Advancing the science of literature reviewing in social research: the focused mapping review and synthesis

Carolyn Bradbury-Jones, Jenna P. Breckenridge, Maria T. Clarke, Oliver R. Herber, Christine Jones, Julie Taylor

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    1 Citation (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Literature reviews are an important and popular part of synthesising evidence across a range of disciplines. There are numerous approaches, each with their distinctive features and purposes. The aim of this article is to advance the science of literature reviewing by describing a new form of review: The ‘Focused Mapping Review and Synthesis’ (FMRS). We critique the approach and highlight its similarities and differences in relation to existing review methodologies. There are four key features of FMRS. It: 1) focuses on a defined field of knowledge rather than a body of evidence; 2) creates a descriptive map or topography of key features of research within the field rather than a synthesis of findings; 3) comments on the overall approach to knowledge production rather than the state of the evidence; 4) examines this within a broader epistemological context. The FMRS can be used to answer questions that might not be appropriate for other review types and potentially offers a useful addition to the methodological toolkit of social researchers from multiple disciplines.
    LanguageEnglish
    Pages451-462
    Number of pages12
    JournalInternational Journal of Social Research Methodology
    Volume22
    Issue number5
    Early online date18 Feb 2019
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 3 Sep 2019

    Fingerprint

    social research
    science
    evidence
    knowledge production
    geography
    methodology
    literature

    Keywords

    • evidence
    • literature review
    • synthesis
    • scientific inquiry
    • knowledge synthesis
    • methodology
    • social research
    • focused mapping review

    Cite this

    Bradbury-Jones, Carolyn ; Breckenridge, Jenna P. ; Clarke, Maria T. ; Herber, Oliver R. ; Jones, Christine ; Taylor, Julie. / Advancing the science of literature reviewing in social research : the focused mapping review and synthesis. In: International Journal of Social Research Methodology. 2019 ; Vol. 22, No. 5. pp. 451-462.
    @article{311e31cb186b486e990faed5fac27856,
    title = "Advancing the science of literature reviewing in social research: the focused mapping review and synthesis",
    abstract = "Literature reviews are an important and popular part of synthesising evidence across a range of disciplines. There are numerous approaches, each with their distinctive features and purposes. The aim of this article is to advance the science of literature reviewing by describing a new form of review: The ‘Focused Mapping Review and Synthesis’ (FMRS). We critique the approach and highlight its similarities and differences in relation to existing review methodologies. There are four key features of FMRS. It: 1) focuses on a defined field of knowledge rather than a body of evidence; 2) creates a descriptive map or topography of key features of research within the field rather than a synthesis of findings; 3) comments on the overall approach to knowledge production rather than the state of the evidence; 4) examines this within a broader epistemological context. The FMRS can be used to answer questions that might not be appropriate for other review types and potentially offers a useful addition to the methodological toolkit of social researchers from multiple disciplines.",
    keywords = "evidence, literature review, synthesis, scientific inquiry, knowledge synthesis, methodology, social research, focused mapping review",
    author = "Carolyn Bradbury-Jones and Breckenridge, {Jenna P.} and Clarke, {Maria T.} and Herber, {Oliver R.} and Christine Jones and Julie Taylor",
    year = "2019",
    month = "9",
    day = "3",
    doi = "10.1080/13645579.2019.1576328",
    language = "English",
    volume = "22",
    pages = "451--462",
    journal = "International Journal of Social Research Methodology",
    issn = "1364-5579",
    number = "5",

    }

    Advancing the science of literature reviewing in social research : the focused mapping review and synthesis. / Bradbury-Jones, Carolyn; Breckenridge, Jenna P.; Clarke, Maria T.; Herber, Oliver R.; Jones, Christine; Taylor, Julie.

    In: International Journal of Social Research Methodology, Vol. 22, No. 5, 03.09.2019, p. 451-462.

    Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Advancing the science of literature reviewing in social research

    T2 - International Journal of Social Research Methodology

    AU - Bradbury-Jones, Carolyn

    AU - Breckenridge, Jenna P.

    AU - Clarke, Maria T.

    AU - Herber, Oliver R.

    AU - Jones, Christine

    AU - Taylor, Julie

    PY - 2019/9/3

    Y1 - 2019/9/3

    N2 - Literature reviews are an important and popular part of synthesising evidence across a range of disciplines. There are numerous approaches, each with their distinctive features and purposes. The aim of this article is to advance the science of literature reviewing by describing a new form of review: The ‘Focused Mapping Review and Synthesis’ (FMRS). We critique the approach and highlight its similarities and differences in relation to existing review methodologies. There are four key features of FMRS. It: 1) focuses on a defined field of knowledge rather than a body of evidence; 2) creates a descriptive map or topography of key features of research within the field rather than a synthesis of findings; 3) comments on the overall approach to knowledge production rather than the state of the evidence; 4) examines this within a broader epistemological context. The FMRS can be used to answer questions that might not be appropriate for other review types and potentially offers a useful addition to the methodological toolkit of social researchers from multiple disciplines.

    AB - Literature reviews are an important and popular part of synthesising evidence across a range of disciplines. There are numerous approaches, each with their distinctive features and purposes. The aim of this article is to advance the science of literature reviewing by describing a new form of review: The ‘Focused Mapping Review and Synthesis’ (FMRS). We critique the approach and highlight its similarities and differences in relation to existing review methodologies. There are four key features of FMRS. It: 1) focuses on a defined field of knowledge rather than a body of evidence; 2) creates a descriptive map or topography of key features of research within the field rather than a synthesis of findings; 3) comments on the overall approach to knowledge production rather than the state of the evidence; 4) examines this within a broader epistemological context. The FMRS can be used to answer questions that might not be appropriate for other review types and potentially offers a useful addition to the methodological toolkit of social researchers from multiple disciplines.

    KW - evidence

    KW - literature review

    KW - synthesis

    KW - scientific inquiry

    KW - knowledge synthesis

    KW - methodology

    KW - social research

    KW - focused mapping review

    UR - https://www.tandfonline.com/toc/tsrm20/current

    U2 - 10.1080/13645579.2019.1576328

    DO - 10.1080/13645579.2019.1576328

    M3 - Article

    VL - 22

    SP - 451

    EP - 462

    JO - International Journal of Social Research Methodology

    JF - International Journal of Social Research Methodology

    SN - 1364-5579

    IS - 5

    ER -