Burden or benefit? paradoxes of penal transition in Russia

L.F. Piacentini, Kieran McEvoy (Editor), Lorna McGregor (Editor)

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter


Although relatively new as a distinct field of study, transitional justice has become rapidly established as a vital field of enquiry. From vaguely exotic origins on the outer edges of political science, the study of 'justice' in times of transition has emerged as a central concern of scholarship and practical policy-making. A process of institutionalisation has confirmed this importance. The ICTY, the ICTR, the ICC, hybrid tribunals in Sierra Leone and East Timor and 'local' processes such as the Iraqi Higher Tribunal (IHT) have energised international law and international criminal justice scholarship. The South African TRC was for a time lauded as the model for dealing with the past and remains one of the most researched institutions in the world. It is one of approximately two dozen such institutions established in different transitional contexts over the past twenty years to assist conflicted societies to come to terms with a violent past. At the national level, international donors contribute huge sums of money to 'Rule of Law' programmes designed to transform national justice systems. This collection seeks to offer something quite different to the mainstream of scholarship in this area, emphasising the need for bespoke solutions to different transitions rather than 'off the shelf' models. The collection is designed to offer a space for diversity, prompted by a series of perspectives "from below" of societies beset by past violent conflict which have sought to effect their transition to justice. In doing so the contributors have also sought to enrich discussion about the role of human rights in transition, the continuing usefulness of perspectives from above, and the still contested meanings of "transition".
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationTransitional Justice from Below : Grassroots Activism and the Struggle for Change
Place of PublicationOxford
Number of pages19
Publication statusPublished - 15 Jul 2008


  • transitional justice
  • political science
  • justice
  • policy-making
  • international criminal law
  • violent conflict
  • penal transition
  • Russia

Cite this