Adler's theory of the capitalist labour process: a pale(o) imitation

P. Thompson

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Adler's paper raises a host of pertinent theoretical and empirical challenges for anyone interested in contemporary trends in work and organization. A version of 'paleo' Marxism is invoked to correct the supposed anomalies of labour process theory and the limits of critical management studies. The theory relies on a notion of the progressive socialization of the productive forces in order to assert a positive conception of Taylorism and lean production, as well as a long-run upskilling trajectory. It is argued in this commentary that it is flawed theory and skewed empirics. Adler's perspectives result in a de-politicized workplace by removing any source of conflict over work relations between capital and labour. His evidence of skill upgrading relies overwhelmingly on a series of unreliable proxies that do not deal with actual work relations. In contrast, the commentary defends the record of labour process theory on issues of skill formation and the workplace as a contested terrain.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1359-1368
Number of pages9
JournalOrganization Studies
Volume28
Issue number9
Publication statusPublished - Sep 2007

Fingerprint

Personnel
Trajectories
Work place
Work relations
Imitation
Labour process
Labour process theory
Conception
Labor
Lean production
Taylorism
Anomaly
Socialization
Skill upgrading
Empirics
Trajectory
Skill formation
Critical management studies
Marxism

Keywords

  • labour process theory
  • skill formation
  • politics of production
  • Marxism
  • capitalism

Cite this

Thompson, P. / Adler's theory of the capitalist labour process: a pale(o) imitation. In: Organization Studies. 2007 ; Vol. 28, No. 9. pp. 1359-1368.
@article{3f2c2405bb874919a90c1b394450aac8,
title = "Adler's theory of the capitalist labour process: a pale(o) imitation",
abstract = "Adler's paper raises a host of pertinent theoretical and empirical challenges for anyone interested in contemporary trends in work and organization. A version of 'paleo' Marxism is invoked to correct the supposed anomalies of labour process theory and the limits of critical management studies. The theory relies on a notion of the progressive socialization of the productive forces in order to assert a positive conception of Taylorism and lean production, as well as a long-run upskilling trajectory. It is argued in this commentary that it is flawed theory and skewed empirics. Adler's perspectives result in a de-politicized workplace by removing any source of conflict over work relations between capital and labour. His evidence of skill upgrading relies overwhelmingly on a series of unreliable proxies that do not deal with actual work relations. In contrast, the commentary defends the record of labour process theory on issues of skill formation and the workplace as a contested terrain.",
keywords = "labour process theory, skill formation, politics of production, Marxism, capitalism",
author = "P. Thompson",
year = "2007",
month = "9",
language = "English",
volume = "28",
pages = "1359--1368",
journal = "Organization Studies",
issn = "0170-8406",
number = "9",

}

Adler's theory of the capitalist labour process: a pale(o) imitation. / Thompson, P.

In: Organization Studies, Vol. 28, No. 9, 09.2007, p. 1359-1368.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - Adler's theory of the capitalist labour process: a pale(o) imitation

AU - Thompson, P.

PY - 2007/9

Y1 - 2007/9

N2 - Adler's paper raises a host of pertinent theoretical and empirical challenges for anyone interested in contemporary trends in work and organization. A version of 'paleo' Marxism is invoked to correct the supposed anomalies of labour process theory and the limits of critical management studies. The theory relies on a notion of the progressive socialization of the productive forces in order to assert a positive conception of Taylorism and lean production, as well as a long-run upskilling trajectory. It is argued in this commentary that it is flawed theory and skewed empirics. Adler's perspectives result in a de-politicized workplace by removing any source of conflict over work relations between capital and labour. His evidence of skill upgrading relies overwhelmingly on a series of unreliable proxies that do not deal with actual work relations. In contrast, the commentary defends the record of labour process theory on issues of skill formation and the workplace as a contested terrain.

AB - Adler's paper raises a host of pertinent theoretical and empirical challenges for anyone interested in contemporary trends in work and organization. A version of 'paleo' Marxism is invoked to correct the supposed anomalies of labour process theory and the limits of critical management studies. The theory relies on a notion of the progressive socialization of the productive forces in order to assert a positive conception of Taylorism and lean production, as well as a long-run upskilling trajectory. It is argued in this commentary that it is flawed theory and skewed empirics. Adler's perspectives result in a de-politicized workplace by removing any source of conflict over work relations between capital and labour. His evidence of skill upgrading relies overwhelmingly on a series of unreliable proxies that do not deal with actual work relations. In contrast, the commentary defends the record of labour process theory on issues of skill formation and the workplace as a contested terrain.

KW - labour process theory

KW - skill formation

KW - politics of production

KW - Marxism

KW - capitalism

UR - http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/0170840607080745

M3 - Article

VL - 28

SP - 1359

EP - 1368

JO - Organization Studies

JF - Organization Studies

SN - 0170-8406

IS - 9

ER -