A service, a ‘way of working’, or a profession? A discourse analysis of community education/community learning and development in Scotland

Gordon Mackie, Howard Sercombe, Anne Ryan

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Community based informal education, like other practices, is fundamentally shaped by the discourses under which it is constituted. In Scotland, since 1975, the practice has been formally established by government policy as an amalgam of youth work, adult education and community development under a discourse of informal education. This combination carries its own internal tensions alongside the continually contested relationship between the field of practice and the State. This study analyses key documents in order to chart the shifts in discourse around the constitution of Community Education/Community Learning and Development (CE/CLD) since 1975. The analysis reveals the force of managerialist discourses which transformed understandings of the practice from post war welfare state discourses as a Service, to its reshaping as technique under New Labour. Current discursive work is directed to its reconstitution (still somewhat ambivalently) as a profession. This ‘re-professionalisation’ connects with similar movements in medicine, social work, parole and teaching which are attempting to reduce the costs of actuarial disciplinary techniques (in record-keeping, reporting, and the generation of outcome data) by returning professional trust and judgment to practitioners. There are wider indications of what might be called an ‘ethical turn’ from the market-driven and outcomes-focused ethos of managerialism, of which the phone tapping scandal at the News of the World may be the most public and dramatic instance.
LanguageEnglish
JournalDiscourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education
Volume34
Issue number3
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jun 2013

Fingerprint

discourse analysis
profession
discourse
learning
community
education
youth work
Adult Education
New Labour
scandal
professionalization
community development
welfare state
government policy
indication
constitution
social work
news
medicine
market

Keywords

  • community education
  • community learning
  • discursive work
  • informal education

Cite this

@article{55ddc748d35e4a69afd923501a6496d7,
title = "A service, a ‘way of working’, or a profession? A discourse analysis of community education/community learning and development in Scotland",
abstract = "Community based informal education, like other practices, is fundamentally shaped by the discourses under which it is constituted. In Scotland, since 1975, the practice has been formally established by government policy as an amalgam of youth work, adult education and community development under a discourse of informal education. This combination carries its own internal tensions alongside the continually contested relationship between the field of practice and the State. This study analyses key documents in order to chart the shifts in discourse around the constitution of Community Education/Community Learning and Development (CE/CLD) since 1975. The analysis reveals the force of managerialist discourses which transformed understandings of the practice from post war welfare state discourses as a Service, to its reshaping as technique under New Labour. Current discursive work is directed to its reconstitution (still somewhat ambivalently) as a profession. This ‘re-professionalisation’ connects with similar movements in medicine, social work, parole and teaching which are attempting to reduce the costs of actuarial disciplinary techniques (in record-keeping, reporting, and the generation of outcome data) by returning professional trust and judgment to practitioners. There are wider indications of what might be called an ‘ethical turn’ from the market-driven and outcomes-focused ethos of managerialism, of which the phone tapping scandal at the News of the World may be the most public and dramatic instance.",
keywords = "community education, community learning, discursive work, informal education",
author = "Gordon Mackie and Howard Sercombe and Anne Ryan",
year = "2013",
month = "6",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1080/01596306.2012.717192",
language = "English",
volume = "34",
journal = "Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education",
issn = "0159-6306",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "3",

}

TY - JOUR

T1 - A service, a ‘way of working’, or a profession? A discourse analysis of community education/community learning and development in Scotland

AU - Mackie, Gordon

AU - Sercombe, Howard

AU - Ryan, Anne

PY - 2013/6/1

Y1 - 2013/6/1

N2 - Community based informal education, like other practices, is fundamentally shaped by the discourses under which it is constituted. In Scotland, since 1975, the practice has been formally established by government policy as an amalgam of youth work, adult education and community development under a discourse of informal education. This combination carries its own internal tensions alongside the continually contested relationship between the field of practice and the State. This study analyses key documents in order to chart the shifts in discourse around the constitution of Community Education/Community Learning and Development (CE/CLD) since 1975. The analysis reveals the force of managerialist discourses which transformed understandings of the practice from post war welfare state discourses as a Service, to its reshaping as technique under New Labour. Current discursive work is directed to its reconstitution (still somewhat ambivalently) as a profession. This ‘re-professionalisation’ connects with similar movements in medicine, social work, parole and teaching which are attempting to reduce the costs of actuarial disciplinary techniques (in record-keeping, reporting, and the generation of outcome data) by returning professional trust and judgment to practitioners. There are wider indications of what might be called an ‘ethical turn’ from the market-driven and outcomes-focused ethos of managerialism, of which the phone tapping scandal at the News of the World may be the most public and dramatic instance.

AB - Community based informal education, like other practices, is fundamentally shaped by the discourses under which it is constituted. In Scotland, since 1975, the practice has been formally established by government policy as an amalgam of youth work, adult education and community development under a discourse of informal education. This combination carries its own internal tensions alongside the continually contested relationship between the field of practice and the State. This study analyses key documents in order to chart the shifts in discourse around the constitution of Community Education/Community Learning and Development (CE/CLD) since 1975. The analysis reveals the force of managerialist discourses which transformed understandings of the practice from post war welfare state discourses as a Service, to its reshaping as technique under New Labour. Current discursive work is directed to its reconstitution (still somewhat ambivalently) as a profession. This ‘re-professionalisation’ connects with similar movements in medicine, social work, parole and teaching which are attempting to reduce the costs of actuarial disciplinary techniques (in record-keeping, reporting, and the generation of outcome data) by returning professional trust and judgment to practitioners. There are wider indications of what might be called an ‘ethical turn’ from the market-driven and outcomes-focused ethos of managerialism, of which the phone tapping scandal at the News of the World may be the most public and dramatic instance.

KW - community education

KW - community learning

KW - discursive work

KW - informal education

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=84880608235&partnerID=8YFLogxK

UR - http://www.tandfonline.com/loi/cdis20

U2 - 10.1080/01596306.2012.717192

DO - 10.1080/01596306.2012.717192

M3 - Article

VL - 34

JO - Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education

T2 - Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education

JF - Discourse: Studies in the Cultural Politics of Education

SN - 0159-6306

IS - 3

ER -