Can we use the cohort II data to explore the effects of taking pass plus?

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

The Cohort II study sampled 8000 candidates taking their practical driving test in the UK with a practical questionnaire just after taking their practical driving test and experience questionnaires at 6, 12, 24 and 36 months after test pass. The use of this information to determine the effectiveness of the Pass Plus training scheme for new drivers was investigated. Pass Plus requires a minimum of six hours' training, though this may not necessarily be separate sessions. It consists of 6 modules covering town driving, all-weather driving, driving out of town, night driving, driving on dual carriageways and driving on motorways. The take-up rate for Pass Plus is currently around 16%. It is considered that the Cohort II data are not ideal for a study of Pass Plus as the data are not derived from an experimental study and are self-reported. Also, those members of the cohort taking Pass Plus are a self-selected group so it is not possible to use randomised controlled trials to evaluate the Cohort II data. A comparison of persons taking and not taking Pass Plus was made. With one exception there were no differences between those Cohort II respondents who took Pass Plus in the first six months of driving and those who did not in terms of their accident rates or driving behaviour. The exception was that Pass Plus drivers reported committing fewer aggressive driving violations than those who did not take Pass Plus. It is considered that the results should be treated with caution because of the possibility of volunteer bias. A trial where the Pass Plus intervention was mandatory in a given area and not another area would provide a proper controlled experimental design. For the covering abstract see ITRD E138063.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationBehavioural research in road safety 2006
Subtitle of host publicationsixteenth seminar
Pages225-236
Number of pages11
Publication statusPublished - 2006

Fingerprint

Weather
Accidents
Volunteers
Cohort Studies
Research Design
Randomized Controlled Trials
Surveys and Questionnaires

Keywords

  • attitudes
  • driver training
  • driving
  • recently qualified drivers

Cite this

Elliott, M. A. (2006). Can we use the cohort II data to explore the effects of taking pass plus? In Behavioural research in road safety 2006: sixteenth seminar (pp. 225-236)
Elliott, M.A. / Can we use the cohort II data to explore the effects of taking pass plus?. Behavioural research in road safety 2006: sixteenth seminar. 2006. pp. 225-236
@inbook{a352183ee4514c4bb49c90b8d8453f33,
title = "Can we use the cohort II data to explore the effects of taking pass plus?",
abstract = "The Cohort II study sampled 8000 candidates taking their practical driving test in the UK with a practical questionnaire just after taking their practical driving test and experience questionnaires at 6, 12, 24 and 36 months after test pass. The use of this information to determine the effectiveness of the Pass Plus training scheme for new drivers was investigated. Pass Plus requires a minimum of six hours' training, though this may not necessarily be separate sessions. It consists of 6 modules covering town driving, all-weather driving, driving out of town, night driving, driving on dual carriageways and driving on motorways. The take-up rate for Pass Plus is currently around 16{\%}. It is considered that the Cohort II data are not ideal for a study of Pass Plus as the data are not derived from an experimental study and are self-reported. Also, those members of the cohort taking Pass Plus are a self-selected group so it is not possible to use randomised controlled trials to evaluate the Cohort II data. A comparison of persons taking and not taking Pass Plus was made. With one exception there were no differences between those Cohort II respondents who took Pass Plus in the first six months of driving and those who did not in terms of their accident rates or driving behaviour. The exception was that Pass Plus drivers reported committing fewer aggressive driving violations than those who did not take Pass Plus. It is considered that the results should be treated with caution because of the possibility of volunteer bias. A trial where the Pass Plus intervention was mandatory in a given area and not another area would provide a proper controlled experimental design. For the covering abstract see ITRD E138063.",
keywords = "attitudes, driver training, driving, recently qualified drivers",
author = "M.A. Elliott",
year = "2006",
language = "English",
isbn = "1904763707",
pages = "225--236",
booktitle = "Behavioural research in road safety 2006",

}

Elliott, MA 2006, Can we use the cohort II data to explore the effects of taking pass plus? in Behavioural research in road safety 2006: sixteenth seminar. pp. 225-236.

Can we use the cohort II data to explore the effects of taking pass plus? / Elliott, M.A.

Behavioural research in road safety 2006: sixteenth seminar. 2006. p. 225-236.

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Can we use the cohort II data to explore the effects of taking pass plus?

AU - Elliott, M.A.

PY - 2006

Y1 - 2006

N2 - The Cohort II study sampled 8000 candidates taking their practical driving test in the UK with a practical questionnaire just after taking their practical driving test and experience questionnaires at 6, 12, 24 and 36 months after test pass. The use of this information to determine the effectiveness of the Pass Plus training scheme for new drivers was investigated. Pass Plus requires a minimum of six hours' training, though this may not necessarily be separate sessions. It consists of 6 modules covering town driving, all-weather driving, driving out of town, night driving, driving on dual carriageways and driving on motorways. The take-up rate for Pass Plus is currently around 16%. It is considered that the Cohort II data are not ideal for a study of Pass Plus as the data are not derived from an experimental study and are self-reported. Also, those members of the cohort taking Pass Plus are a self-selected group so it is not possible to use randomised controlled trials to evaluate the Cohort II data. A comparison of persons taking and not taking Pass Plus was made. With one exception there were no differences between those Cohort II respondents who took Pass Plus in the first six months of driving and those who did not in terms of their accident rates or driving behaviour. The exception was that Pass Plus drivers reported committing fewer aggressive driving violations than those who did not take Pass Plus. It is considered that the results should be treated with caution because of the possibility of volunteer bias. A trial where the Pass Plus intervention was mandatory in a given area and not another area would provide a proper controlled experimental design. For the covering abstract see ITRD E138063.

AB - The Cohort II study sampled 8000 candidates taking their practical driving test in the UK with a practical questionnaire just after taking their practical driving test and experience questionnaires at 6, 12, 24 and 36 months after test pass. The use of this information to determine the effectiveness of the Pass Plus training scheme for new drivers was investigated. Pass Plus requires a minimum of six hours' training, though this may not necessarily be separate sessions. It consists of 6 modules covering town driving, all-weather driving, driving out of town, night driving, driving on dual carriageways and driving on motorways. The take-up rate for Pass Plus is currently around 16%. It is considered that the Cohort II data are not ideal for a study of Pass Plus as the data are not derived from an experimental study and are self-reported. Also, those members of the cohort taking Pass Plus are a self-selected group so it is not possible to use randomised controlled trials to evaluate the Cohort II data. A comparison of persons taking and not taking Pass Plus was made. With one exception there were no differences between those Cohort II respondents who took Pass Plus in the first six months of driving and those who did not in terms of their accident rates or driving behaviour. The exception was that Pass Plus drivers reported committing fewer aggressive driving violations than those who did not take Pass Plus. It is considered that the results should be treated with caution because of the possibility of volunteer bias. A trial where the Pass Plus intervention was mandatory in a given area and not another area would provide a proper controlled experimental design. For the covering abstract see ITRD E138063.

KW - attitudes

KW - driver training

KW - driving

KW - recently qualified drivers

UR - http://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/+/http://www.dft.gov.uk/pgr/roadsafety/research/behavioural/sixteenthseminar/pdf.pdf

M3 - Chapter

SN - 1904763707

SP - 225

EP - 236

BT - Behavioural research in road safety 2006

ER -

Elliott MA. Can we use the cohort II data to explore the effects of taking pass plus? In Behavioural research in road safety 2006: sixteenth seminar. 2006. p. 225-236