Community benefit through community ownership of renewable generation in Scotland: power to the people?

Aileen McHarg

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

Community ownership is being promoted by the Scottish Government as a means of delivering economic benefits to communities in which renewable electricity developments are situated. This paper argues that community ownership should be regarded as more than simply a strategy for increasing the public acceptability of renewable energy projects, but rather that has considerable transformative potential: for the economic sustainability of host communities; in relation to wider issues concerning the social distribution of power and resources; and for the energy industry itself. The paper discusses, first, the financial and other advantages of community ownership, as compared with more conventional methods of delivering community benefit. Second, it explores the relationship between community ownership of renewables and wider processes of land reform in Scotland. Finally, it considers the potential of community ownership to be the harbinger of a new model of 'energy democracy' which challenges the prevailing neo-liberal paradigm.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationSharing the Costs and Benefits of Energy and Resource Activity
Subtitle of host publicationLegal Change and Impact on Communities
EditorsLila Barrera-Hernandez, Barry Barton, Lee Godden, Alastair Lucas, Anita Rønne
Publication statusPublished - 31 Mar 2016

Fingerprint

community
energy industry
distribution of power
agrarian reform
renewable energy
electricity
economics
sustainability
democracy
paradigm
energy
resources

Keywords

  • Scotland
  • renewable energy
  • community ownership
  • land reform
  • energy democracy

Cite this

McHarg, A. (2016). Community benefit through community ownership of renewable generation in Scotland: power to the people? In L. Barrera-Hernandez, B. Barton, L. Godden, A. Lucas, & A. Rønne (Eds.), Sharing the Costs and Benefits of Energy and Resource Activity: Legal Change and Impact on Communities
McHarg, Aileen. / Community benefit through community ownership of renewable generation in Scotland : power to the people?. Sharing the Costs and Benefits of Energy and Resource Activity: Legal Change and Impact on Communities. editor / Lila Barrera-Hernandez ; Barry Barton ; Lee Godden ; Alastair Lucas ; Anita Rønne. 2016.
@inbook{b5ff5cbaddcf4be88b8905f743f4d27e,
title = "Community benefit through community ownership of renewable generation in Scotland: power to the people?",
abstract = "Community ownership is being promoted by the Scottish Government as a means of delivering economic benefits to communities in which renewable electricity developments are situated. This paper argues that community ownership should be regarded as more than simply a strategy for increasing the public acceptability of renewable energy projects, but rather that has considerable transformative potential: for the economic sustainability of host communities; in relation to wider issues concerning the social distribution of power and resources; and for the energy industry itself. The paper discusses, first, the financial and other advantages of community ownership, as compared with more conventional methods of delivering community benefit. Second, it explores the relationship between community ownership of renewables and wider processes of land reform in Scotland. Finally, it considers the potential of community ownership to be the harbinger of a new model of 'energy democracy' which challenges the prevailing neo-liberal paradigm.",
keywords = "Scotland, renewable energy, community ownership, land reform, energy democracy",
author = "Aileen McHarg",
year = "2016",
month = "3",
day = "31",
language = "English",
isbn = "9780198767954",
editor = "Lila Barrera-Hernandez and Barry Barton and Lee Godden and Alastair Lucas and Anita R{\o}nne",
booktitle = "Sharing the Costs and Benefits of Energy and Resource Activity",

}

McHarg, A 2016, Community benefit through community ownership of renewable generation in Scotland: power to the people? in L Barrera-Hernandez, B Barton, L Godden, A Lucas & A Rønne (eds), Sharing the Costs and Benefits of Energy and Resource Activity: Legal Change and Impact on Communities.

Community benefit through community ownership of renewable generation in Scotland : power to the people? / McHarg, Aileen.

Sharing the Costs and Benefits of Energy and Resource Activity: Legal Change and Impact on Communities. ed. / Lila Barrera-Hernandez; Barry Barton; Lee Godden; Alastair Lucas; Anita Rønne. 2016.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Community benefit through community ownership of renewable generation in Scotland

T2 - power to the people?

AU - McHarg, Aileen

PY - 2016/3/31

Y1 - 2016/3/31

N2 - Community ownership is being promoted by the Scottish Government as a means of delivering economic benefits to communities in which renewable electricity developments are situated. This paper argues that community ownership should be regarded as more than simply a strategy for increasing the public acceptability of renewable energy projects, but rather that has considerable transformative potential: for the economic sustainability of host communities; in relation to wider issues concerning the social distribution of power and resources; and for the energy industry itself. The paper discusses, first, the financial and other advantages of community ownership, as compared with more conventional methods of delivering community benefit. Second, it explores the relationship between community ownership of renewables and wider processes of land reform in Scotland. Finally, it considers the potential of community ownership to be the harbinger of a new model of 'energy democracy' which challenges the prevailing neo-liberal paradigm.

AB - Community ownership is being promoted by the Scottish Government as a means of delivering economic benefits to communities in which renewable electricity developments are situated. This paper argues that community ownership should be regarded as more than simply a strategy for increasing the public acceptability of renewable energy projects, but rather that has considerable transformative potential: for the economic sustainability of host communities; in relation to wider issues concerning the social distribution of power and resources; and for the energy industry itself. The paper discusses, first, the financial and other advantages of community ownership, as compared with more conventional methods of delivering community benefit. Second, it explores the relationship between community ownership of renewables and wider processes of land reform in Scotland. Finally, it considers the potential of community ownership to be the harbinger of a new model of 'energy democracy' which challenges the prevailing neo-liberal paradigm.

KW - Scotland

KW - renewable energy

KW - community ownership

KW - land reform

KW - energy democracy

UR - https://global.oup.com/academic/product/sharing-the-costs-and-benefits-of-energy-and-resource-activity-9780198767954?q=9780198767954&lang=en&cc=gb

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9780198767954

BT - Sharing the Costs and Benefits of Energy and Resource Activity

A2 - Barrera-Hernandez, Lila

A2 - Barton, Barry

A2 - Godden, Lee

A2 - Lucas, Alastair

A2 - Rønne, Anita

ER -

McHarg A. Community benefit through community ownership of renewable generation in Scotland: power to the people? In Barrera-Hernandez L, Barton B, Godden L, Lucas A, Rønne A, editors, Sharing the Costs and Benefits of Energy and Resource Activity: Legal Change and Impact on Communities. 2016