Aligning process questions, perspectives, and explanations

Andrew Van de Ven, Harry Sminia

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

    6 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    This essay describes different kinds of research questions, process perspectives, and types of explanations to argue pragmatically that the quality and coherence of process research will be enhanced when these ingredients of process research are aligned. A distinction is made between questions about process past (what has happened?), process present (what is going on?), process future (where are we going?), and process action (what should we do?); which are then associated respectively with the historical reconstruction, becoming/ emergent, unfolding, and developing/control process perspectives. Each of these research questions requires a specific and distinct type of explanation, in terms of a unique sequence of events, a key event, a generalizable pattern of events, or a social mechanism. A hierarchy of logical relationships between questions and explanations is discussed, leading to implications for management research as well as manage- ment practice.
    LanguageEnglish
    Title of host publicationConstructing identity in and around organizations
    EditorsMajken Schultz, Steve Maguire, Ann Langley, Haridimos Tsoukas
    Place of PublicationOxford
    Pages306-319
    Number of pages14
    Publication statusPublished - 19 Jan 2012

    Publication series

    NamePerspectives on Process Organization Studies
    PublisherOxford University Press
    Volume2

    Fingerprint

    research process
    key event
    event
    control process
    management
    reconstruction
    present
    coherence

    Keywords

    • process questions
    • perspectives
    • explanations

    Cite this

    Van de Ven, A., & Sminia, H. (2012). Aligning process questions, perspectives, and explanations. In M. Schultz, S. Maguire, A. Langley, & H. Tsoukas (Eds.), Constructing identity in and around organizations (pp. 306-319). (Perspectives on Process Organization Studies; Vol. 2). Oxford.
    Van de Ven, Andrew ; Sminia, Harry. / Aligning process questions, perspectives, and explanations. Constructing identity in and around organizations. editor / Majken Schultz ; Steve Maguire ; Ann Langley ; Haridimos Tsoukas. Oxford, 2012. pp. 306-319 (Perspectives on Process Organization Studies).
    @inbook{9447b573bb5e43fca0600bda66d684be,
    title = "Aligning process questions, perspectives, and explanations",
    abstract = "This essay describes different kinds of research questions, process perspectives, and types of explanations to argue pragmatically that the quality and coherence of process research will be enhanced when these ingredients of process research are aligned. A distinction is made between questions about process past (what has happened?), process present (what is going on?), process future (where are we going?), and process action (what should we do?); which are then associated respectively with the historical reconstruction, becoming/ emergent, unfolding, and developing/control process perspectives. Each of these research questions requires a specific and distinct type of explanation, in terms of a unique sequence of events, a key event, a generalizable pattern of events, or a social mechanism. A hierarchy of logical relationships between questions and explanations is discussed, leading to implications for management research as well as manage- ment practice.",
    keywords = "process questions, perspectives, explanations",
    author = "{Van de Ven}, Andrew and Harry Sminia",
    year = "2012",
    month = "1",
    day = "19",
    language = "English",
    isbn = "9780199640997",
    series = "Perspectives on Process Organization Studies",
    publisher = "Oxford University Press",
    pages = "306--319",
    editor = "Majken Schultz and Steve Maguire and Ann Langley and Haridimos Tsoukas",
    booktitle = "Constructing identity in and around organizations",

    }

    Van de Ven, A & Sminia, H 2012, Aligning process questions, perspectives, and explanations. in M Schultz, S Maguire, A Langley & H Tsoukas (eds), Constructing identity in and around organizations. Perspectives on Process Organization Studies, vol. 2, Oxford, pp. 306-319.

    Aligning process questions, perspectives, and explanations. / Van de Ven, Andrew; Sminia, Harry.

    Constructing identity in and around organizations. ed. / Majken Schultz; Steve Maguire; Ann Langley; Haridimos Tsoukas. Oxford, 2012. p. 306-319 (Perspectives on Process Organization Studies; Vol. 2).

    Research output: Chapter in Book/Report/Conference proceedingChapter

    TY - CHAP

    T1 - Aligning process questions, perspectives, and explanations

    AU - Van de Ven, Andrew

    AU - Sminia, Harry

    PY - 2012/1/19

    Y1 - 2012/1/19

    N2 - This essay describes different kinds of research questions, process perspectives, and types of explanations to argue pragmatically that the quality and coherence of process research will be enhanced when these ingredients of process research are aligned. A distinction is made between questions about process past (what has happened?), process present (what is going on?), process future (where are we going?), and process action (what should we do?); which are then associated respectively with the historical reconstruction, becoming/ emergent, unfolding, and developing/control process perspectives. Each of these research questions requires a specific and distinct type of explanation, in terms of a unique sequence of events, a key event, a generalizable pattern of events, or a social mechanism. A hierarchy of logical relationships between questions and explanations is discussed, leading to implications for management research as well as manage- ment practice.

    AB - This essay describes different kinds of research questions, process perspectives, and types of explanations to argue pragmatically that the quality and coherence of process research will be enhanced when these ingredients of process research are aligned. A distinction is made between questions about process past (what has happened?), process present (what is going on?), process future (where are we going?), and process action (what should we do?); which are then associated respectively with the historical reconstruction, becoming/ emergent, unfolding, and developing/control process perspectives. Each of these research questions requires a specific and distinct type of explanation, in terms of a unique sequence of events, a key event, a generalizable pattern of events, or a social mechanism. A hierarchy of logical relationships between questions and explanations is discussed, leading to implications for management research as well as manage- ment practice.

    KW - process questions

    KW - perspectives

    KW - explanations

    UR - http://ukcatalogue.oup.com/product/9780199640997.do#.UacfmNKR-So

    M3 - Chapter

    SN - 9780199640997

    T3 - Perspectives on Process Organization Studies

    SP - 306

    EP - 319

    BT - Constructing identity in and around organizations

    A2 - Schultz, Majken

    A2 - Maguire, Steve

    A2 - Langley, Ann

    A2 - Tsoukas, Haridimos

    CY - Oxford

    ER -

    Van de Ven A, Sminia H. Aligning process questions, perspectives, and explanations. In Schultz M, Maguire S, Langley A, Tsoukas H, editors, Constructing identity in and around organizations. Oxford. 2012. p. 306-319. (Perspectives on Process Organization Studies).