Change within the probation service: evaluation from an action research perspective

Steve Fineman, Colin Eden

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    3 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    The present account results from twelve months of the authors' involvement with a probation service undergoing change. The change was initiated by an external body to the service and was based upon an apparently plausible rationale. Nevertheless considerable difficulties arose in the implementation of the change and these have provided some specific insights into the functioning of the organisation, and the values, attitudes and beliefs of some of its key decision-makers. The data have also formed the basis of an action research programme (which is currently underway) and have generated substantive material from which to draw conclusions concerning the salient factors affecting the change. We believe that these conclusions, which form the core of this article, have particular implications for the management of change in professional settings, such as research and development, schools and further education establishments. These settings, like a probation service, are characteristically client centred, where the professionals ‘… are trained on the outside, usually at the public expense, and a large number of rules are inculcated into them. They bring these into the organization and are expected to act upon them without further reference to their skills’. Furthermore we consider that the essence of our findings has important implications for any organisation where internal or external change agents are attempting to bring about change.
    LanguageEnglish
    Pages30-35
    Number of pages5
    JournalPersonnel Review
    Volume8
    Issue number2
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 1979

    Fingerprint

    Health Services Research
    Organizations
    Education
    Research
    Service evaluation
    Probation

    Keywords

    • probation service
    • action research perspective
    • change
    • management science
    • operational research

    Cite this

    @article{483d452f36b64c11bbadd3ee2cdbaf01,
    title = "Change within the probation service: evaluation from an action research perspective",
    abstract = "The present account results from twelve months of the authors' involvement with a probation service undergoing change. The change was initiated by an external body to the service and was based upon an apparently plausible rationale. Nevertheless considerable difficulties arose in the implementation of the change and these have provided some specific insights into the functioning of the organisation, and the values, attitudes and beliefs of some of its key decision-makers. The data have also formed the basis of an action research programme (which is currently underway) and have generated substantive material from which to draw conclusions concerning the salient factors affecting the change. We believe that these conclusions, which form the core of this article, have particular implications for the management of change in professional settings, such as research and development, schools and further education establishments. These settings, like a probation service, are characteristically client centred, where the professionals ‘… are trained on the outside, usually at the public expense, and a large number of rules are inculcated into them. They bring these into the organization and are expected to act upon them without further reference to their skills’. Furthermore we consider that the essence of our findings has important implications for any organisation where internal or external change agents are attempting to bring about change.",
    keywords = "probation service, action research perspective, change, management science, operational research",
    author = "Steve Fineman and Colin Eden",
    year = "1979",
    doi = "10.1108/eb055381",
    language = "English",
    volume = "8",
    pages = "30--35",
    journal = "Personnel Review",
    issn = "0048-3486",
    publisher = "Emerald Publishing Limited",
    number = "2",

    }

    Change within the probation service : evaluation from an action research perspective. / Fineman, Steve; Eden, Colin.

    In: Personnel Review, Vol. 8, No. 2, 1979, p. 30-35.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Change within the probation service

    T2 - Personnel Review

    AU - Fineman, Steve

    AU - Eden, Colin

    PY - 1979

    Y1 - 1979

    N2 - The present account results from twelve months of the authors' involvement with a probation service undergoing change. The change was initiated by an external body to the service and was based upon an apparently plausible rationale. Nevertheless considerable difficulties arose in the implementation of the change and these have provided some specific insights into the functioning of the organisation, and the values, attitudes and beliefs of some of its key decision-makers. The data have also formed the basis of an action research programme (which is currently underway) and have generated substantive material from which to draw conclusions concerning the salient factors affecting the change. We believe that these conclusions, which form the core of this article, have particular implications for the management of change in professional settings, such as research and development, schools and further education establishments. These settings, like a probation service, are characteristically client centred, where the professionals ‘… are trained on the outside, usually at the public expense, and a large number of rules are inculcated into them. They bring these into the organization and are expected to act upon them without further reference to their skills’. Furthermore we consider that the essence of our findings has important implications for any organisation where internal or external change agents are attempting to bring about change.

    AB - The present account results from twelve months of the authors' involvement with a probation service undergoing change. The change was initiated by an external body to the service and was based upon an apparently plausible rationale. Nevertheless considerable difficulties arose in the implementation of the change and these have provided some specific insights into the functioning of the organisation, and the values, attitudes and beliefs of some of its key decision-makers. The data have also formed the basis of an action research programme (which is currently underway) and have generated substantive material from which to draw conclusions concerning the salient factors affecting the change. We believe that these conclusions, which form the core of this article, have particular implications for the management of change in professional settings, such as research and development, schools and further education establishments. These settings, like a probation service, are characteristically client centred, where the professionals ‘… are trained on the outside, usually at the public expense, and a large number of rules are inculcated into them. They bring these into the organization and are expected to act upon them without further reference to their skills’. Furthermore we consider that the essence of our findings has important implications for any organisation where internal or external change agents are attempting to bring about change.

    KW - probation service

    KW - action research perspective

    KW - change

    KW - management science

    KW - operational research

    U2 - 10.1108/eb055381

    DO - 10.1108/eb055381

    M3 - Article

    VL - 8

    SP - 30

    EP - 35

    JO - Personnel Review

    JF - Personnel Review

    SN - 0048-3486

    IS - 2

    ER -