Abstract
/l/ and /r/ are synchronically and diachronically complex speech-sound categories that can function phonologically as syllable margins, or as nuclei without being considered true vowels, and are often grouped together as ‘liquids’ (for cross-linguistic perceptual evidence, see (Howson & Madathodiyil, 2023)). They are articulatorily complex sounds that show a great deal of variation within and between languages, and comparable analytic techniques can be used to help understand them. However, when we take into account their heterogeneity, treating /l/ and /r/ as one category might be seen as an idealization, implying greater similarity than is theoretically justified. In particular, rhotic variants are diverse to the extent that identifying unifying features (articulatory and acoustic) within each category is difficult, much less finding features that unify /l/ and /r/. The heterogeneity of /l/ and /r/ is extensively described in (Ladefoged & Maddieson, 1996chapters 6 & 7), and in (Lindau, 1985; Scobbie, 2006; Sebregts, 2015) and is not addressed further here. However, in addition to highly salient aspects of phonetic variation, acoustic and articulatory instrumental analyses reveal subtle, covert variation, including for example incomplete central occlusion, or even absence of a central occlusion in [l] (Ladefoged & Maddieson, 1996, pp. 183-185; Scobbie & Pouplier, 2010), or marked variation in place of articulation, gesture timing and tongue configuration for approximant [ɹ] (Delattre & Freeman, 1968; Lawson et al., 2011; Lawson et al., 2018). As we shall see, even such subtle articulatory variation can index social categories.
Although /l/ and /r/ variants may consist of a single articulation (Gick et al., 2006), the gestural composition of /l/ and /r/ variants often involves combinations of articulatory strictures of different degrees: e.g. in the pharynx, at the velar, palatal and alveolar regions and at the lips. Perceptible gradient variations in the quality of liquids can be the result of variation in gesture sequencing and separation, perhaps motivated by perceptual recoverability, or biomechanical factors (Gick, 2004).
In English and many other languages (e.g. Quebecois French, see Hutin and Lancien (2024)), positionally-conditioned variability results in variants that are respectively more consonantal (strong), or more vocalized (weak). Consequently, in postvocalic position, liquids have often weakened to the point of complete phonological deletion, usually with compensatory lengthening of the preceding vowel – e.g. coda /l/ in Middle English psalm and half (Dobson, 1957 §425), coda /l/ in Middle Scots after back vowels: salt [sɔːt] [ɔ] all [ɔː], full [fʉː] etc. (Macafee & Aitken, 2002); postvocalic /r/ in early modern English lard [lɑːd] (Dobson, 1957 §427; Wells, 1982a, 1982b).
Posterior lingual gestures involving the tongue dorsum, or root, may also lead to vowel epenthesis (emergence of an extra, transitional vowel, feel [fiᵊlˠ], hear [hiᵊɹ]), or retraction of preceding vowels, far [fa̠ɹ] (Wilson & Gick, 2014). The phenomenon is evident historically (e.g. Old English, (Campbell, 1959 §§ 139-149; Marshall Denton, 2001) and in present-day rless (nonrhotic) Englishes (Wells, 1982b, 1982c) and Dutch (Plug & Ogden, 2003; Scobbie et al., 2009; Sebregts, 2015). These multiple coordinated gestures help explain the phonetic diversity of /l/ and /r/; v[EL1.1][EL1.2][JS1.3]ariants that can be used to index a range of social characteristics (often called socially indexical characteristics), including national, regional, or ethnic identity, social class and gender.
Although /l/ and /r/ variants may consist of a single articulation (Gick et al., 2006), the gestural composition of /l/ and /r/ variants often involves combinations of articulatory strictures of different degrees: e.g. in the pharynx, at the velar, palatal and alveolar regions and at the lips. Perceptible gradient variations in the quality of liquids can be the result of variation in gesture sequencing and separation, perhaps motivated by perceptual recoverability, or biomechanical factors (Gick, 2004).
In English and many other languages (e.g. Quebecois French, see Hutin and Lancien (2024)), positionally-conditioned variability results in variants that are respectively more consonantal (strong), or more vocalized (weak). Consequently, in postvocalic position, liquids have often weakened to the point of complete phonological deletion, usually with compensatory lengthening of the preceding vowel – e.g. coda /l/ in Middle English psalm and half (Dobson, 1957 §425), coda /l/ in Middle Scots after back vowels: salt [sɔːt] [ɔ] all [ɔː], full [fʉː] etc. (Macafee & Aitken, 2002); postvocalic /r/ in early modern English lard [lɑːd] (Dobson, 1957 §427; Wells, 1982a, 1982b).
Posterior lingual gestures involving the tongue dorsum, or root, may also lead to vowel epenthesis (emergence of an extra, transitional vowel, feel [fiᵊlˠ], hear [hiᵊɹ]), or retraction of preceding vowels, far [fa̠ɹ] (Wilson & Gick, 2014). The phenomenon is evident historically (e.g. Old English, (Campbell, 1959 §§ 139-149; Marshall Denton, 2001) and in present-day rless (nonrhotic) Englishes (Wells, 1982b, 1982c) and Dutch (Plug & Ogden, 2003; Scobbie et al., 2009; Sebregts, 2015). These multiple coordinated gestures help explain the phonetic diversity of /l/ and /r/; v[EL1.1][EL1.2][JS1.3]ariants that can be used to index a range of social characteristics (often called socially indexical characteristics), including national, regional, or ethnic identity, social class and gender.
| Original language | English |
|---|---|
| Title of host publication | Sociophonetics A Student's Guide |
| Editors | Marianna Di Paolo, Malcah Yaeger-Dror |
| Publisher | Routledge |
| Chapter | 7 |
| Edition | 2nd |
| Publication status | Accepted/In press - 7 Jul 2026 |
Keywords
- speech sound categories
- speech sounds
Fingerprint
Dive into the research topics of 'Analyzing liquids'. Together they form a unique fingerprint.Cite this
- APA
- Author
- BIBTEX
- Harvard
- Standard
- RIS
- Vancouver