Carceral framing of human rights in Russian prisons

Laura Piacentini, Elena Katz

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

This paper introduces to punishment and society scholarship a new carceral framing of human rights in Russian prisons. Russian imprisonment remains elusive to prisons scholars and ethnographers around the world. Moreover, on the subject of prisoners’ rights specifically, the scholarship is dominated by legal discourse. The empirical and theoretical scholarship that has developed over the last twenty years has argued that Russian imprisonment is exceptional in the study of world penal systems with the research seeking to gain a sense of this exceptionality through looking at the inertial legacies of Gulag penal culture on present day punishment forms. This article attempts to challenge this claim and will argue that specifically in the area of human rights, Russia has followed a not dissimilar carceral formation to Western prisons. Through an interrogation of the cultural, political and historical factors underpinning how rights are framed in Russian prisons the article suggests that human rights are operationalised as a lever for legal and penal control. This is a significant new finding in the study of Russian imprisonment because of the questions that arise around penal resilience, how rights and penal power develop through discourse and how global penal norms converge across jurisdictions.
LanguageEnglish
Number of pages30
JournalPunishment and Society
Early online date22 Aug 2016
DOIs
StateE-pub ahead of print - 22 Aug 2016

Fingerprint

correctional institution
imprisonment
human rights
penalty
gulag
discourse
prisoner
resilience
jurisdiction
Russia
present

Keywords

  • Russian
  • prisons
  • carceral
  • framing
  • human
  • rights
  • European
  • pravosoznaniye
  • imprisonment
  • penal systems

Cite this

@article{84aabcc4a14141afac6c3574d9672e05,
title = "Carceral framing of human rights in Russian prisons",
abstract = "This paper introduces to punishment and society scholarship a new carceral framing of human rights in Russian prisons. Russian imprisonment remains elusive to prisons scholars and ethnographers around the world. Moreover, on the subject of prisoners’ rights specifically, the scholarship is dominated by legal discourse. The empirical and theoretical scholarship that has developed over the last twenty years has argued that Russian imprisonment is exceptional in the study of world penal systems with the research seeking to gain a sense of this exceptionality through looking at the inertial legacies of Gulag penal culture on present day punishment forms. This article attempts to challenge this claim and will argue that specifically in the area of human rights, Russia has followed a not dissimilar carceral formation to Western prisons. Through an interrogation of the cultural, political and historical factors underpinning how rights are framed in Russian prisons the article suggests that human rights are operationalised as a lever for legal and penal control. This is a significant new finding in the study of Russian imprisonment because of the questions that arise around penal resilience, how rights and penal power develop through discourse and how global penal norms converge across jurisdictions.",
keywords = "Russian, prisons, carceral, framing, human, rights, European, pravosoznaniye, imprisonment, penal systems",
author = "Laura Piacentini and Elena Katz",
year = "2016",
month = "8",
day = "22",
doi = "10.1177/1462474516665609",
language = "English",
journal = "Punishment and Society",
issn = "1462-4745",

}

Carceral framing of human rights in Russian prisons. / Piacentini, Laura; Katz, Elena.

In: Punishment and Society, 22.08.2016.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Carceral framing of human rights in Russian prisons

AU - Piacentini,Laura

AU - Katz,Elena

PY - 2016/8/22

Y1 - 2016/8/22

N2 - This paper introduces to punishment and society scholarship a new carceral framing of human rights in Russian prisons. Russian imprisonment remains elusive to prisons scholars and ethnographers around the world. Moreover, on the subject of prisoners’ rights specifically, the scholarship is dominated by legal discourse. The empirical and theoretical scholarship that has developed over the last twenty years has argued that Russian imprisonment is exceptional in the study of world penal systems with the research seeking to gain a sense of this exceptionality through looking at the inertial legacies of Gulag penal culture on present day punishment forms. This article attempts to challenge this claim and will argue that specifically in the area of human rights, Russia has followed a not dissimilar carceral formation to Western prisons. Through an interrogation of the cultural, political and historical factors underpinning how rights are framed in Russian prisons the article suggests that human rights are operationalised as a lever for legal and penal control. This is a significant new finding in the study of Russian imprisonment because of the questions that arise around penal resilience, how rights and penal power develop through discourse and how global penal norms converge across jurisdictions.

AB - This paper introduces to punishment and society scholarship a new carceral framing of human rights in Russian prisons. Russian imprisonment remains elusive to prisons scholars and ethnographers around the world. Moreover, on the subject of prisoners’ rights specifically, the scholarship is dominated by legal discourse. The empirical and theoretical scholarship that has developed over the last twenty years has argued that Russian imprisonment is exceptional in the study of world penal systems with the research seeking to gain a sense of this exceptionality through looking at the inertial legacies of Gulag penal culture on present day punishment forms. This article attempts to challenge this claim and will argue that specifically in the area of human rights, Russia has followed a not dissimilar carceral formation to Western prisons. Through an interrogation of the cultural, political and historical factors underpinning how rights are framed in Russian prisons the article suggests that human rights are operationalised as a lever for legal and penal control. This is a significant new finding in the study of Russian imprisonment because of the questions that arise around penal resilience, how rights and penal power develop through discourse and how global penal norms converge across jurisdictions.

KW - Russian

KW - prisons

KW - carceral

KW - framing

KW - human

KW - rights

KW - European

KW - pravosoznaniye

KW - imprisonment

KW - penal systems

UR - http://pun.sagepub.com/

U2 - 10.1177/1462474516665609

DO - 10.1177/1462474516665609

M3 - Article

JO - Punishment and Society

T2 - Punishment and Society

JF - Punishment and Society

SN - 1462-4745

ER -