Assessing the evidence base on health, employability and the labour market - lessons for activation in the UK

Colin Lindsay, Bent Greve, Ignazio Cabras, Nick Ellison, Stephen Kellett

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

Abstract

Despite recent attempts by UK policymakers to restrict access to incapacity and disability benefits (DBs), claimant numbers remain high by historical comparison. This article aims to offer direction on more productive foci for welfare reform and activation policies. It reviews the latest evidence on the ‘nature of the problem’ (i.e. the factors contributing to high levels of DBs among some groups and communities); analyzes the appropriateness of current and recent policies in responding to these factors; and contrasts the UK's approach with that of Denmark. The chapter presents details of the structured literature and evidence review that identified the most robust evidence from both academic sources and policy stakeholders. The review confirms a disconnect between the evidence on the nature of the DBs ‘problem’ and an increasingly narrow and behaviourist policy agenda implemented under successive UK governments. It also reveals that alternative policy approaches are possible.
LanguageEnglish
Title of host publicationNew Perspectives on Health, Disability, Welfare and the Labour Market
EditorsColin Lindsay, Bent Greve, Ignazio Cabras, Nick Ellison, Stephen Kellett
Place of PublicationChichester, UK
Pages5-23
Number of pages19
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 7 Oct 2015

Publication series

Name Broadening Perspectives in Social Policy
PublisherWiley-Blackwell

Fingerprint

employability
activation
labor market
health
evidence
policy approach
Denmark
welfare
stakeholder
reform
community
Group

Keywords

  • activation policies
  • behaviourist policy agenda
  • Denmark's DB claim rate
  • disability benefits
  • incapacity benefits
  • labour market
  • UK policymakers
  • welfare reform

Cite this

Lindsay, C., Greve, B., Cabras, I., Ellison, N., & Kellett, S. (2015). Assessing the evidence base on health, employability and the labour market - lessons for activation in the UK. In C. Lindsay, B. Greve, I. Cabras, N. Ellison, & S. Kellett (Eds.), New Perspectives on Health, Disability, Welfare and the Labour Market (pp. 5-23). ( Broadening Perspectives in Social Policy). Chichester, UK. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119145486.ch1
Lindsay, Colin ; Greve, Bent ; Cabras, Ignazio ; Ellison, Nick ; Kellett, Stephen. / Assessing the evidence base on health, employability and the labour market - lessons for activation in the UK. New Perspectives on Health, Disability, Welfare and the Labour Market. editor / Colin Lindsay ; Bent Greve ; Ignazio Cabras ; Nick Ellison ; Stephen Kellett. Chichester, UK, 2015. pp. 5-23 ( Broadening Perspectives in Social Policy).
@inbook{d00fcfb819384b099e8480df36f72b6c,
title = "Assessing the evidence base on health, employability and the labour market - lessons for activation in the UK",
abstract = "Despite recent attempts by UK policymakers to restrict access to incapacity and disability benefits (DBs), claimant numbers remain high by historical comparison. This article aims to offer direction on more productive foci for welfare reform and activation policies. It reviews the latest evidence on the ‘nature of the problem’ (i.e. the factors contributing to high levels of DBs among some groups and communities); analyzes the appropriateness of current and recent policies in responding to these factors; and contrasts the UK's approach with that of Denmark. The chapter presents details of the structured literature and evidence review that identified the most robust evidence from both academic sources and policy stakeholders. The review confirms a disconnect between the evidence on the nature of the DBs ‘problem’ and an increasingly narrow and behaviourist policy agenda implemented under successive UK governments. It also reveals that alternative policy approaches are possible.",
keywords = "activation policies, behaviourist policy agenda, Denmark's DB claim rate, disability benefits, incapacity benefits, labour market, UK policymakers, welfare reform",
author = "Colin Lindsay and Bent Greve and Ignazio Cabras and Nick Ellison and Stephen Kellett",
year = "2015",
month = "10",
day = "7",
doi = "10.1002/9781119145486.ch1",
language = "English",
isbn = "9781119145516",
series = "Broadening Perspectives in Social Policy",
publisher = "Wiley-Blackwell",
pages = "5--23",
editor = "Colin Lindsay and Bent Greve and Ignazio Cabras and Nick Ellison and Stephen Kellett",
booktitle = "New Perspectives on Health, Disability, Welfare and the Labour Market",

}

Lindsay, C, Greve, B, Cabras, I, Ellison, N & Kellett, S 2015, Assessing the evidence base on health, employability and the labour market - lessons for activation in the UK. in C Lindsay, B Greve, I Cabras, N Ellison & S Kellett (eds), New Perspectives on Health, Disability, Welfare and the Labour Market. Broadening Perspectives in Social Policy, Chichester, UK, pp. 5-23. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119145486.ch1

Assessing the evidence base on health, employability and the labour market - lessons for activation in the UK. / Lindsay, Colin; Greve, Bent; Cabras, Ignazio; Ellison, Nick; Kellett, Stephen.

New Perspectives on Health, Disability, Welfare and the Labour Market. ed. / Colin Lindsay; Bent Greve; Ignazio Cabras; Nick Ellison; Stephen Kellett. Chichester, UK, 2015. p. 5-23 ( Broadening Perspectives in Social Policy).

Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

TY - CHAP

T1 - Assessing the evidence base on health, employability and the labour market - lessons for activation in the UK

AU - Lindsay, Colin

AU - Greve, Bent

AU - Cabras, Ignazio

AU - Ellison, Nick

AU - Kellett, Stephen

PY - 2015/10/7

Y1 - 2015/10/7

N2 - Despite recent attempts by UK policymakers to restrict access to incapacity and disability benefits (DBs), claimant numbers remain high by historical comparison. This article aims to offer direction on more productive foci for welfare reform and activation policies. It reviews the latest evidence on the ‘nature of the problem’ (i.e. the factors contributing to high levels of DBs among some groups and communities); analyzes the appropriateness of current and recent policies in responding to these factors; and contrasts the UK's approach with that of Denmark. The chapter presents details of the structured literature and evidence review that identified the most robust evidence from both academic sources and policy stakeholders. The review confirms a disconnect between the evidence on the nature of the DBs ‘problem’ and an increasingly narrow and behaviourist policy agenda implemented under successive UK governments. It also reveals that alternative policy approaches are possible.

AB - Despite recent attempts by UK policymakers to restrict access to incapacity and disability benefits (DBs), claimant numbers remain high by historical comparison. This article aims to offer direction on more productive foci for welfare reform and activation policies. It reviews the latest evidence on the ‘nature of the problem’ (i.e. the factors contributing to high levels of DBs among some groups and communities); analyzes the appropriateness of current and recent policies in responding to these factors; and contrasts the UK's approach with that of Denmark. The chapter presents details of the structured literature and evidence review that identified the most robust evidence from both academic sources and policy stakeholders. The review confirms a disconnect between the evidence on the nature of the DBs ‘problem’ and an increasingly narrow and behaviourist policy agenda implemented under successive UK governments. It also reveals that alternative policy approaches are possible.

KW - activation policies

KW - behaviourist policy agenda

KW - Denmark's DB claim rate

KW - disability benefits

KW - incapacity benefits

KW - labour market

KW - UK policymakers

KW - welfare reform

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84955124100&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://dx.doi.org/10.1002/9781119145486

U2 - 10.1002/9781119145486.ch1

DO - 10.1002/9781119145486.ch1

M3 - Chapter

SN - 9781119145516

T3 - Broadening Perspectives in Social Policy

SP - 5

EP - 23

BT - New Perspectives on Health, Disability, Welfare and the Labour Market

A2 - Lindsay, Colin

A2 - Greve, Bent

A2 - Cabras, Ignazio

A2 - Ellison, Nick

A2 - Kellett, Stephen

CY - Chichester, UK

ER -

Lindsay C, Greve B, Cabras I, Ellison N, Kellett S. Assessing the evidence base on health, employability and the labour market - lessons for activation in the UK. In Lindsay C, Greve B, Cabras I, Ellison N, Kellett S, editors, New Perspectives on Health, Disability, Welfare and the Labour Market. Chichester, UK. 2015. p. 5-23. ( Broadening Perspectives in Social Policy). https://doi.org/10.1002/9781119145486.ch1