A perceptual and electropalatographic study of /sh/ in young people with Down's syndrome

Claire Timmins, Joanne Cleland, Sara Wood, William Hardcastle, Jennifer Wishart

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

Abstract

Speech production in young people with Down’s syndrome has been found to be variable and inconsistent. Errors tend to be more in the production of sounds that typically develop later, for example, fricatives and affricates, rather than stops and nasals. It has been suggested that inconsistency in production is a result of a motor speech deficit. Late acquired fricatives such as /s/ and /sh/ are complex articulations, which may require more precise motor programming and may therefore show highly inconsistent productions. Other factors potentially affecting speech production in this population are abnormal palatal structure, hearing loss, and hypotonia. A group of 20 young people with Down’s syndrome were recorded using Electropalatography (EPG), reading a wordlist containing the phrase ‘a sheep’. The wordlist contained seven other phrases and was repeated 10 times. Eight typically developing, cognitively matched children and eight adults were also recorded producing the same data set. Articulatory (EPG pattern analysis) and perceptual analyses of the 10 productions of /sh/ were carried out. /sh/ production was found to be inconsistent in the young people with Down’s syndrome, with more errors both in the auditory analysis and articulatory analysis than in the typical sample, which may be due to a motor programming or motor control problem. There were a greater number of errors in the EPG analysis than in the perceptual analysis. This suggests that some young people with DS were able to produce perceptually acceptable /sh/ with atypical EPG patterns. The use of typical, adult-modelled /sh/ EPG patterns in therapy may be inappropriate for some children with DS who present with atypical palatal structures.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)911-925
Number of pages15
JournalClinical linguistics & phonetics
Volume23
Issue number12
Publication statusPublished - Dec 2009

Fingerprint

Down Syndrome
Muscle Hypotonia
Hearing Loss
Reading
Sheep
programming
Population
deficit
Therapeutics

Keywords

  • Down's syndrome
  • electropalatography
  • speech production measurement
  • fricative production
  • variability

Cite this

Timmins, Claire ; Cleland, Joanne ; Wood, Sara ; Hardcastle, William ; Wishart, Jennifer . / A perceptual and electropalatographic study of /sh/ in young people with Down's syndrome. In: Clinical linguistics & phonetics. 2009 ; Vol. 23, No. 12. pp. 911-925.
@article{2b4875bcdbae4487b29e5ab6a083a7fc,
title = "A perceptual and electropalatographic study of /sh/ in young people with Down's syndrome",
abstract = "Speech production in young people with Down’s syndrome has been found to be variable and inconsistent. Errors tend to be more in the production of sounds that typically develop later, for example, fricatives and affricates, rather than stops and nasals. It has been suggested that inconsistency in production is a result of a motor speech deficit. Late acquired fricatives such as /s/ and /sh/ are complex articulations, which may require more precise motor programming and may therefore show highly inconsistent productions. Other factors potentially affecting speech production in this population are abnormal palatal structure, hearing loss, and hypotonia. A group of 20 young people with Down’s syndrome were recorded using Electropalatography (EPG), reading a wordlist containing the phrase ‘a sheep’. The wordlist contained seven other phrases and was repeated 10 times. Eight typically developing, cognitively matched children and eight adults were also recorded producing the same data set. Articulatory (EPG pattern analysis) and perceptual analyses of the 10 productions of /sh/ were carried out. /sh/ production was found to be inconsistent in the young people with Down’s syndrome, with more errors both in the auditory analysis and articulatory analysis than in the typical sample, which may be due to a motor programming or motor control problem. There were a greater number of errors in the EPG analysis than in the perceptual analysis. This suggests that some young people with DS were able to produce perceptually acceptable /sh/ with atypical EPG patterns. The use of typical, adult-modelled /sh/ EPG patterns in therapy may be inappropriate for some children with DS who present with atypical palatal structures.",
keywords = "Down's syndrome, electropalatography, speech production measurement, fricative production, variability",
author = "Claire Timmins and Joanne Cleland and Sara Wood and William Hardcastle and Jennifer Wishart",
year = "2009",
month = "12",
language = "English",
volume = "23",
pages = "911--925",
journal = "Clinical linguistics & phonetics",
issn = "0269-9206",
number = "12",

}

A perceptual and electropalatographic study of /sh/ in young people with Down's syndrome. / Timmins, Claire; Cleland, Joanne; Wood, Sara ; Hardcastle, William ; Wishart, Jennifer .

In: Clinical linguistics & phonetics, Vol. 23, No. 12, 12.2009, p. 911-925.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - A perceptual and electropalatographic study of /sh/ in young people with Down's syndrome

AU - Timmins, Claire

AU - Cleland, Joanne

AU - Wood, Sara

AU - Hardcastle, William

AU - Wishart, Jennifer

PY - 2009/12

Y1 - 2009/12

N2 - Speech production in young people with Down’s syndrome has been found to be variable and inconsistent. Errors tend to be more in the production of sounds that typically develop later, for example, fricatives and affricates, rather than stops and nasals. It has been suggested that inconsistency in production is a result of a motor speech deficit. Late acquired fricatives such as /s/ and /sh/ are complex articulations, which may require more precise motor programming and may therefore show highly inconsistent productions. Other factors potentially affecting speech production in this population are abnormal palatal structure, hearing loss, and hypotonia. A group of 20 young people with Down’s syndrome were recorded using Electropalatography (EPG), reading a wordlist containing the phrase ‘a sheep’. The wordlist contained seven other phrases and was repeated 10 times. Eight typically developing, cognitively matched children and eight adults were also recorded producing the same data set. Articulatory (EPG pattern analysis) and perceptual analyses of the 10 productions of /sh/ were carried out. /sh/ production was found to be inconsistent in the young people with Down’s syndrome, with more errors both in the auditory analysis and articulatory analysis than in the typical sample, which may be due to a motor programming or motor control problem. There were a greater number of errors in the EPG analysis than in the perceptual analysis. This suggests that some young people with DS were able to produce perceptually acceptable /sh/ with atypical EPG patterns. The use of typical, adult-modelled /sh/ EPG patterns in therapy may be inappropriate for some children with DS who present with atypical palatal structures.

AB - Speech production in young people with Down’s syndrome has been found to be variable and inconsistent. Errors tend to be more in the production of sounds that typically develop later, for example, fricatives and affricates, rather than stops and nasals. It has been suggested that inconsistency in production is a result of a motor speech deficit. Late acquired fricatives such as /s/ and /sh/ are complex articulations, which may require more precise motor programming and may therefore show highly inconsistent productions. Other factors potentially affecting speech production in this population are abnormal palatal structure, hearing loss, and hypotonia. A group of 20 young people with Down’s syndrome were recorded using Electropalatography (EPG), reading a wordlist containing the phrase ‘a sheep’. The wordlist contained seven other phrases and was repeated 10 times. Eight typically developing, cognitively matched children and eight adults were also recorded producing the same data set. Articulatory (EPG pattern analysis) and perceptual analyses of the 10 productions of /sh/ were carried out. /sh/ production was found to be inconsistent in the young people with Down’s syndrome, with more errors both in the auditory analysis and articulatory analysis than in the typical sample, which may be due to a motor programming or motor control problem. There were a greater number of errors in the EPG analysis than in the perceptual analysis. This suggests that some young people with DS were able to produce perceptually acceptable /sh/ with atypical EPG patterns. The use of typical, adult-modelled /sh/ EPG patterns in therapy may be inappropriate for some children with DS who present with atypical palatal structures.

KW - Down's syndrome

KW - electropalatography

KW - speech production measurement

KW - fricative production

KW - variability

UR - http://informahealthcare.com/doi/abs/10.3109/02699200903141271

M3 - Article

VL - 23

SP - 911

EP - 925

JO - Clinical linguistics & phonetics

JF - Clinical linguistics & phonetics

SN - 0269-9206

IS - 12

ER -