "Contesting concepts of the nation in arms: French memories of the war of 1870-1871 in Dijon",
abstract = "In the campaign to rebuild hope after the defeat of 1870–1, cultural representations of the Franco-Prussian War asserted that the nation had united behind the defence. Yet, while patriotic discourse insisted on the popular character of the resistance, memories of the Paris Commune served to discredit the concept of the nation in arms. By examining radical republican efforts to commemorate the defence of Dijon, this article challenges assumptions of consensus over the conduct of the armed forces in 1870–1. The city’s first war memorial portrayed a civilian- led resistance with revolutionary iconography. Deemed subversive by the government of Moral Order, it was toppled in 1875. Memories of Garibaldi’s antimilitarism and anti-clericalism, revived at the unveiling of his statue in 1900, exacerbated controversies over radical military reforms and the separation of Church and State. At the heart of debates about the defence of Dijon lay competing concepts of the role of the army within the Republic.",
keywords = "France, Commemoration, memory, Garibaldi, Franco-Prussian War , Franco-Prussian War memory",
author = "Karine Varley",
year = "2006",
month = "10",
doi = "10.1177/0265691406068128",
language = "English",
volume = "36",
pages = "548--573",
journal = "European History Quarterly",
issn = "0265-6914",
number = "4",

}

Contesting concepts of the nation in arms: French memories of the war of 1870-1871 in Dijon. / Varley, Karine.

In: European History Quarterly, Vol. 36, No. 4, 10.2006, p. 548-573.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Contesting concepts of the nation in arms: French memories of the war of 1870-1871 in Dijon

AU - Varley, Karine

PY - 2006/10

Y1 - 2006/10

N2 - In the campaign to rebuild hope after the defeat of 1870–1, cultural representations of the Franco-Prussian War asserted that the nation had united behind the defence. Yet, while patriotic discourse insisted on the popular character of the resistance, memories of the Paris Commune served to discredit the concept of the nation in arms. By examining radical republican efforts to commemorate the defence of Dijon, this article challenges assumptions of consensus over the conduct of the armed forces in 1870–1. The city’s first war memorial portrayed a civilian- led resistance with revolutionary iconography. Deemed subversive by the government of Moral Order, it was toppled in 1875. Memories of Garibaldi’s antimilitarism and anti-clericalism, revived at the unveiling of his statue in 1900, exacerbated controversies over radical military reforms and the separation of Church and State. At the heart of debates about the defence of Dijon lay competing concepts of the role of the army within the Republic.

AB - In the campaign to rebuild hope after the defeat of 1870–1, cultural representations of the Franco-Prussian War asserted that the nation had united behind the defence. Yet, while patriotic discourse insisted on the popular character of the resistance, memories of the Paris Commune served to discredit the concept of the nation in arms. By examining radical republican efforts to commemorate the defence of Dijon, this article challenges assumptions of consensus over the conduct of the armed forces in 1870–1. The city’s first war memorial portrayed a civilian- led resistance with revolutionary iconography. Deemed subversive by the government of Moral Order, it was toppled in 1875. Memories of Garibaldi’s antimilitarism and anti-clericalism, revived at the unveiling of his statue in 1900, exacerbated controversies over radical military reforms and the separation of Church and State. At the heart of debates about the defence of Dijon lay competing concepts of the role of the army within the Republic.

KW - France

KW - Commemoration

KW - memory

KW - Garibaldi

KW - Franco-Prussian War

KW - Franco-Prussian War memory

U2 - 10.1177/0265691406068128

DO - 10.1177/0265691406068128

M3 - Article

VL - 36

SP - 548

EP - 573

JO - European History Quarterly

T2 - European History Quarterly

JF - European History Quarterly

SN - 0265-6914

IS - 4

ER -