Analysis of effectiveness of fire safety in machinery spaces

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

The primary cause of machinery space fires is cited as the release of flammable oil mist contacting unprotected hot surfaces. With this being common knowledge why do we continue to see this type of incident reoccurring on ships carrying thousands of passengers to precarious destinations? We review regulatory and Class requirements with respect to fire safety, Formal Safety Assessment (FSA) as a rule-making instrument of the IMO, accident investigation recommendations involving fire, fire safety technology, and research literature. For each constituent of fire safety control, the paper aims to determine the preferred strategies for accident prevention and their relative cost effectiveness. Subsequently, the cost effectiveness of the current safety approach is established. This review found that fire prevention could be made more cost effective if its scope was broadened beyond the detection of proximate events occurring immediately before ignition. The findings suggest that more cost-effective safety measures can be developed by addressing systemic causes of fire. Removal of the systemic causal factors of fire from the equation, means we can address fire safety prior to the moments before ignition when the point of no return can unwittingly be passed. The paper suggests directions of how this can be achieved.
LanguageEnglish
Article number102859
Number of pages12
JournalFire Safety Journal
Volume108
Early online date12 Aug 2019
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 30 Sep 2019

Fingerprint

machinery
Machinery
safety
Fires
cost effectiveness
Cost effectiveness
ignition
fire prevention
accident investigation
Ignition
hot surfaces
costs
mist
accident prevention
passengers
causes
ships
recommendations
Fog
Costs

Keywords

  • fire
  • machinery space
  • engine room
  • ship
  • marine
  • safety
  • bowtie models

Cite this

@article{e5ecda87871f4396b7b2fa64483fc26b,
title = "Analysis of effectiveness of fire safety in machinery spaces",
abstract = "The primary cause of machinery space fires is cited as the release of flammable oil mist contacting unprotected hot surfaces. With this being common knowledge why do we continue to see this type of incident reoccurring on ships carrying thousands of passengers to precarious destinations? We review regulatory and Class requirements with respect to fire safety, Formal Safety Assessment (FSA) as a rule-making instrument of the IMO, accident investigation recommendations involving fire, fire safety technology, and research literature. For each constituent of fire safety control, the paper aims to determine the preferred strategies for accident prevention and their relative cost effectiveness. Subsequently, the cost effectiveness of the current safety approach is established. This review found that fire prevention could be made more cost effective if its scope was broadened beyond the detection of proximate events occurring immediately before ignition. The findings suggest that more cost-effective safety measures can be developed by addressing systemic causes of fire. Removal of the systemic causal factors of fire from the equation, means we can address fire safety prior to the moments before ignition when the point of no return can unwittingly be passed. The paper suggests directions of how this can be achieved.",
keywords = "fire, machinery space, engine room, ship, marine, safety, bowtie models",
author = "James McNay and Romanas Puisa and Dracos Vassalos",
year = "2019",
month = "9",
day = "30",
doi = "10.1016/j.firesaf.2019.102859",
language = "English",
volume = "108",
journal = "Fire Safety Journal",
issn = "0379-7112",

}

Analysis of effectiveness of fire safety in machinery spaces. / McNay, James; Puisa, Romanas; Vassalos, Dracos.

In: Fire Safety Journal , Vol. 108, 102859, 30.09.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Analysis of effectiveness of fire safety in machinery spaces

AU - McNay, James

AU - Puisa, Romanas

AU - Vassalos, Dracos

PY - 2019/9/30

Y1 - 2019/9/30

N2 - The primary cause of machinery space fires is cited as the release of flammable oil mist contacting unprotected hot surfaces. With this being common knowledge why do we continue to see this type of incident reoccurring on ships carrying thousands of passengers to precarious destinations? We review regulatory and Class requirements with respect to fire safety, Formal Safety Assessment (FSA) as a rule-making instrument of the IMO, accident investigation recommendations involving fire, fire safety technology, and research literature. For each constituent of fire safety control, the paper aims to determine the preferred strategies for accident prevention and their relative cost effectiveness. Subsequently, the cost effectiveness of the current safety approach is established. This review found that fire prevention could be made more cost effective if its scope was broadened beyond the detection of proximate events occurring immediately before ignition. The findings suggest that more cost-effective safety measures can be developed by addressing systemic causes of fire. Removal of the systemic causal factors of fire from the equation, means we can address fire safety prior to the moments before ignition when the point of no return can unwittingly be passed. The paper suggests directions of how this can be achieved.

AB - The primary cause of machinery space fires is cited as the release of flammable oil mist contacting unprotected hot surfaces. With this being common knowledge why do we continue to see this type of incident reoccurring on ships carrying thousands of passengers to precarious destinations? We review regulatory and Class requirements with respect to fire safety, Formal Safety Assessment (FSA) as a rule-making instrument of the IMO, accident investigation recommendations involving fire, fire safety technology, and research literature. For each constituent of fire safety control, the paper aims to determine the preferred strategies for accident prevention and their relative cost effectiveness. Subsequently, the cost effectiveness of the current safety approach is established. This review found that fire prevention could be made more cost effective if its scope was broadened beyond the detection of proximate events occurring immediately before ignition. The findings suggest that more cost-effective safety measures can be developed by addressing systemic causes of fire. Removal of the systemic causal factors of fire from the equation, means we can address fire safety prior to the moments before ignition when the point of no return can unwittingly be passed. The paper suggests directions of how this can be achieved.

KW - fire

KW - machinery space

KW - engine room

KW - ship

KW - marine

KW - safety

KW - bowtie models

U2 - 10.1016/j.firesaf.2019.102859

DO - 10.1016/j.firesaf.2019.102859

M3 - Article

VL - 108

JO - Fire Safety Journal

T2 - Fire Safety Journal

JF - Fire Safety Journal

SN - 0379-7112

M1 - 102859

ER -