Considering internal conflict in the face of natural product biosynthesis and biosynthetic gene cluster evolution

This essay attempts to stimulate interest and provide insight in to the dynamics of internal conflicts, kin selection, and ecological interactions in multicellular, metabolically-gifted microorganisms and how these processes may affect biosynthetic gene cluster (BGC) diversity. The multicellular antibiotic-producing soil bacterium Streptomyces provides a useful model for exploring how internal conflicts emerge and are resolved in biology. These organisms must balance two resource-intensive processes that can create internal conflicts - natural product biosynthesis and sporulation. In Streptomyces there is potential to mitigate these internal conflicts through division of labour, phenotypic specialisation, and extensive gene duplication and diversification, enabling colonies to optimise both natural product production and reproductive success. Horizontal gene transfer further expands gene families and BGCs, introducing new metabolic capabilities while generating opportunities for functional divergence to reduce internal conflict and potentially promote kin selection. Natural product BGCs also possess features that could identify them as ‘greenbeards’ (kin selection by trait), promoting cooperation among producers and harming non-producers. The coexistence of multiple natural product BGCs and resistance mechanisms in Streptomyces is discussed in the context of the diverse eco-evolutionary processes occurring in structured natural environments, competition among close relatives, recurrent BGC acquisition, and regulatory compatibility encountered by Streptomyces.