A critical account of a 'creeping neo-abolitionism': regulating prostitution in England and Wales

Jane Scoular, Anna Carline

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

23 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

An increasingly dominant neo-abolitionist perspective on the issue of prostitution is currently taking hold across Europe. Pioneered in Sweden, this approach considers prostitution as inherently oppressive and seeks to tackle the dynamics of supply and demand by criminalizing purchasers and offering support to sellers who are regarded as victims. Against recent calls from both the European Parliament and an All Party Parliamentary Group on prostitution to universalize this model, we urge caution against moving any further in this direction. Our argument is informed, not only by critical accounts of the ‘Nordic model’, but also by emerging research which highlights the negative effects of recent criminal and ‘therapeutic’ interventions in England and Wales that have already attempted to reduce the demand and supply of commercial sex: the strict liability offence of paying for sexual services of a prostitute subject to exploitation and Engagement and Support Orders (ESOs) for on-street sex workers. We offer both normative insights and draw upon the findings of the first empirical study of ESOs, in order to highlight the problems that emerge when the complexities of commercial sexual exchange are reduced into a binary of ‘victims and victimizers’ to be saved or corrected by criminal justice sanctioned initiatives. In conclusion, we argue for a more productive use of the criminal law that complements rather than eclipses the wider social justice concerns in this arena.
LanguageEnglish
Pages608-626
Number of pages19
JournalCriminology and Criminal Justice
Volume14
Issue number5
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Nov 2014

Fingerprint

prostitution
supply
European Parliament
demand
criminal law
liability
social justice
exploitation
Sweden
justice
offense
worker
Group

Keywords

  • engagement and support orders
  • policy
  • prostitution
  • social inclusion
  • strict liability

Cite this

@article{c0ab908af83c4713b4349555a09df3bf,
title = "A critical account of a 'creeping neo-abolitionism': regulating prostitution in England and Wales",
abstract = "An increasingly dominant neo-abolitionist perspective on the issue of prostitution is currently taking hold across Europe. Pioneered in Sweden, this approach considers prostitution as inherently oppressive and seeks to tackle the dynamics of supply and demand by criminalizing purchasers and offering support to sellers who are regarded as victims. Against recent calls from both the European Parliament and an All Party Parliamentary Group on prostitution to universalize this model, we urge caution against moving any further in this direction. Our argument is informed, not only by critical accounts of the ‘Nordic model’, but also by emerging research which highlights the negative effects of recent criminal and ‘therapeutic’ interventions in England and Wales that have already attempted to reduce the demand and supply of commercial sex: the strict liability offence of paying for sexual services of a prostitute subject to exploitation and Engagement and Support Orders (ESOs) for on-street sex workers. We offer both normative insights and draw upon the findings of the first empirical study of ESOs, in order to highlight the problems that emerge when the complexities of commercial sexual exchange are reduced into a binary of ‘victims and victimizers’ to be saved or corrected by criminal justice sanctioned initiatives. In conclusion, we argue for a more productive use of the criminal law that complements rather than eclipses the wider social justice concerns in this arena.",
keywords = "engagement and support orders, policy, prostitution, social inclusion, strict liability",
author = "Jane Scoular and Anna Carline",
note = "Copyright {\circledC} 2014 SAGE Publications",
year = "2014",
month = "11",
doi = "10.1177/1748895814543534",
language = "English",
volume = "14",
pages = "608--626",
journal = "Criminology and Criminal Justice",
issn = "1748-8958",
number = "5",

}

A critical account of a 'creeping neo-abolitionism' : regulating prostitution in England and Wales. / Scoular, Jane; Carline, Anna.

In: Criminology and Criminal Justice, Vol. 14, No. 5, 11.2014, p. 608-626.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticle

TY - JOUR

T1 - A critical account of a 'creeping neo-abolitionism'

T2 - Criminology and Criminal Justice

AU - Scoular, Jane

AU - Carline, Anna

N1 - Copyright © 2014 SAGE Publications

PY - 2014/11

Y1 - 2014/11

N2 - An increasingly dominant neo-abolitionist perspective on the issue of prostitution is currently taking hold across Europe. Pioneered in Sweden, this approach considers prostitution as inherently oppressive and seeks to tackle the dynamics of supply and demand by criminalizing purchasers and offering support to sellers who are regarded as victims. Against recent calls from both the European Parliament and an All Party Parliamentary Group on prostitution to universalize this model, we urge caution against moving any further in this direction. Our argument is informed, not only by critical accounts of the ‘Nordic model’, but also by emerging research which highlights the negative effects of recent criminal and ‘therapeutic’ interventions in England and Wales that have already attempted to reduce the demand and supply of commercial sex: the strict liability offence of paying for sexual services of a prostitute subject to exploitation and Engagement and Support Orders (ESOs) for on-street sex workers. We offer both normative insights and draw upon the findings of the first empirical study of ESOs, in order to highlight the problems that emerge when the complexities of commercial sexual exchange are reduced into a binary of ‘victims and victimizers’ to be saved or corrected by criminal justice sanctioned initiatives. In conclusion, we argue for a more productive use of the criminal law that complements rather than eclipses the wider social justice concerns in this arena.

AB - An increasingly dominant neo-abolitionist perspective on the issue of prostitution is currently taking hold across Europe. Pioneered in Sweden, this approach considers prostitution as inherently oppressive and seeks to tackle the dynamics of supply and demand by criminalizing purchasers and offering support to sellers who are regarded as victims. Against recent calls from both the European Parliament and an All Party Parliamentary Group on prostitution to universalize this model, we urge caution against moving any further in this direction. Our argument is informed, not only by critical accounts of the ‘Nordic model’, but also by emerging research which highlights the negative effects of recent criminal and ‘therapeutic’ interventions in England and Wales that have already attempted to reduce the demand and supply of commercial sex: the strict liability offence of paying for sexual services of a prostitute subject to exploitation and Engagement and Support Orders (ESOs) for on-street sex workers. We offer both normative insights and draw upon the findings of the first empirical study of ESOs, in order to highlight the problems that emerge when the complexities of commercial sexual exchange are reduced into a binary of ‘victims and victimizers’ to be saved or corrected by criminal justice sanctioned initiatives. In conclusion, we argue for a more productive use of the criminal law that complements rather than eclipses the wider social justice concerns in this arena.

KW - engagement and support orders

KW - policy

KW - prostitution

KW - social inclusion

KW - strict liability

UR - http://crj.sagepub.com/

U2 - 10.1177/1748895814543534

DO - 10.1177/1748895814543534

M3 - Article

VL - 14

SP - 608

EP - 626

JO - Criminology and Criminal Justice

JF - Criminology and Criminal Justice

SN - 1748-8958

IS - 5

ER -