A dirty little secret: taste hierarchies and Richard and Judy’s book club

Anouk Lang

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article

Abstract

This paper locates Richard and Judy’s Book Club within hierarchies of taste in contemporary British society. Analysing the words of both media commentators and readers interviewed in focus groups, it identifies pervasive patterns of suspicion and general disparagement circulating in the discourse about the show’s book club, and explores how and why this stigma is expressed. Using methodologies from corpus linguistics to identify recurring patterns in language usage across a large number of media texts in three different national contexts, it considers the way the book club is discussed in the British press and how this differs from the kinds of discourses employed to talk about comparable nationwide reading events in the US and Canada. The findings include evidence of anxiety that the process of valuing and potentially canonising books is being done by a daytime television programme without the requisite symbolic capital to make decisions about literary matters.
LanguageEnglish
Pages316-340
Number of pages25
JournalParticipations
Volume7
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - Nov 2010

Fingerprint

book club
symbolic capital
language usage
television program
discourse
Canada
anxiety
linguistics
event
methodology
evidence
Group

Keywords

  • Richard and Judy’s Book Club
  • taste hierarchies
  • book clubs
  • television

Cite this

Lang, Anouk. / A dirty little secret : taste hierarchies and Richard and Judy’s book club. In: Participations. 2010 ; Vol. 7, No. 2. pp. 316-340.
@article{9873b7ab7b7a402f833539e72a1f5a63,
title = "A dirty little secret: taste hierarchies and Richard and Judy’s book club",
abstract = "This paper locates Richard and Judy’s Book Club within hierarchies of taste in contemporary British society. Analysing the words of both media commentators and readers interviewed in focus groups, it identifies pervasive patterns of suspicion and general disparagement circulating in the discourse about the show’s book club, and explores how and why this stigma is expressed. Using methodologies from corpus linguistics to identify recurring patterns in language usage across a large number of media texts in three different national contexts, it considers the way the book club is discussed in the British press and how this differs from the kinds of discourses employed to talk about comparable nationwide reading events in the US and Canada. The findings include evidence of anxiety that the process of valuing and potentially canonising books is being done by a daytime television programme without the requisite symbolic capital to make decisions about literary matters.",
keywords = "Richard and Judy’s Book Club, taste hierarchies, book clubs, television",
author = "Anouk Lang",
year = "2010",
month = "11",
language = "English",
volume = "7",
pages = "316--340",
journal = "Participations",
issn = "1749-8716",
number = "2",

}

Lang, A 2010, 'A dirty little secret: taste hierarchies and Richard and Judy’s book club' Participations, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 316-340.

A dirty little secret : taste hierarchies and Richard and Judy’s book club. / Lang, Anouk.

In: Participations, Vol. 7, No. 2, 11.2010, p. 316-340.

Research output: Contribution to journal › Article

TY - JOUR

T1 - A dirty little secret

T2 - Participations

AU - Lang, Anouk

PY - 2010/11

Y1 - 2010/11

N2 - This paper locates Richard and Judy’s Book Club within hierarchies of taste in contemporary British society. Analysing the words of both media commentators and readers interviewed in focus groups, it identifies pervasive patterns of suspicion and general disparagement circulating in the discourse about the show’s book club, and explores how and why this stigma is expressed. Using methodologies from corpus linguistics to identify recurring patterns in language usage across a large number of media texts in three different national contexts, it considers the way the book club is discussed in the British press and how this differs from the kinds of discourses employed to talk about comparable nationwide reading events in the US and Canada. The findings include evidence of anxiety that the process of valuing and potentially canonising books is being done by a daytime television programme without the requisite symbolic capital to make decisions about literary matters.

AB - This paper locates Richard and Judy’s Book Club within hierarchies of taste in contemporary British society. Analysing the words of both media commentators and readers interviewed in focus groups, it identifies pervasive patterns of suspicion and general disparagement circulating in the discourse about the show’s book club, and explores how and why this stigma is expressed. Using methodologies from corpus linguistics to identify recurring patterns in language usage across a large number of media texts in three different national contexts, it considers the way the book club is discussed in the British press and how this differs from the kinds of discourses employed to talk about comparable nationwide reading events in the US and Canada. The findings include evidence of anxiety that the process of valuing and potentially canonising books is being done by a daytime television programme without the requisite symbolic capital to make decisions about literary matters.

KW - Richard and Judy’s Book Club

KW - taste hierarchies

KW - book clubs

KW - television

UR - http://www.participations.org/Volume%207/Issue%202/PDF/lang.pdf

M3 - Article

VL - 7

SP - 316

EP - 340

JO - Participations

JF - Participations

SN - 1749-8716

IS - 2

ER -

Lang A. A dirty little secret: taste hierarchies and Richard and Judy’s book club. Participations. 2010 Nov;7(2):316-340.

Access to Document