Beauty Italian style: Gendered imaginings of, and responses to, stage divas in early post-unification literary culture

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

1 Citation (Scopus)

Abstract

In this article I argue that Bartky’s ‘fashion-beauty complex’ - a major articulation of capitalist patriarchy which seeks to glorify the female body, yet covertly depreciates it - gained momentum in Italian culture at the end of the nineteenth century through the emergence of the cosmetic industry and divas’ advertising of beauty products in women’s magazines. Through a close reading of the literary culture (reviews of divas’ performances in women’s and theatre journals, as well as realist fiction), I show that the discursive construction of the Italian diva in this period was gendered: though women writers demonstrate an awareness of, and take pleasure in the diva’s ‘beauty’, but above all celebrate her skills and talents as a performing artist, male writers - without exception - pass comment on the diva’s appearance over and above a critique of her performing skills. This would suggest that ‘the beauty myth’ – the idea that a woman’s value is determined by her appearance – was an integral component of divadom in late nineteenth-century Italy, and, for male journalists and writers, an even more important attribute than the diva’s acting or singing abilities.
LanguageEnglish
Pages330-346
Number of pages17
JournalItalian Studies
Volume70
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Aug 2015

Fingerprint

beauty
writer
nineteenth century
women's press
cosmetics
singing
patriarchy
journalist
theater
artist
myth
Italy
Literary Culture
Unification
Imagining
industry
ability
performance
Values
Writer

Keywords

  • fashion-beauty complex
  • feminine beauty
  • definitions of the diva
  • cosmetics industry
  • women writers

Cite this

@article{d893d180cc7043f1a168be45ba218d95,
title = "Beauty Italian style: Gendered imaginings of, and responses to, stage divas in early post-unification literary culture",
abstract = "In this article I argue that Bartky’s ‘fashion-beauty complex’ - a major articulation of capitalist patriarchy which seeks to glorify the female body, yet covertly depreciates it - gained momentum in Italian culture at the end of the nineteenth century through the emergence of the cosmetic industry and divas’ advertising of beauty products in women’s magazines. Through a close reading of the literary culture (reviews of divas’ performances in women’s and theatre journals, as well as realist fiction), I show that the discursive construction of the Italian diva in this period was gendered: though women writers demonstrate an awareness of, and take pleasure in the diva’s ‘beauty’, but above all celebrate her skills and talents as a performing artist, male writers - without exception - pass comment on the diva’s appearance over and above a critique of her performing skills. This would suggest that ‘the beauty myth’ – the idea that a woman’s value is determined by her appearance – was an integral component of divadom in late nineteenth-century Italy, and, for male journalists and writers, an even more important attribute than the diva’s acting or singing abilities.",
keywords = "fashion-beauty complex, feminine beauty, definitions of the diva, cosmetics industry, women writers",
author = "Katharine Mitchell",
year = "2015",
month = "8",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1179/0075163415Z.000000000105",
language = "English",
volume = "70",
pages = "330--346",
journal = "Italian Studies",
issn = "0075-1634",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - Beauty Italian style

T2 - Italian Studies

AU - Mitchell, Katharine

PY - 2015/8/1

Y1 - 2015/8/1

N2 - In this article I argue that Bartky’s ‘fashion-beauty complex’ - a major articulation of capitalist patriarchy which seeks to glorify the female body, yet covertly depreciates it - gained momentum in Italian culture at the end of the nineteenth century through the emergence of the cosmetic industry and divas’ advertising of beauty products in women’s magazines. Through a close reading of the literary culture (reviews of divas’ performances in women’s and theatre journals, as well as realist fiction), I show that the discursive construction of the Italian diva in this period was gendered: though women writers demonstrate an awareness of, and take pleasure in the diva’s ‘beauty’, but above all celebrate her skills and talents as a performing artist, male writers - without exception - pass comment on the diva’s appearance over and above a critique of her performing skills. This would suggest that ‘the beauty myth’ – the idea that a woman’s value is determined by her appearance – was an integral component of divadom in late nineteenth-century Italy, and, for male journalists and writers, an even more important attribute than the diva’s acting or singing abilities.

AB - In this article I argue that Bartky’s ‘fashion-beauty complex’ - a major articulation of capitalist patriarchy which seeks to glorify the female body, yet covertly depreciates it - gained momentum in Italian culture at the end of the nineteenth century through the emergence of the cosmetic industry and divas’ advertising of beauty products in women’s magazines. Through a close reading of the literary culture (reviews of divas’ performances in women’s and theatre journals, as well as realist fiction), I show that the discursive construction of the Italian diva in this period was gendered: though women writers demonstrate an awareness of, and take pleasure in the diva’s ‘beauty’, but above all celebrate her skills and talents as a performing artist, male writers - without exception - pass comment on the diva’s appearance over and above a critique of her performing skills. This would suggest that ‘the beauty myth’ – the idea that a woman’s value is determined by her appearance – was an integral component of divadom in late nineteenth-century Italy, and, for male journalists and writers, an even more important attribute than the diva’s acting or singing abilities.

KW - fashion-beauty complex

KW - feminine beauty

KW - definitions of the diva

KW - cosmetics industry

KW - women writers

UR - http://www.maneyonline.com/doi/abs/10.1179/0075163415Z.000000000105

UR - http://www.maneyonline.com/loi/its

U2 - 10.1179/0075163415Z.000000000105

DO - 10.1179/0075163415Z.000000000105

M3 - Article

VL - 70

SP - 330

EP - 346

JO - Italian Studies

JF - Italian Studies

SN - 0075-1634

IS - 3

ER -