An unintended experiment in fisheries science: a marine area protected by war results in Mexican waves in fish numbers-at-age

D.J. Beare, F. Holker, GH Engelhard, E. McKenzie, D. Reid

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

14 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Marine protected areas (MPAs) are attaining increasing importance in the management of marine ecosystems. They are effective for conservation in tropical and subtropical areas (mainly coral and rocky reefs), but it is debated whether they are useful in the management of migratory fish stocks in open temperate regions. World War II created a large marine area within which commercial fishing was prevented for 6 years. Here we analyse scientific trawl data for three important North Sea gadoids, collected between 1928 and 1958. Using statistical models to summarise the data, we demonstrate the potential of MPAs for expediting the recovery of over-exploited fisheries in open temperate regions. Our age-structured data and population models suggest that wild fish stocks will respond rapidly and positively to reductions in harvesting rates and that the numbers of older fish in a population will react before, and in much greater proportion, than their younger counterparts in a kind of Mexican wave. Our analyses demonstrate both the overall increase in survival due to the lack of harvesting in the War and the form of the age-dependent wave in numbers. We conclude that large closed areas can be very useful in the conservation of migratory species from temperate areas and that older fish benefit fastest and in greater proportion. Importantly, any rise in spawning stock biomass may also not immediately result in better recruitment, which can respond more slowly and hence take longer to contribute to higher future harvestable biomass levels.
LanguageEnglish
Pages797-808
Number of pages11
JournalNaturwissenschaften
Volume97
Issue number9
Publication statusPublished - 2010

Fingerprint

fishery science
marine science
protected area
conservation areas
fisheries
fish
migratory species
experiment
wild fish
biomass
statistical models
marine ecosystem
North Sea
corals
reefs
coral
fishing
spawning
reef
fishery

Keywords

  • Marine protected areas - North Sea - World War II - Age-structured population - Gadoids - Exploitation - Mortality

Cite this

@article{e8a633ec0c424e21aaaa7599db67c791,
title = "An unintended experiment in fisheries science: a marine area protected by war results in Mexican waves in fish numbers-at-age",
abstract = "Marine protected areas (MPAs) are attaining increasing importance in the management of marine ecosystems. They are effective for conservation in tropical and subtropical areas (mainly coral and rocky reefs), but it is debated whether they are useful in the management of migratory fish stocks in open temperate regions. World War II created a large marine area within which commercial fishing was prevented for 6 years. Here we analyse scientific trawl data for three important North Sea gadoids, collected between 1928 and 1958. Using statistical models to summarise the data, we demonstrate the potential of MPAs for expediting the recovery of over-exploited fisheries in open temperate regions. Our age-structured data and population models suggest that wild fish stocks will respond rapidly and positively to reductions in harvesting rates and that the numbers of older fish in a population will react before, and in much greater proportion, than their younger counterparts in a kind of Mexican wave. Our analyses demonstrate both the overall increase in survival due to the lack of harvesting in the War and the form of the age-dependent wave in numbers. We conclude that large closed areas can be very useful in the conservation of migratory species from temperate areas and that older fish benefit fastest and in greater proportion. Importantly, any rise in spawning stock biomass may also not immediately result in better recruitment, which can respond more slowly and hence take longer to contribute to higher future harvestable biomass levels.",
keywords = "Marine protected areas - North Sea - World War II - Age-structured population - Gadoids - Exploitation - Mortality",
author = "D.J. Beare and F. Holker and GH Engelhard and E. McKenzie and D. Reid",
year = "2010",
language = "English",
volume = "97",
pages = "797--808",
journal = "Naturwissenschaften",
issn = "0028-1042",
number = "9",

}

An unintended experiment in fisheries science: a marine area protected by war results in Mexican waves in fish numbers-at-age. / Beare, D.J.; Holker, F.; Engelhard, GH; McKenzie, E.; Reid, D.

In: Naturwissenschaften, Vol. 97, No. 9, 2010, p. 797-808.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - An unintended experiment in fisheries science: a marine area protected by war results in Mexican waves in fish numbers-at-age

AU - Beare, D.J.

AU - Holker, F.

AU - Engelhard, GH

AU - McKenzie, E.

AU - Reid, D.

PY - 2010

Y1 - 2010

N2 - Marine protected areas (MPAs) are attaining increasing importance in the management of marine ecosystems. They are effective for conservation in tropical and subtropical areas (mainly coral and rocky reefs), but it is debated whether they are useful in the management of migratory fish stocks in open temperate regions. World War II created a large marine area within which commercial fishing was prevented for 6 years. Here we analyse scientific trawl data for three important North Sea gadoids, collected between 1928 and 1958. Using statistical models to summarise the data, we demonstrate the potential of MPAs for expediting the recovery of over-exploited fisheries in open temperate regions. Our age-structured data and population models suggest that wild fish stocks will respond rapidly and positively to reductions in harvesting rates and that the numbers of older fish in a population will react before, and in much greater proportion, than their younger counterparts in a kind of Mexican wave. Our analyses demonstrate both the overall increase in survival due to the lack of harvesting in the War and the form of the age-dependent wave in numbers. We conclude that large closed areas can be very useful in the conservation of migratory species from temperate areas and that older fish benefit fastest and in greater proportion. Importantly, any rise in spawning stock biomass may also not immediately result in better recruitment, which can respond more slowly and hence take longer to contribute to higher future harvestable biomass levels.

AB - Marine protected areas (MPAs) are attaining increasing importance in the management of marine ecosystems. They are effective for conservation in tropical and subtropical areas (mainly coral and rocky reefs), but it is debated whether they are useful in the management of migratory fish stocks in open temperate regions. World War II created a large marine area within which commercial fishing was prevented for 6 years. Here we analyse scientific trawl data for three important North Sea gadoids, collected between 1928 and 1958. Using statistical models to summarise the data, we demonstrate the potential of MPAs for expediting the recovery of over-exploited fisheries in open temperate regions. Our age-structured data and population models suggest that wild fish stocks will respond rapidly and positively to reductions in harvesting rates and that the numbers of older fish in a population will react before, and in much greater proportion, than their younger counterparts in a kind of Mexican wave. Our analyses demonstrate both the overall increase in survival due to the lack of harvesting in the War and the form of the age-dependent wave in numbers. We conclude that large closed areas can be very useful in the conservation of migratory species from temperate areas and that older fish benefit fastest and in greater proportion. Importantly, any rise in spawning stock biomass may also not immediately result in better recruitment, which can respond more slowly and hence take longer to contribute to higher future harvestable biomass levels.

KW - Marine protected areas - North Sea - World War II - Age-structured population - Gadoids - Exploitation - Mortality

UR - http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/s00114-010-0696-5

M3 - Article

VL - 97

SP - 797

EP - 808

JO - Naturwissenschaften

T2 - Naturwissenschaften

JF - Naturwissenschaften

SN - 0028-1042

IS - 9

ER -