A comparison of design options for offshore HVDC networks through a sequential Monte-Carlo reliability analysis

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

Abstract

There is growing interest in developing offshore HVDC networks to connect both offshore wind power and provide interconnection between regions. There are a number of technology, topology and protection options available to developers each with varying levels of design complexity, capital cost and system redundancy. This paper highlights some of the available options and outlines a methodology for investigating the performance of a number of these through an investigation of their reliability against a lifetime of expected fault conditions, principally through a calculation of the expected level of curtailed energy associated with each network design. A number of case studies are investigated to provide a comparison between options including designs with and without HVDC circuit breakers and with varying levels of interconnection and system redundancy.
The paper shows that there are potentially significant benefits in terms of reduction in curtailed energy through use of redundant paths for power transmission in the network design and that these can in certain cases outweigh the increased capital expenditure associated with their implementation. An investigation into the need case for HVDC circuit breakers is carried out through a comparison with an alternative sectionalised HVDC network topology and the impact on system reliability is found to be negligible in comparison to the cost of the breakers. Offshore network reliability is also found to be highly sensitive to input assumptions for failure and repair rates and the variability within the results was found to be large meaning it could be difficult to accurately predict the reliability of future offshore network implementations.
LanguageEnglish
Pages1-10
Number of pages10
Publication statusPublished - 10 Mar 2014
EventEuropean Wind Energy Association 2014 Annual Conference - Barcelona, Spain
Duration: 10 Mar 201413 Mar 2014

Conference

ConferenceEuropean Wind Energy Association 2014 Annual Conference
Abbreviated titleEWEA 2014
CountrySpain
CityBarcelona
Period10/03/1413/03/14

Fingerprint

Reliability analysis
Electric circuit breakers
Redundancy
Topology
Power transmission
Wind power
Costs
Repair

Keywords

  • reliability
  • HVDC
  • offshore network

Cite this

MacIver, C., Bell, K. R. W., & Nedic, D. P. (2014). A comparison of design options for offshore HVDC networks through a sequential Monte-Carlo reliability analysis. 1-10. Paper presented at European Wind Energy Association 2014 Annual Conference, Barcelona, Spain.
MacIver, C. ; Bell, K. R. W. ; Nedic, D.P. / A comparison of design options for offshore HVDC networks through a sequential Monte-Carlo reliability analysis. Paper presented at European Wind Energy Association 2014 Annual Conference, Barcelona, Spain.10 p.
@conference{bca438c496e64dc582ec3ada08fdc449,
title = "A comparison of design options for offshore HVDC networks through a sequential Monte-Carlo reliability analysis",
abstract = "There is growing interest in developing offshore HVDC networks to connect both offshore wind power and provide interconnection between regions. There are a number of technology, topology and protection options available to developers each with varying levels of design complexity, capital cost and system redundancy. This paper highlights some of the available options and outlines a methodology for investigating the performance of a number of these through an investigation of their reliability against a lifetime of expected fault conditions, principally through a calculation of the expected level of curtailed energy associated with each network design. A number of case studies are investigated to provide a comparison between options including designs with and without HVDC circuit breakers and with varying levels of interconnection and system redundancy.The paper shows that there are potentially significant benefits in terms of reduction in curtailed energy through use of redundant paths for power transmission in the network design and that these can in certain cases outweigh the increased capital expenditure associated with their implementation. An investigation into the need case for HVDC circuit breakers is carried out through a comparison with an alternative sectionalised HVDC network topology and the impact on system reliability is found to be negligible in comparison to the cost of the breakers. Offshore network reliability is also found to be highly sensitive to input assumptions for failure and repair rates and the variability within the results was found to be large meaning it could be difficult to accurately predict the reliability of future offshore network implementations.",
keywords = "reliability, HVDC, offshore network",
author = "C. MacIver and Bell, {K. R. W.} and D.P. Nedic",
year = "2014",
month = "3",
day = "10",
language = "English",
pages = "1--10",
note = "European Wind Energy Association 2014 Annual Conference, EWEA 2014 ; Conference date: 10-03-2014 Through 13-03-2014",

}

MacIver, C, Bell, KRW & Nedic, DP 2014, 'A comparison of design options for offshore HVDC networks through a sequential Monte-Carlo reliability analysis' Paper presented at European Wind Energy Association 2014 Annual Conference, Barcelona, Spain, 10/03/14 - 13/03/14, pp. 1-10.

A comparison of design options for offshore HVDC networks through a sequential Monte-Carlo reliability analysis. / MacIver, C.; Bell, K. R. W.; Nedic, D.P.

2014. 1-10 Paper presented at European Wind Energy Association 2014 Annual Conference, Barcelona, Spain.

Research output: Contribution to conferencePaper

TY - CONF

T1 - A comparison of design options for offshore HVDC networks through a sequential Monte-Carlo reliability analysis

AU - MacIver, C.

AU - Bell, K. R. W.

AU - Nedic, D.P.

PY - 2014/3/10

Y1 - 2014/3/10

N2 - There is growing interest in developing offshore HVDC networks to connect both offshore wind power and provide interconnection between regions. There are a number of technology, topology and protection options available to developers each with varying levels of design complexity, capital cost and system redundancy. This paper highlights some of the available options and outlines a methodology for investigating the performance of a number of these through an investigation of their reliability against a lifetime of expected fault conditions, principally through a calculation of the expected level of curtailed energy associated with each network design. A number of case studies are investigated to provide a comparison between options including designs with and without HVDC circuit breakers and with varying levels of interconnection and system redundancy.The paper shows that there are potentially significant benefits in terms of reduction in curtailed energy through use of redundant paths for power transmission in the network design and that these can in certain cases outweigh the increased capital expenditure associated with their implementation. An investigation into the need case for HVDC circuit breakers is carried out through a comparison with an alternative sectionalised HVDC network topology and the impact on system reliability is found to be negligible in comparison to the cost of the breakers. Offshore network reliability is also found to be highly sensitive to input assumptions for failure and repair rates and the variability within the results was found to be large meaning it could be difficult to accurately predict the reliability of future offshore network implementations.

AB - There is growing interest in developing offshore HVDC networks to connect both offshore wind power and provide interconnection between regions. There are a number of technology, topology and protection options available to developers each with varying levels of design complexity, capital cost and system redundancy. This paper highlights some of the available options and outlines a methodology for investigating the performance of a number of these through an investigation of their reliability against a lifetime of expected fault conditions, principally through a calculation of the expected level of curtailed energy associated with each network design. A number of case studies are investigated to provide a comparison between options including designs with and without HVDC circuit breakers and with varying levels of interconnection and system redundancy.The paper shows that there are potentially significant benefits in terms of reduction in curtailed energy through use of redundant paths for power transmission in the network design and that these can in certain cases outweigh the increased capital expenditure associated with their implementation. An investigation into the need case for HVDC circuit breakers is carried out through a comparison with an alternative sectionalised HVDC network topology and the impact on system reliability is found to be negligible in comparison to the cost of the breakers. Offshore network reliability is also found to be highly sensitive to input assumptions for failure and repair rates and the variability within the results was found to be large meaning it could be difficult to accurately predict the reliability of future offshore network implementations.

KW - reliability

KW - HVDC

KW - offshore network

UR - http://www.ewea.org/annual2014/conference/programme/

M3 - Paper

SP - 1

EP - 10

ER -

MacIver C, Bell KRW, Nedic DP. A comparison of design options for offshore HVDC networks through a sequential Monte-Carlo reliability analysis. 2014. Paper presented at European Wind Energy Association 2014 Annual Conference, Barcelona, Spain.