AI to support decision making in collision risk assessment

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

This paper introduces an Artificial Intelligence(AI)-based system to support operators to manage the risk of collisions. The system implements an Artificial Neural Network (ANN) based technique to predict the risk of collision between two space objects, where one of the two is an operational satellite and the other one is a piece of space debris. The ANN-based technique provides a prediction of the Probability of Collision (PC), MOID and B-parameter between a primary satellite and a set of space debris objects during an interval of time starting from a database including the initial states synthetic space objects. Results of the system over a database of synthetic objects not previously seen during training show the good accuracy predicting the evolution of the aforementioned variables.
The achieved results suggest that the proposed system can be able to implement in collision assessment as a method to identify - quickly, accurately and automatically - possible conjunctions between space objects in an interval of time with no use of dynamic models or orbit propagators. A revised calculation of the PC is also proposed to mitigate the Dilution of Probability that affects the usual definition of this quantity. This phenomenon gives the counterintuitive idea that the lower the quality of the data (or amount of information available to the operators), the smaller the probability of collision, which can lead to a false confidence in the likelihood of a collision or forces operators to accept very large margins. The method presented here will account for epistemic uncertainty under the assumption of Dempster-Shaffer’s Theory of Evidence which leads to the definition of confidence intervals on the probability of a collision. Confidence intervals incorporate the dependency of the probability of collision on the amount and quality of the available information, using the concepts of Belief and Plausibility introduced in Theory of Evidence. The result of this revised calculation of the PC is a more informed decision. At the same time, a lack of information can lead to a higher uncertainty on the decision to be made. Thus the paper will propose a possible approach to make optimal decisions under epistemic uncertainty where the cost of the decision is the risk associated with the decision are concurrently taken into account.
Original languageEnglish
Number of pages17
Publication statusPublished - 24 Oct 2019
Event70th International Astronautical Congress - Washington D.C., United States
Duration: 21 Oct 201925 Oct 2019
https://www.iac2019.org/

Conference

Conference70th International Astronautical Congress
Abbreviated titleIAC
CountryUnited States
CityWashington D.C.
Period21/10/1925/10/19
Internet address

Fingerprint

Risk assessment
Artificial intelligence
Decision making
Space debris
Mathematical operators
Satellites
Neural networks
Dilution
Dynamic models
Orbits
Uncertainty
Costs

Keywords

  • Artificial Neural Network
  • space traffic management
  • probability of collision
  • evidence theory
  • astronautics

Cite this

Sánchez, L., Vasile, M., & Minisci, E. (2019). AI to support decision making in collision risk assessment. Paper presented at 70th International Astronautical Congress, Washington D.C., United States.
Sánchez, Luis ; Vasile, Massimiliano ; Minisci, Edmondo. / AI to support decision making in collision risk assessment. Paper presented at 70th International Astronautical Congress, Washington D.C., United States.17 p.
@conference{dffd8c2b90874fa09443e9b31f9a6842,
title = "AI to support decision making in collision risk assessment",
abstract = "This paper introduces an Artificial Intelligence(AI)-based system to support operators to manage the risk of collisions. The system implements an Artificial Neural Network (ANN) based technique to predict the risk of collision between two space objects, where one of the two is an operational satellite and the other one is a piece of space debris. The ANN-based technique provides a prediction of the Probability of Collision (PC), MOID and B-parameter between a primary satellite and a set of space debris objects during an interval of time starting from a database including the initial states synthetic space objects. Results of the system over a database of synthetic objects not previously seen during training show the good accuracy predicting the evolution of the aforementioned variables.The achieved results suggest that the proposed system can be able to implement in collision assessment as a method to identify - quickly, accurately and automatically - possible conjunctions between space objects in an interval of time with no use of dynamic models or orbit propagators. A revised calculation of the PC is also proposed to mitigate the Dilution of Probability that affects the usual definition of this quantity. This phenomenon gives the counterintuitive idea that the lower the quality of the data (or amount of information available to the operators), the smaller the probability of collision, which can lead to a false confidence in the likelihood of a collision or forces operators to accept very large margins. The method presented here will account for epistemic uncertainty under the assumption of Dempster-Shaffer’s Theory of Evidence which leads to the definition of confidence intervals on the probability of a collision. Confidence intervals incorporate the dependency of the probability of collision on the amount and quality of the available information, using the concepts of Belief and Plausibility introduced in Theory of Evidence. The result of this revised calculation of the PC is a more informed decision. At the same time, a lack of information can lead to a higher uncertainty on the decision to be made. Thus the paper will propose a possible approach to make optimal decisions under epistemic uncertainty where the cost of the decision is the risk associated with the decision are concurrently taken into account.",
keywords = "Artificial Neural Network, space traffic management, probability of collision, evidence theory, astronautics",
author = "Luis S{\'a}nchez and Massimiliano Vasile and Edmondo Minisci",
year = "2019",
month = "10",
day = "24",
language = "English",
note = "70th International Astronautical Congress, IAC ; Conference date: 21-10-2019 Through 25-10-2019",
url = "https://www.iac2019.org/",

}

Sánchez, L, Vasile, M & Minisci, E 2019, 'AI to support decision making in collision risk assessment' Paper presented at 70th International Astronautical Congress, Washington D.C., United States, 21/10/19 - 25/10/19, .

AI to support decision making in collision risk assessment. / Sánchez, Luis; Vasile, Massimiliano; Minisci, Edmondo.

2019. Paper presented at 70th International Astronautical Congress, Washington D.C., United States.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - AI to support decision making in collision risk assessment

AU - Sánchez, Luis

AU - Vasile, Massimiliano

AU - Minisci, Edmondo

PY - 2019/10/24

Y1 - 2019/10/24

N2 - This paper introduces an Artificial Intelligence(AI)-based system to support operators to manage the risk of collisions. The system implements an Artificial Neural Network (ANN) based technique to predict the risk of collision between two space objects, where one of the two is an operational satellite and the other one is a piece of space debris. The ANN-based technique provides a prediction of the Probability of Collision (PC), MOID and B-parameter between a primary satellite and a set of space debris objects during an interval of time starting from a database including the initial states synthetic space objects. Results of the system over a database of synthetic objects not previously seen during training show the good accuracy predicting the evolution of the aforementioned variables.The achieved results suggest that the proposed system can be able to implement in collision assessment as a method to identify - quickly, accurately and automatically - possible conjunctions between space objects in an interval of time with no use of dynamic models or orbit propagators. A revised calculation of the PC is also proposed to mitigate the Dilution of Probability that affects the usual definition of this quantity. This phenomenon gives the counterintuitive idea that the lower the quality of the data (or amount of information available to the operators), the smaller the probability of collision, which can lead to a false confidence in the likelihood of a collision or forces operators to accept very large margins. The method presented here will account for epistemic uncertainty under the assumption of Dempster-Shaffer’s Theory of Evidence which leads to the definition of confidence intervals on the probability of a collision. Confidence intervals incorporate the dependency of the probability of collision on the amount and quality of the available information, using the concepts of Belief and Plausibility introduced in Theory of Evidence. The result of this revised calculation of the PC is a more informed decision. At the same time, a lack of information can lead to a higher uncertainty on the decision to be made. Thus the paper will propose a possible approach to make optimal decisions under epistemic uncertainty where the cost of the decision is the risk associated with the decision are concurrently taken into account.

AB - This paper introduces an Artificial Intelligence(AI)-based system to support operators to manage the risk of collisions. The system implements an Artificial Neural Network (ANN) based technique to predict the risk of collision between two space objects, where one of the two is an operational satellite and the other one is a piece of space debris. The ANN-based technique provides a prediction of the Probability of Collision (PC), MOID and B-parameter between a primary satellite and a set of space debris objects during an interval of time starting from a database including the initial states synthetic space objects. Results of the system over a database of synthetic objects not previously seen during training show the good accuracy predicting the evolution of the aforementioned variables.The achieved results suggest that the proposed system can be able to implement in collision assessment as a method to identify - quickly, accurately and automatically - possible conjunctions between space objects in an interval of time with no use of dynamic models or orbit propagators. A revised calculation of the PC is also proposed to mitigate the Dilution of Probability that affects the usual definition of this quantity. This phenomenon gives the counterintuitive idea that the lower the quality of the data (or amount of information available to the operators), the smaller the probability of collision, which can lead to a false confidence in the likelihood of a collision or forces operators to accept very large margins. The method presented here will account for epistemic uncertainty under the assumption of Dempster-Shaffer’s Theory of Evidence which leads to the definition of confidence intervals on the probability of a collision. Confidence intervals incorporate the dependency of the probability of collision on the amount and quality of the available information, using the concepts of Belief and Plausibility introduced in Theory of Evidence. The result of this revised calculation of the PC is a more informed decision. At the same time, a lack of information can lead to a higher uncertainty on the decision to be made. Thus the paper will propose a possible approach to make optimal decisions under epistemic uncertainty where the cost of the decision is the risk associated with the decision are concurrently taken into account.

KW - Artificial Neural Network

KW - space traffic management

KW - probability of collision

KW - evidence theory

KW - astronautics

M3 - Paper

ER -

Sánchez L, Vasile M, Minisci E. AI to support decision making in collision risk assessment. 2019. Paper presented at 70th International Astronautical Congress, Washington D.C., United States.